Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The Dissenters: Melville and Brownson
View through CrossRef
Abstract
In his classic study Melville’s Quarrel with God, Lawrance Thompson wrote that it would be more appropriate to call Melville a “descendentalist” than a transcendentalist, a witticism that manifests a deeper truth than one might expect: The turn which his life had taken translated him from a transcendentalist and a mystic into an inverted transcendentalist, an inverted mystic. To this extent, then, he was consistent, in spite of all his concomitant inconsistencies, to the very end of his life. Like his own Captain Ahab, he remained a defiant rebel, even in the face of death.
Oxford University PressNew York, NY
Title: The Dissenters: Melville and Brownson
Description:
Abstract
In his classic study Melville’s Quarrel with God, Lawrance Thompson wrote that it would be more appropriate to call Melville a “descendentalist” than a transcendentalist, a witticism that manifests a deeper truth than one might expect: The turn which his life had taken translated him from a transcendentalist and a mystic into an inverted transcendentalist, an inverted mystic.
To this extent, then, he was consistent, in spite of all his concomitant inconsistencies, to the very end of his life.
Like his own Captain Ahab, he remained a defiant rebel, even in the face of death.
Related Results
The Oxford Handbook of Herman Melville
The Oxford Handbook of Herman Melville
Abstract
Now, more than a century since the revival that placed Herman Melville at the center of the US literary canon, his work stands as one of the most important ...
“Copyright, 1892, by Elizabeth S. Melville”: Rethinking the Field Formation of Melville Studies
“Copyright, 1892, by Elizabeth S. Melville”: Rethinking the Field Formation of Melville Studies
Abstract
This chapter focuses particular attention on what might be called the first Melville revival, beginning in 1892 when Elizabeth Shaw Melville returned four o...
Mahomet’s Gospel and Other Revelations: Discovering Melville’s Hand in The Works of William E. Channing
Mahomet’s Gospel and Other Revelations: Discovering Melville’s Hand in The Works of William E. Channing
This essay announces the discovery of Herman Melville’s erased annotation in Elizabeth Shaw Melville’s copy of the six-volume Works of William E. Channing , as well as the presence...
Melville's Intervisionary Network
Melville's Intervisionary Network
The romances of Herman Melville, author of Moby-Dick and Billy Budd, Sailor, are usually examined from some setting almost exclusively American. European or other planetary context...
Introduction: Melville’s Third Century
Introduction: Melville’s Third Century
Abstract
As we begin the third century after Melville’s birth and the second century of Melville studies, the Oxford Handbook of Herman Melville aims to reintroduce ...
"MY BEARD IS MY OWN”: HERMAN MELVILLE’S BEARD POETICS IN HIS NARRATIVES OF MARITIME MASCULINITY.
"MY BEARD IS MY OWN”: HERMAN MELVILLE’S BEARD POETICS IN HIS NARRATIVES OF MARITIME MASCULINITY.
This article celebrates the vital role of the beard in Herman Melville’s narratives of maritime masculinity. While the limited commentary on the beard has thus far focused on the h...
Herman Melville’s Pessimist Verse: James Thomson and Timoleon, Etc.
Herman Melville’s Pessimist Verse: James Thomson and Timoleon, Etc.
Abstract
In a letter in 1885, Melville commented about a pessimist poet: “altho’ neither pessimist nor optomist [sic] myself, nevertheless I relish it in the verse i...
The Image of Philosophy in Herman Melville’s Story Cock-A-Doodle-Do! or, the Crowing of the Noble Cock Beneventano
The Image of Philosophy in Herman Melville’s Story Cock-A-Doodle-Do! or, the Crowing of the Noble Cock Beneventano
The work of the outstanding American writer Herman Melville (1819–1891) is widely acknowledged for its profound philosophical depth. It parallels various philosophical and religiou...

