Javascript must be enabled to continue!
KEIMANAN ABU THALIB (Studi Komparatif Terhadap Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir al-Mizan)
View through CrossRef
Abu Talib's faith in the realm of Islamic thought still has a very long debate. Some scholars have claimed that he is an infidel, while others have claimed that he was a believer. Abu Talib was not uncommon also mixed up in political issues at the time of the power held by Mu'awiya sought to discredit Ali and his family. In the Koran, there are many verses that are considered by some scholars that the verses 113-114, al-Qasas verse 56, Surah al-An'am verse 26, and other letters relating to the faith of Abu Talib. The study was written as a reflection of the author's interest in knowing more about the subject by focusing Ibn Kathir's interpretation of the study as a Sunni interpretation and interpretation Tabataba'i as a homage to Shiite interpretation. The equation of these two interpreters is that Ibn Kathir explicitly says that these verses descend are addressed to Abu Talib (The Prophet's Uncle), who tells of Abu Talib's refusal to recite the two sentences of the shahadah at the end of his life, and still holds to his former religion Religion Abdul Mutallib. So also with T{abat{aba’i who said that Abu Talib died in a state of no faith and still hold on to the religion of his ancestors. While the location of the differences between them is contained in the interpretation of the letter al-An'am Ibn Kathir says the verse goes down with regard to Abu Talib who defends the Prophet to carry out his da'wah. T{abat{aba’i is different from Ibn Kathir in the explanation of his riwayah, namely the interpretation of 'Iyasi and Qumi's commentary, he says from the line of Ahl Bait that Abu Talib is a believer based on his evidence and his sayings. Essentially these two interpretations are the same, the most notable distinction lies only in the flow they profess, Ibn Kathir as a Sunni interpreter, T{abat{aba’i as a Shiite interpreter.
Title: KEIMANAN ABU THALIB (Studi Komparatif Terhadap Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir al-Mizan)
Description:
Abu Talib's faith in the realm of Islamic thought still has a very long debate.
Some scholars have claimed that he is an infidel, while others have claimed that he was a believer.
Abu Talib was not uncommon also mixed up in political issues at the time of the power held by Mu'awiya sought to discredit Ali and his family.
In the Koran, there are many verses that are considered by some scholars that the verses 113-114, al-Qasas verse 56, Surah al-An'am verse 26, and other letters relating to the faith of Abu Talib.
The study was written as a reflection of the author's interest in knowing more about the subject by focusing Ibn Kathir's interpretation of the study as a Sunni interpretation and interpretation Tabataba'i as a homage to Shiite interpretation.
The equation of these two interpreters is that Ibn Kathir explicitly says that these verses descend are addressed to Abu Talib (The Prophet's Uncle), who tells of Abu Talib's refusal to recite the two sentences of the shahadah at the end of his life, and still holds to his former religion Religion Abdul Mutallib.
So also with T{abat{aba’i who said that Abu Talib died in a state of no faith and still hold on to the religion of his ancestors.
While the location of the differences between them is contained in the interpretation of the letter al-An'am Ibn Kathir says the verse goes down with regard to Abu Talib who defends the Prophet to carry out his da'wah.
T{abat{aba’i is different from Ibn Kathir in the explanation of his riwayah, namely the interpretation of 'Iyasi and Qumi's commentary, he says from the line of Ahl Bait that Abu Talib is a believer based on his evidence and his sayings.
Essentially these two interpretations are the same, the most notable distinction lies only in the flow they profess, Ibn Kathir as a Sunni interpreter, T{abat{aba’i as a Shiite interpreter.
Related Results
Makna Ikhlas dalam Tafsir Fakhruddin Ar-Razi dan Ibn Kaṡīr
Makna Ikhlas dalam Tafsir Fakhruddin Ar-Razi dan Ibn Kaṡīr
Konsep ikhlas merupakan nilai fundamental dalam Islam yang telah diinterpretasikan secara mendalam oleh para mufassir, seperti Fakhruddin Ar-Razi dan Ibn Kaṡīr, yang memberikan kon...
[Interpretation Method of Al-Ilmi Hamka and Al-Maraghiy on Al-Kawniyah Verses: A Comparison] Metode Pentafsiran Al-Ilmiy Hamka dan Al-Maraghiy Terhadap Ayat-Ayat Al-Kawniyyah : Satu Perbandingan
[Interpretation Method of Al-Ilmi Hamka and Al-Maraghiy on Al-Kawniyah Verses: A Comparison] Metode Pentafsiran Al-Ilmiy Hamka dan Al-Maraghiy Terhadap Ayat-Ayat Al-Kawniyyah : Satu Perbandingan
The Tafsir al-Azhar of HAMKA is one of the Malay world's tafsir which reveals the vastness of knowledge that encompasses and covers all disciplines of science. In this interpretati...
Penafsiran Ayat-Ayat tentang Laknat dalam al-Qur’an (Studi Komparasi Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir Ibn as-Si’di)
Penafsiran Ayat-Ayat tentang Laknat dalam al-Qur’an (Studi Komparasi Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir Ibn as-Si’di)
Tujuan dari penelitian ini antara lain; Mengetahui bagaimana penafsiran Ibn Kasir terhadap ayat-ayat laknat dalam al-Qur’an. Mengetahui bagaimana penafsiran Ibn Na?ir as-Si’di ter...
[Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir’s Political Involvement According to The Chronicle Of Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi] Penglibatan Politik Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir Menurut Catatan Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi
[Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir’s Political Involvement According to The Chronicle Of Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi] Penglibatan Politik Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir Menurut Catatan Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi
Abstract
Muhammad ibn Abi ‘Amir was a de facto leader of al-Andalus during the Umayyad rule based in Cordoba. Caliph al-Hakam II had appointed him to hold some political posi...
DISKURSUS MUNĀSABAH: Problem Tafsīr al-Qur’ān bi ’l-Qur’ān
DISKURSUS MUNĀSABAH: Problem Tafsīr al-Qur’ān bi ’l-Qur’ān
Abstract: Munāsabah al-Qur’ān is a part of ‘Ulūm al-Qur’ān which presents pros and contrast. The pros ulama makes munāsabah as a method to reveal enigma system of Quran verses and ...
Kajian Kritis terhadap Rumusan Konsep Mufassir: Perspektif Ushul Tafsir
Kajian Kritis terhadap Rumusan Konsep Mufassir: Perspektif Ushul Tafsir
In the study of ushûl al-tafsir, among the most important things in discussing the basics of interpretation is establishing the concept of mufassir. This is because without underst...
POLA PENAFSIRAN MUHAMMAD BASIUNI IMRAN DALAM TAFSĪR TŪJUH SŪRAH DAN ĀYĀT AṢ-ṢIYĀM TERHADAP TAFSIR MUHAMMAD RASYID RIDHA: (Kajian Intertekstualitas)
POLA PENAFSIRAN MUHAMMAD BASIUNI IMRAN DALAM TAFSĪR TŪJUH SŪRAH DAN ĀYĀT AṢ-ṢIYĀM TERHADAP TAFSIR MUHAMMAD RASYID RIDHA: (Kajian Intertekstualitas)
Pada abad ke-20 M, penulisan tafsir al-Qur’an yang lahir di Nusantara umumnya menampilkan ciri kemodernannya, baik dari segi bahasa dan aksara. Namun, berbeda dengan Tafsīr Tūjuh S...

