Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Intraperitoneal drain placement and outcomes after elective colorectal surgery: international matched, prospective, cohort study
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Background
Many surgeons routinely place intraperitoneal drains after elective colorectal surgery. However, enhanced recovery after surgery guidelines recommend against their routine use owing to a lack of clear clinical benefit. This study aimed to describe international variation in intraperitoneal drain placement and the safety of this practice.
Methods
COMPASS (COMPlicAted intra-abdominal collectionS after colorectal Surgery) was a prospective, international, cohort study which enrolled consecutive adults undergoing elective colorectal surgery (February to March 2020). The primary outcome was the rate of intraperitoneal drain placement. Secondary outcomes included: rate and time to diagnosis of postoperative intraperitoneal collections; rate of surgical site infections (SSIs); time to discharge; and 30-day major postoperative complications (Clavien–Dindo grade at least III). After propensity score matching, multivariable logistic regression and Cox proportional hazards regression were used to estimate the independent association of the secondary outcomes with drain placement.
Results
Overall, 1805 patients from 22 countries were included (798 women, 44.2 per cent; median age 67.0 years). The drain insertion rate was 51.9 per cent (937 patients). After matching, drains were not associated with reduced rates (odds ratio (OR) 1.33, 95 per cent c.i. 0.79 to 2.23; P = 0.287) or earlier detection (hazard ratio (HR) 0.87, 0.33 to 2.31; P = 0.780) of collections. Although not associated with worse major postoperative complications (OR 1.09, 0.68 to 1.75; P = 0.709), drains were associated with delayed hospital discharge (HR 0.58, 0.52 to 0.66; P < 0.001) and an increased risk of SSIs (OR 2.47, 1.50 to 4.05; P < 0.001).
Conclusion
Intraperitoneal drain placement after elective colorectal surgery is not associated with earlier detection of postoperative collections, but prolongs hospital stay and increases SSI risk.
Oxford University Press (OUP)
A Sgrò
R Blanco-Colino
WUR Ahmed
N Brindl
RR Gujjuri
P Lapolla
EC Mills
S Pérez-Ajates
AS Soares
C Varghese
W Xu
KA McLean
SJ Chapman
E Espín-Basany
JC Glasbey
A Mihaljevic
D Nepogodiev
F Pata
G Pellino
P Pockney
NN Dudi-Venkata
N Egoroff
I Ludbrook
K Raubenheimer
T Richards
P Pockney
S Delibegovic
M Salibasic
T Amjad
N Brindl
C Dörr-Harim
N Gedeon
J Gsenger
A Mihaljevic
M Tachezy
S Bini
G Gallo
A Gori
P Lapolla
F Pata
G Pellino
A Picciariello
M Podda
C Riboni
MJ Machatschek
A Nguyen
M Jakubauskas
M Kryzauskas
T Poskus
SZ Kuiper
J Wang
CI Wells
IP Bissett
KM Augestad
I Steinholt
AS Soares
BN Vieira
J Juloski
O Anabitarte Bautista
Y El Kasmy El Kasmy
S Pérez-Ajates
P Martín-Borregón
M Ossola Revilla
E Espín-Basany
S Van Straten
MK Aktas
BE Baki
WUR Ahmed
M Akhbari
D Baker
S Bhatia
S Brown
W Cambridge
SK Kamarajah
RA Khaw
O Kouli
KA McLean
EC Mills
V Murray
I Trout
I Yasin
Y Wong J
H Reyhani
KHF Wong
R Pancharatnam
WL Chia
A Walmsley
A Hassane
D Saeed
B Wang
B Walters
Z Nowinka
A Alsaif
M Mirza
K Foster
J Luu
P Kakodkar
JT Hughes
T Yogarajah
A Antypas
A Rahman
M Bradbury
M McLarnon
S Nagi
AM Riad
M Erotocritou
H Kyriacou
V Kaminskaite
S Alfadhel
Q Fatimah Hussain
A Handa
C Massy-Westropp
S Čustović
R Dimov
H Mughal
M Slavchev
T Ivanov
N Gouvas
A Hegazi
P Kocián
MD Kjaer
A Mark-Christensen
D Papakonstantinou
N Machairas
T Triantafyllou
Z Garoufalia
D Korkolis
A Castaldi
A Picciariello
S Giaccari
G Spolverato
G Pagano
M Milone
G Turri
F Colombo
E Cucinotta
G Poillucci
P Lapolla
S Bini
T Perra
R Tutino
F Belia
D Coletta
A Belli
D Rega
P Cianci
G Pirozzolo
M Di Lena
F Perrone
A Giani
F Lovisetto
M Grassia
NS Pipitone Federico
F Ferrara
A Biancafarina
N Tamini
G Sinibaldi
F Tuminello
R Galleano
D Sasia
L Bragaglia
A de Manzoni Garberini
A Pesce
F Cassaro
P Venturelli
A Gori
GL Canu
G Esposito
M Campanelli
R Cardia
M Ricciardiello
A Sagnotta
G Canonico
G De Marco
A Cappiello
E Pinotti
F Carlei
G Lisi
G Bagaglini
G Gallo
A Nguyen
MJ Machatschek
M Farrugia
EM Meima - van Praag
C Monteiro
M Pereira
P Botelho
A Quigley
A O'Neill
L Gaule
L Crone
A Arnold
F Grama
A Beuca
I Tulina
A Litvin
J Juloski
A Panyko
ME Ossola
J Trujillo Díaz
JM Marín Santos
E Alonso Batanero
S Gortázar de las Casas
C Soldevila Verdeguer
E Colás-Ruiz
I Talal El-Abur
M García Domínguez
M Delorme
M Sauvain
BB Ozmen
MK Aktas
BB Ozkan
F Calikoglu
S Kural
F Zafer
Y Kaya
A Yalcinkaya
K Kargici
MD Tepe
OC Tatar
E Kabadayi
A Yıldırım
D Hurmuzlu
K Korkmaz
P Sharma
R Troller
N Hagan
J Mooney
A Light
M Tansey
D Bhojwani
RM McGing
A Mallon
M Fadel
C Spilsbury
R James
S O’Brien
A Isaac
S Balasubramanya
H Sadik
T Gala
JY Chen
B Turner
E Goh
K Hassan
M Karam
P Mason
N Tzoumas
T Noton
JK Seehra
N Ahmed
R Motiwale
V Tanna
A Argyriou
SK Bylapudi
N Grace
S Latif
A Hounat
JS Kiam
M Zaidi
K Elsamani
C Hughes
A Suresh
LOH Sinan
D El-Dalil
EJM Khoo
EE Salim
D Stark
N Minhas
G Fowler
E Rees
I Giudiceandrea
A Bardon
P Jayawardena
N Dieseru
A Murphy
C Yates
K Ziolkowska
A Rafie
F Khoda
M Okocha
T Ashdown
P Vitish-Sharma
J Gilliland
S Toh
K Jones
A Devine
A Berry
S McDonnell
J Olivier
G Richardson
HJ Lim
P Vitish-Sharma
N Slim
K Elsayeh
T Sammour
R Dimov
A Sarpanov
N Belev
D Dimitrov
N Gouvas
T Dušek
P Kocián
MD Kjaer
A Mark-Christensen
V Ntomi
GC Sotiropoulos
D Theodorou
N Nikiteas
D Balalis
C Antropoli
DF Altomare
G Luglio
GD De Palma
C Pedrazzani
E Cucinotta
L Simonelli
S Brozzetti
A Porcu
M Massani
GL Grazi
F Izzo
P Delrio
E Restini
G Pirozzolo
G Chetta
G Lantone
G Ferrari
F Lovisetto
A Lucchi
M De Prizio
N Tamini
G Sinibaldi
R Galleano
G Caristo
F Borghi
N Petrucciani
A de Manzoni Garberini
C Huscher
G Cocorullo
V Tonini
F Medas
M Podda
G Sica
N Cillara
M Ricciardiello
A Anastasi
G De Marco
F Bianco
A Giuliani
M Carlini
F Selvaggi
G Sammarco
A Ozoliņš
A Malašonoks
P Andrejevic
P Tanis
A van de Ven
M Gerhards
B Ribeiro da Silva
A Silva
MJ Lima
D Kavanagh
N McCawley
D Kavanagh
F Grama
V Bintintan
A Karamarkovic
A Panyko
G Sanz Ortega
B De Andrés-Asenjo
C Nevado García
LJ García Flórez
JJ Segura-Sampedro
E Colás-Ruiz
JL Blas Laina
L Ponchietti
P Buchwald
E Gialamas
V Ozben
A Rencuzogullari
İE Gecim
Y Altinel
O Isik
T Yoldas
A Isik
S Leventoğlu
MS Ertürk
A Guner
SA Güler
W Attaallah
M Ugur
GS Özbalcı
H Marzook
N Eardley
S Smolarek
R Morgan
C Roxburgh
AK Lala
Y Salama
B Singh
A Khanna
M Evans
I Shaikh
K Maradi Thippeswamy
B Appleton
S Moug
I Smith
N Smart
P Shah
G Williams
G Khera
A Goede
M Varcada
C Parmar
S Duff
R Hargest
P Marriott
D Speake
A Ben Sassi
A Goede
B Furfaro
D Daudu
N Golijanin
WY Yek
G Capasso
LT Mansour
N Niu
W Seow
A Hamidovic
E Kulovic
E Letic
A Aljić
E Letic
M Helez
A Banji-Kelan
N Dimitrova
P Kavradjieva
V Ivanov
A Jukaku
D Hadzhiev
H Mughal
M Slavchev
A Gabarski
M Karamanliev
P Vladova
S Iliev
T Yotsov
Η Ευσταθίου
K Vetsa
N Gouvas
O Stavrinidou
P Papatheodorou
T Liassides
T Georgiou
A Hegazi
M Al Nassrallah
R Altaf
T Amjad
M Negametzyanov
T Dušek
D Zagibová
F Foltys
H Štefanová
A Paspala
D Papakonstantinou
G Bompetsi
T Sidiropoulos
GC Sotiropoulos
N Machairas
P Stamopoulos
A Triantafyllou
C Theodoropoulos
A Kimpizi
D Theodorou
T Triantafyllou
T Palyvou
A Charalabopoulos
A Syllaios
D Schizas
E Liatsou
E Baili
I Vagios
N Tomara
S Davakis
D Balalis
A Palumbo
A Castaldi
F Foroni
A Picciariello
DF Altomare
R Dibra
V Papagni
A Urbani
E Rossin
G Nezi
P Romano
A Amendola
E Esposito
M Manigrasso
P Anoldo
S Vertaldi
G Gecchele
G Turri
ZS Sabrina
C Guerci
F Cammarata
GMB Lamperti
G Zaffaroni
L Benuzzi
L Ferrario
M Cigognini
C Mazzeo
G Badessi
G Pintabona
A Fassari
A Mingoli
B Cirillo
C D’Alterio
G Brachini
M Tancredi
M Zambon
M Aulicino
P Sapienza
P Lapolla
P Liberatore
S Bini
AM Scanu
CF Feo
T Perra
A Iacomino
M Massani
P Pelizzo
R Tutino
S Rossi
SA Vigna
U Grossi
V Grillo
A Agnes
CA Schena
F Belia
G Marincola
A Oddi
B Perotti
D Coletta
V Mario
P Perri
S Zazza
A Aversano
D Scala
K Di Lauro
M Leongito
M Piccirillo
R Patrone
E Restini
P Cianci
S Capuzzolo
C Vignotto
G Pirozzolo
QR Bao
C Giuseppe
E Angarano
M Di Lena
F Marino
F Perrone
F Pezzolla
G Gigante
C Magistro
J Crippa
M Maspero
P Carnevali
F Lovisetto
R Trapani
S Zonta
L Agostinelli
L Vittori
L Romeo
E Doria
F Farnesi
R Danna
F Ferrara
A Biancafarina
E Andolfi
GA Pellicano’
M Angelini
M Scricciolo
C Zanframundo
C Ciulli
L Ripamonti
L Cigagna
M Oldani
N Tamini
A Larcinese
D Rossi
E Picone
G Crescentini
F Tuminello
G Caristo
A Marano
D Sasia
M Migliore
MC Giuffrida
S Palagi
V Testa
A Borrello
A Lucarini
E Garofalo
G Canali
L Bragaglia
P Orlandi
A de Manzoni Garberini
F Nervegna
F Marchegiani
I Damoli
A Licata
C Trovato
F Cassaro
F Alicata
F Sardo
M Milazzo
B Randisi
DM Dominici
G Cocorullo
P Venturelli
A Gori
L Sartarelli
M Zanni
A Pisanu
C Soddu
D Delogu
E Erdas
F Campus
F Cappellacci
F Casti
G Esposito
J Marcialis
J Atzeni
MG Podda
B Sensi
G Sica
M Franceschilli
M Campanelli
V Bellato
A Cannavera
G Putzu
N Cillara
FF di Mola
M Ricciardiello
A Sagnotta
B Picardi
L Solinas
M Loponte
S Rossi del Monte
S Rossi
C Di Martino
C Linari
G Spagni
L Capezzuoli
L Tirloni
T Nelli
A Caridi
C Elter
M Camassa
S D'Amico
T Bargellini
A Cappiello
F Bianco
P Incollingo
E Pinotti
M Montuori
F Maffione
L Romano
S Valiyeva
D Spoletini
G Lisi
M Carlini
F Menegon Tasselli
G Pellino
G Bagaglini
G Sciaudone
L Selvaggi
MP Menna
G De Paola
G Sammarco
S Fulginiti
A Truskovs
C Weiß
G Saknītis
JTR Rauscher
J Larnovskis
M Jeyarajan-Davidsson
A Malašonoks
D Nitisa
MJ Machatschek
N Gille
SC Reiser
M Farrugia
MHK Roshan
P Andrejevic
C Leseman
P Tanis
A van de Ven
J Chen
AS van Dalen
C Top
M Gerhards
R Detering
C Matos
C Monteiro
C Silva
D Pinto
J Mendes
J Couto
M Leite
C Velez
M Damasio Cotovio
AM Cinza
M Pereira
R Pedroso de Lima
P Botelho
A Quigley
E Boyle
HW Yang
I Banerjee
S Rahmat
Z Afzal
A O'Neill
C Reid
F Dumitrascu
JA Croyle
K Gressmann
N Cullen
A Graham
A Nasehi
C Montano King
L Gaule
B Martin
C Stokell
L Crone
N Sanderson
R Farnan
S jassim
A Arnold
B Chan
K Chua Vi Long
N Kaka
S Pandey
WX Neo
A Chitul
C Bezede
F Grama
A Beuca
D Cincilei
A David
M Blaga
SN Blaga
V Fagarasan
I Tulina
M Khetagurova
S Rodimov
A Kapustina
A Mekhralyzade
M Zabiyaka
J Juloski
U Janković
V Cuk
A Panyko
M Hájska
M Dubovský
M Hrošová
N Ferancikova
E Camarero Rodríguez
F Laguna Alcántara
J Adarraga
C Jezieniecki
M Ruiz Soriano
T Gómez Sanz
A Suarez
C Sánchez García
JM Marín Santos
E Alonso Batanero
I Cifrian Canales
J Llosa Pérez
M Merayo
A Urbieta
A Gegúndez Simón
JF Tone
J Gazo Martínez
M Vicario Bravo
N Chavarrias
A Gil Catalán
A Oseira
B Villalonga
C Soldevila Verdeguer
S Jeri
E Colás-Ruiz
J Perez Calvo
A Nogués
B Cros
C Yánez
I Talal El-Abur
JL Blas Laina
A Utrilla Fornals
M Roldón Golet
M García Domínguez
P Colsa
T Gimenez Maurel
M Delorme
P Buchwald
T Axmarker
E Gialamas
M Chevallay
TV Pham
BB Ozmen
EK Sel
V Ozben
C Atar
MK Aktas
M Aba
BB Ozkan
M Sarkin
YM Akkaya
AG Durmaz
F Calikoglu
HF Gullu
A Boğa
A Aktaş
B Bakar
MT Demirel
S Kural
X Hysejni
F Zafer
M Taser
OR Guzel
O Bozbiyik
A Isik
D Özen
M Ölmez
Y Kaya
B Uyar
E Gülçek
GS Kayacan
N Atıcı
OF Gul
S Altiner
B Ibis
S Altunsu
T Banaz
C Diler
I Demirbas
MA Usta
O Erkul
R Orman
S Salih
NZ Utkan
OC Tatar
SA Güler
C Acil
E Ozgur
M Maddahali
AB Turhan
AB Eskici
B Ular
M Doğru
OU Öztürk
ER Arslan
A Panahi Sharif
D Hurmuzlu
E Dikmen
J Ates
R Bircan
T Cavus
AE Sever
B Balak
E Duman
K Korkmaz
L Altay
O Emanet
F Cullen
JY Tan
P Sharma
A Nathan
A Rottenberg
CY Williams
CG Mitrofan
D Xu
JH Bawa
P Morris
R Troller
D Gordon
G Richmond
JC Hui
N Hagan
O Ighomereho
R Rocks
S McCabe
A Fitzpatrick
J Mooney
J Nicoletti
JC Hui
L Auterson
N Darrah
VWY Soh
A Light
CS Ong
M Utukuri
C Gallagher
LM Stuart
M Hipolito
N Douglas
R Ghazal
G Parris
J Catchpole
M Tansey
M Bryden
S Jamal
Z Karim
C Lyon-Dean
D Bhojwani
G Rowley
KS Lee
O Whitehurst
A Mirza
F Sheikh
H Yousaf
J Bilbao
R Sinclair
S Takar
H Kressel
RM McGing
V Chan
A Mallon
K Schack
R Osborne
S Baldemor
S Smyth
S Gilmour
A Ting
I Bozonelou
P Saunders
QA Qhaireel Anwar
R Tirimanna
S Jauhari
A Gardener
B Walker
C Spilsbury
C Wenban
H Reddy
R Conway-Jones
S Loganathan
A Clynch
C James
E Matey
F Cameron
R James
W Roberts
A Gicquel
C Milliken
J Forbes
P Rubinchik
S O’Brien
A Isaac
A Azmi
C Hawkes
L Cornett
P Adarkwah
R McConville
S O'Hara
C Tijare
J Parkes
L Yao
R Ahmad
S Balasubramanya
U Shafiq
A Mhaisalkar
A Gurung
H Sadik
K de Stadler
S Elias
T Thomas
A Madras
A Jani
HK Daler
KS Tong
SS Sundaralingam
Z Nowinka
A Szal
A Khan
C O'Sullivan
E Baker
J Joseph-Gubral
T Gala
JY Chen
B Turner
E Hadley
R Trivedi
E Igwelaezoh
E Goh
H Barton
W Allison
W Hurst
F Alam
I Parkes
K Hassan
M Jamshaid
N Azizan
T Burgher
A Afzal
I Eltilib
M Zahid
O Sadiq
A Lloyd
P Mason
R Ho
A Brazukas
CH Li
M Kamdar
MN Mohamed Nazeer
N Tzoumas
A Mighiu
D Kim
L Wilkins
L Kuo
R Conway-Jones
T Rafe
T Noton
D Maduka
H Cheema
K Farag
M Mirza
M Abdellatif
R Nzewi
A Kruczynska
H Grasselli
M Yousuff
N Ahmed
R Bassi
AK Mann
J Chopra
M Shaikh
P Sharma
S D Sa
V Tsimplis
A Ghanchi
E Skene
K Asim
M Zaheer
S Chan
H Dalton
K Gibbons
O Adderley
I Chukwujindu
I Jayasuriya
K Sivanu
M Borumand
SK Bylapudi
G Chick
I Bridges
J Tomlin
J McKenna
N Nandra
N Grace
C Grieco
FF Quek
R Mercer
S Latif
T Brankin-Frisby
A Sattar
A Aslam
E Edelsten
S Shafi
T Kouli
V Ford
F Gurung
JS Kiam
M Fernandes
N Deader
R Ponniah
S Jamieson
A Davies
J Taubwurcel
MT Aung
R Desai
S Begum
T Jamadar
A Kangatharan
B Rzeszowski
C Ho
SHK Yap
M Prendergast
R Sethi
A Duku
C Lowe
J Bray
K Elsamani
M Ghobrial
V Nichita
A Wagstaff
C Hughes
E Rengasamy
F Abu Hassan
H Mahmood
N Savill
S Shah
T Almeida
LOH Sinan
A Edwards
A Antypas
B Catchpole
D El-Dalil
Z Halford
A Carmichael
EJM Khoo
H Alsusa
EE Salim
M Boyd
C Reid
D Stark
J Williams
J Feyi-Waboso
M Patel
Z Zeidan
E Bailey
J Bapty
M Brazkiewicz
N Minhas
A Tremlett
G Fowler
H Pringle
S Mankal
V Kaminskaite
W Chung
E Rees
E Parry-Jones
K Anderson
A Mcforrester
A Stanley
A Hoather
H Wise
I Laid
I Giudiceandrea
J Scriven
A Braniste
A Wilson
L Le Blevec
N Pakunwanich
N Evans
HL Chong
C White
J Hunter
M Haque
P Vanalia
S Murdoch
T Choudhary
A McCann
A Harun
H Shah
N Dieseru
S Hunt
Y Shafiq
A Murphy
E Bickley-Morris
L Emms
M Dare
M Patel
Y Akula
C Yates
E Deliyannis
F Mayes
M Ellacott
Z Zagorac
A Farren
C Manning
C Hughed
EG Stewart
KH Lim
N Chohan
A Thaker
B Thompson
K Ziolkowska
D Ahari
E Burdekin
U Okwu
A Akintunde
F Lhaf
F Khoda
J Douthwaite
R Govindan
S Leelamanthep
E Gull
F Wright
L Dundas
M Okocha
N Mackdermott
T Burchi-Khairy
I Campbell
J Walsh
JY Yeo
S Meehan
D Banerjee
M Fu
M Kawka
T Ali
Z Hussain
C Thomas
H Ahmad
J Moroney
C Yick
R Risquet
D Ntuiabane
M Shimato
M Khan
S Ilangovan
NM Vaselli
R Smithers
R Uhanowita Marage
A Valnarov-Boulter
J Kayran
M Banerjee
N Parekh-Hill
A Hooper
J Bowen
R Jagdish
C Mcquoid
N Khan
R O Hare
S Jeffery
A Devine
A Zahid
C Elsworth
L Walter
S Dhillon
S Rao
A Anthony
A Ashaye
N Phillips
R Faderani
S Pengelly
S Choi
SY Kwak
YHL Lau
K Bagheri
R Pancharatnam
S McDonnell
DYC Ong
E Kerr
K Falconer
N Clancy
S Douglas
Y Zhang
F Greenfield
I Mutanga
J McAlinden
J Olivier
L Willis
A Adefolaju
H Agarwal
R Barter
G Harris
G Spencer
HJ Lim
MW Lee
T V Vadiveloo
G Herbert
J Moroney
C Yick
R Patel
R Risquet
M Shah
N Slim
S El Falaha
C Wong
C Soare
J Akram
K Elsayeh
L Bozhkova
Y Ma
UG Vo
HWN Tan
L Leto
MA Kamal
E Hadzhieva
P Krastev
P Tonchev
G Kokkinos
I Pozotou
D Sabbagh
J Votava
P Kocián
F St
N Koliakos
P Tsaparas
G Zografos
D Mantas
G Tsourouflis
E Fradelos
A Castaldi
G Trigiante
G Labellarte
G Resta
G Capelli
A D'Amore
V Verlingieri
T Campagnaro
A Maffioli
F Viscosi
C De Lucia
G Poillucci
S Meneghini
A Fancellu
M Colella
A Biondi
V De Peppo
U Pace
V Albino
D Gattulli
A Piangerelli
D Kalivaci
G Sisto
M Mazzola
A Caneparo
M Grassia
EG Lunghi
E Andolfi
LC Nespoli
M Angrisani
G Sinibaldi
A Langone
R Galleano
E Gelarda
E Virgilio
E Angelini
C Fornasier
S Asero
P Venturelli
E Filippone
F Frongia
PG Calò
V Bellato
P Panaccio
A Sagnotta
M Loponte
P Ipponi
S D'Amico
S Gili
A Giuliani
G Lisi
B Braccio
V Tiesi
K Stolcers
L Kokaine
V Novikovs
M Farrugia
L Capel
V Bastiaenen
H Heijmans
B Ribeiro da Silva
A Silva
P Botelho
S Henriques
SZ Gan
H Ramanayake
M Nolan
P Kakodkar
H Temperley
P Kakodkar
E Ciofic
A Beuca
BA Pop
M Kurtenkov
M Jovanović
M Vician
P Egea Arias
J Beltrán de Heredia
M Labalde Martinez
I De Santiago Alvarez
M Alvarez-Gallego
E Colás-Ruiz
I Talal El-Abur
JM Rodriguez Artigas
O Dwidar
HK Korkmaz
IC Eray
S Meriç
R Aydin
B Çetin
D Özen
A Yalcinkaya
BE Karaca
OF Kuyumcu
BE Baki
E Yüksel
TK Uprak
M Ugur
K Karabulut
E Kavukçu
A Mansor
R Troller
R Hackett
M Zammit-Maempel
R Sabaratnam
J Nicoletti
A Maan
I Ferarrio
L Dixon
H Halai
S Sethi
L Nelson
A Grassam-rowe
E Krishnan
D Deeny
M McKeever
A George Pandeth
P Dhavala
S Sreenivasan
G Sundaram Venkatesan
L Zhu
Z Atiyah
J Gregory
T Morey
Z Seymour
L Holdsworth
S Abdelmahmoud
J Bourhill
G Bisheet
J Shaw
K Kulkarni
P Kumarakulasingam
S Pillay
R Al-Habsi
G Kungwengwe
J Richards
K Davoudi
B Ibrahim
B Tailor
M Zayed
F Chen
S Bailey
S Sheefat
G Nawaz
R Pawar
S Marsh
ZH Sam
S Roy Bentley
C Simpson
J Hughes
Y Lim
R Ooi
WH Toh
P Mannion
A Lovett
A Kinčius
S Hussein
E Kirby
RG Beckett
J Salmon
A Rafie
T Glynn
SY Choo
S Lyons
D Browne
W Ravindran
S Ahmad
M Erotocritou
X Zhu
M Erotocritou
M Bradbury
J McNulty
L McCarthy
J Ng
Z Karmally
K McTeir
M Hanna
E Tan
S Namdeo
R Schembri
E Pusey
Title: Intraperitoneal drain placement and outcomes after elective colorectal surgery: international matched, prospective, cohort study
Description:
Abstract
Background
Many surgeons routinely place intraperitoneal drains after elective colorectal surgery.
However, enhanced recovery after surgery guidelines recommend against their routine use owing to a lack of clear clinical benefit.
This study aimed to describe international variation in intraperitoneal drain placement and the safety of this practice.
Methods
COMPASS (COMPlicAted intra-abdominal collectionS after colorectal Surgery) was a prospective, international, cohort study which enrolled consecutive adults undergoing elective colorectal surgery (February to March 2020).
The primary outcome was the rate of intraperitoneal drain placement.
Secondary outcomes included: rate and time to diagnosis of postoperative intraperitoneal collections; rate of surgical site infections (SSIs); time to discharge; and 30-day major postoperative complications (Clavien–Dindo grade at least III).
After propensity score matching, multivariable logistic regression and Cox proportional hazards regression were used to estimate the independent association of the secondary outcomes with drain placement.
Results
Overall, 1805 patients from 22 countries were included (798 women, 44.
2 per cent; median age 67.
0 years).
The drain insertion rate was 51.
9 per cent (937 patients).
After matching, drains were not associated with reduced rates (odds ratio (OR) 1.
33, 95 per cent c.
i.
0.
79 to 2.
23; P = 0.
287) or earlier detection (hazard ratio (HR) 0.
87, 0.
33 to 2.
31; P = 0.
780) of collections.
Although not associated with worse major postoperative complications (OR 1.
09, 0.
68 to 1.
75; P = 0.
709), drains were associated with delayed hospital discharge (HR 0.
58, 0.
52 to 0.
66; P < 0.
001) and an increased risk of SSIs (OR 2.
47, 1.
50 to 4.
05; P < 0.
001).
Conclusion
Intraperitoneal drain placement after elective colorectal surgery is not associated with earlier detection of postoperative collections, but prolongs hospital stay and increases SSI risk.
Related Results
Safety and efficacy of intraperitoneal drain placement after emergency colorectal surgery: An international, prospective cohort study
Safety and efficacy of intraperitoneal drain placement after emergency colorectal surgery: An international, prospective cohort study
AbstractAimIntraperitoneal drains are often placed during emergency colorectal surgery. However, there is a lack of evidence supporting their use. This study aimed to describe the ...
Management of COMPlicAted intra‐abdominal collectionS after colorectal Surgery (COMPASS): protocol for a multicentre, observational, prospective international study of drain placement practices in colorectal surgery
Management of COMPlicAted intra‐abdominal collectionS after colorectal Surgery (COMPASS): protocol for a multicentre, observational, prospective international study of drain placement practices in colorectal surgery
AbstractAimPostoperative drains have historically been used for the prevention and early detection of intra‐abdominal collections. However, current evidence suggests that prophylac...
Cohort studies
Cohort studies
A cohort study is one in which the outcome (usually disease status) is ascertained for groups of individuals defined on the basis of their exposure. At the time exposure status is ...
Abstract A13: Applied the proteomics characteristics to detect the inherited colorectal adenomas
Abstract A13: Applied the proteomics characteristics to detect the inherited colorectal adenomas
Abstract
Introduction: Current study found that about one-third of the incidence of colorectal cancer have genetic related. Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer...
Perbedaan cost-effectiveness pengangkatan drain kurang dari 3 hari dengan lebih dari 3 hari pada modified radical mastectomy
Perbedaan cost-effectiveness pengangkatan drain kurang dari 3 hari dengan lebih dari 3 hari pada modified radical mastectomy
Introduction: Modified radical mastectomy (MRM) is a therapeutic choice for operable breast cancer. The most frequent post-surgery complication is seroma formation, and this can be...
Intraperitoneal-Free Cancer Cells Represent a Major Prognostic Factor in Colorectal Peritoneal Carcinomatosis
Intraperitoneal-Free Cancer Cells Represent a Major Prognostic Factor in Colorectal Peritoneal Carcinomatosis
BACKGROUND:
Intraperitoneal-free cancer cells are considered as an important prognostic tool in gastric and ovarian cancer. However, their significance in colorectal ca...
A comparative study of laparoscopic cholecystectomy with and without abdominal drain
A comparative study of laparoscopic cholecystectomy with and without abdominal drain
Background: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) has been considered the Gold-standard for the management of benign gallbladder disease. With increasing surgeon experience and advance...
A comparative study of laparoscopic cholecystectomy with and without abdominal drain
A comparative study of laparoscopic cholecystectomy with and without abdominal drain
Background: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) has been considered the Gold-standard for the management of benign gallbladder disease. With increasing surgeon experience and advance...

