Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Blood Glucose Measurement in Rabbits - Performance Evaluation of Portable Glucometers
View through CrossRef
Background: Blood glucose level measurement plays an important role in the diagnosis and prognosis of different clinical conditions in rabbits. Portable glucometers offer a quick and affordable tool to measure blood glucose. However, not all commercially available glucometers are suitable for this purpose in different animal species and in different clinical conditions. This study aimed to assess the performance of 4 portable glucometers compared to a biochemical analyzer using blood samples from both healthy and sick rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus).
Material,s Methods & Results: Blood samples were collected via jugular venipuncture from 51 rabbits. The blood glucose concentration was measured using 3 human (FO= FreeStyle Optium Neo®; AA= Accu-chek® Active; IS= Injex Sens II®) and 1 veterinarian (PGM= Wellion Vet®, Gluco Calea) glucometer, configured for dog (WD), cat (WC), and horse (WH). The results obtained from the glucometers were compared to those from the laboratory biochemical analyzer in wet biochemistry, using Spearman correlation, intraclass correlation coefficient, Bland-Altman analysis, error grid analysis and total error analysis. Blood glucose concentrations were underestimated in the human devices evaluated and overestimated in the veterinary device. Bland-Altman analysis revealed significant systematic differences in 3 of the 4 devices tested. Total error above 20% was observed in normoglycemic samples from 2 devices (FO; and PGM - WC= cat code) and in hyperglycemic samples from 1 glucometer (AA). All glucometers showed glycemic results within Zone A and B of the error grid analysis, although a glucometer (FO) present most of the results (60.8%) in Zone B. Only a single portable glucometer (IS) consistently met the objectives across all analyses.
Discussion: The sample included 26 males and 25 females, with ages ranging from 5 to 96 months. Thirty-five rabbits were healthy, while 16 had various clinical abnormalities. Significant differences in median glycemia were found between the biochemical analyzer and all PGMs, except for the IS glucometer. FO and AA showed significantly lower glycemic values, while WD, WC, and WH showed higher values. The IS glucometer demonstrated the smallest mean variation and highest intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), indicating excellent agreement. Bland-Altman plots revealed that FO and AA underestimated glycemic values, while WD, WC, and WH overestimated them. Only IS showed agreement with the laboratory analyzer. Error grid analysis indicated no serious errors with any PGMs; however, IS had over 75% of results in Zone A, showing high agreement, while FO had the least favorable results. Total error analysis suggested that only IS consistently met accuracy objectives across various analyses. The study concluded that IS was the most accurate PGM, while others showed varying degrees of inaccuracy. Although PGMs are clinically acceptable based on ISO 15197:2013 standards, accuracy and precision issues remain, particularly for euglycemic and hyperglycemic samples. Although all glucometers showed clinically acceptable results in the error grid analysis, the accuracy varied among the devices. Collectively, the IS glucometer achieved the best results in measuring blood glucose in pet rabbits, demonstrating a better accuracy and lower tendency for systematic error compared to the laboratory analyzer. Despite the lower accuracy, the other evaluated glucometers showed potential for use in rabbits when a laboratory analyzer is not available, but should be used with caution, considering the glycemic range presented.
Keywords: glycemia, glycemic range, biochemical analyzer, Oryctolagus cuniculus, lagomorphs, diagnosis.
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul
Title: Blood Glucose Measurement in Rabbits - Performance Evaluation of Portable Glucometers
Description:
Background: Blood glucose level measurement plays an important role in the diagnosis and prognosis of different clinical conditions in rabbits.
Portable glucometers offer a quick and affordable tool to measure blood glucose.
However, not all commercially available glucometers are suitable for this purpose in different animal species and in different clinical conditions.
This study aimed to assess the performance of 4 portable glucometers compared to a biochemical analyzer using blood samples from both healthy and sick rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus).
Material,s Methods & Results: Blood samples were collected via jugular venipuncture from 51 rabbits.
The blood glucose concentration was measured using 3 human (FO= FreeStyle Optium Neo®; AA= Accu-chek® Active; IS= Injex Sens II®) and 1 veterinarian (PGM= Wellion Vet®, Gluco Calea) glucometer, configured for dog (WD), cat (WC), and horse (WH).
The results obtained from the glucometers were compared to those from the laboratory biochemical analyzer in wet biochemistry, using Spearman correlation, intraclass correlation coefficient, Bland-Altman analysis, error grid analysis and total error analysis.
Blood glucose concentrations were underestimated in the human devices evaluated and overestimated in the veterinary device.
Bland-Altman analysis revealed significant systematic differences in 3 of the 4 devices tested.
Total error above 20% was observed in normoglycemic samples from 2 devices (FO; and PGM - WC= cat code) and in hyperglycemic samples from 1 glucometer (AA).
All glucometers showed glycemic results within Zone A and B of the error grid analysis, although a glucometer (FO) present most of the results (60.
8%) in Zone B.
Only a single portable glucometer (IS) consistently met the objectives across all analyses.
Discussion: The sample included 26 males and 25 females, with ages ranging from 5 to 96 months.
Thirty-five rabbits were healthy, while 16 had various clinical abnormalities.
Significant differences in median glycemia were found between the biochemical analyzer and all PGMs, except for the IS glucometer.
FO and AA showed significantly lower glycemic values, while WD, WC, and WH showed higher values.
The IS glucometer demonstrated the smallest mean variation and highest intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), indicating excellent agreement.
Bland-Altman plots revealed that FO and AA underestimated glycemic values, while WD, WC, and WH overestimated them.
Only IS showed agreement with the laboratory analyzer.
Error grid analysis indicated no serious errors with any PGMs; however, IS had over 75% of results in Zone A, showing high agreement, while FO had the least favorable results.
Total error analysis suggested that only IS consistently met accuracy objectives across various analyses.
The study concluded that IS was the most accurate PGM, while others showed varying degrees of inaccuracy.
Although PGMs are clinically acceptable based on ISO 15197:2013 standards, accuracy and precision issues remain, particularly for euglycemic and hyperglycemic samples.
Although all glucometers showed clinically acceptable results in the error grid analysis, the accuracy varied among the devices.
Collectively, the IS glucometer achieved the best results in measuring blood glucose in pet rabbits, demonstrating a better accuracy and lower tendency for systematic error compared to the laboratory analyzer.
Despite the lower accuracy, the other evaluated glucometers showed potential for use in rabbits when a laboratory analyzer is not available, but should be used with caution, considering the glycemic range presented.
Keywords: glycemia, glycemic range, biochemical analyzer, Oryctolagus cuniculus, lagomorphs, diagnosis.
Related Results
Comparative Performance of Different Glucometers for Random Glucose Measurements in Diabetic Patients
Comparative Performance of Different Glucometers for Random Glucose Measurements in Diabetic Patients
Abstract
Background: Proper management of diabetic patients is dependent on accuracy in patient self-monitoring of blood glucose levels at home and during health care visit...
[RETRACTED] Guardian Blood Balance –Feel the difference Guardian Blood Balance makes! v1
[RETRACTED] Guardian Blood Balance –Feel the difference Guardian Blood Balance makes! v1
[RETRACTED]Guardian Blood Balance Reviews (Works Or Hoax) Does Guardian Botanicals Blood Balance AU Really Works? Read Updated Report! Diabetes and Hypertension is such a health p...
Effect of hematocrit on accuracy of two point-of-care glucometers for use in dogs
Effect of hematocrit on accuracy of two point-of-care glucometers for use in dogs
Abstract
Objective—To determine the effect of Hct on blood glucose readings of dogs obtained by use of 2 point-of-care (POC) blood glucometers and a laboratory analyzer.
Animals—18...
The effect of housing system on the behaviour and growth parameters of fattening rabbits
The effect of housing system on the behaviour and growth parameters of fattening rabbits
AbstractThree housing systems for fattening rabbits were compared using a stocking density of 15 rabbits m–2. The rabbits were housed in large pens (3.67 m2, 50 rabbits), small pen...
Symmetrization of the Blood Glucose Measurement Scale and Its Applications
Symmetrization of the Blood Glucose Measurement Scale and Its Applications
OBJECTIVE
To introduce a data transformation that enhances the power of blood glucose data analyses.
RESEARCH DE...
A Comparative Study of Blood Glucose Level Measurement Between Glucometer and Semi Autoanalyser
A Comparative Study of Blood Glucose Level Measurement Between Glucometer and Semi Autoanalyser
Background; Glucometers are the excellent tools for self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG). Glucometer is widely used at hospitals and homes as a first line tool to get an idea ab...
Glucose intolerance is associated with resting heart rate among individuals without diabetes
Glucose intolerance is associated with resting heart rate among individuals without diabetes
Elevated resting heart rate is associated with cardiovascular diseases and all-cause mortality. Unmanaged diabetes is associated with high blood pressure and high resting heart rat...
Effect of castration on the growth performance of rabbits
Effect of castration on the growth performance of rabbits
Castration has been reported as a management practice that could improve weight gain in farm animals but there is not enough informationaboutits effect in rabbits. To help rabbit f...

