Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Defining and Certifying Diversity: Affirmative Action
View through CrossRef
This article is a chapter of my forthcoming book Diversity in America: Keeping Government at a Safe Distance (Harvard U. P., early 2003). The book also contains chapters on a conceptualization/taxonomy of diversity ("The Diversity of Diversity"), an intellectual history of diversity-as-ideal (just published as "The Perceived Values of Diversity, Then and Now," 22 Cardozo L. Rev. 1915 (2001)), and chapters analyzing the law and policy governing immigration-related diversity, diversity in residential communities, and religious diversity. There are also introductory and concluding chapters.
This article consists of ten sections: (1) an introduction; (2) the definitions, designs, and domains of affirmative action; (3) the importance of context in assessments of affirmative action; (4) the size of affirmative action preferences in different domains, especially higher education; (5) rationales and counter-rationales for ethno-racial preferences (restitution, merit, anti-caste, leadership cadre, market failure, institutional pragmatism, and diversity); (6) the politics of affirmative action (political history, public attitudes, and political survival); (7) the consequences of affirmative action (rate of black progress, distribution of benefits in and outside the favored group, and incidence and distribution of costs); (8) the re-segregation nightmare; (9) alternatives (better targeting within favored groups, disadvantage-based preferences, lottery, addressing root causes, time-limited programs, and voluntary programs); and (10) a conclusion.
Prescriptively, I argue that whether or not the diversity rationale for legally-mandated ethno-racial preferences in higher education (and probably elsewhere) can pass constitutional muster (apart from the narrow opening under the Court's Paradise test), public law preferences are unjust and unwise, and are steadily becoming more so. Private preferences, however, are acceptable if the entities using them publicly disclose the nature and magnitude of those preferences and do not discriminate against blacks and other minorities entitled to the highest level of protection under the Constitution.
Title: Defining and Certifying Diversity: Affirmative Action
Description:
This article is a chapter of my forthcoming book Diversity in America: Keeping Government at a Safe Distance (Harvard U.
P.
, early 2003).
The book also contains chapters on a conceptualization/taxonomy of diversity ("The Diversity of Diversity"), an intellectual history of diversity-as-ideal (just published as "The Perceived Values of Diversity, Then and Now," 22 Cardozo L.
Rev.
1915 (2001)), and chapters analyzing the law and policy governing immigration-related diversity, diversity in residential communities, and religious diversity.
There are also introductory and concluding chapters.
This article consists of ten sections: (1) an introduction; (2) the definitions, designs, and domains of affirmative action; (3) the importance of context in assessments of affirmative action; (4) the size of affirmative action preferences in different domains, especially higher education; (5) rationales and counter-rationales for ethno-racial preferences (restitution, merit, anti-caste, leadership cadre, market failure, institutional pragmatism, and diversity); (6) the politics of affirmative action (political history, public attitudes, and political survival); (7) the consequences of affirmative action (rate of black progress, distribution of benefits in and outside the favored group, and incidence and distribution of costs); (8) the re-segregation nightmare; (9) alternatives (better targeting within favored groups, disadvantage-based preferences, lottery, addressing root causes, time-limited programs, and voluntary programs); and (10) a conclusion.
Prescriptively, I argue that whether or not the diversity rationale for legally-mandated ethno-racial preferences in higher education (and probably elsewhere) can pass constitutional muster (apart from the narrow opening under the Court's Paradise test), public law preferences are unjust and unwise, and are steadily becoming more so.
Private preferences, however, are acceptable if the entities using them publicly disclose the nature and magnitude of those preferences and do not discriminate against blacks and other minorities entitled to the highest level of protection under the Constitution.
Related Results
Affirmative Action
Affirmative Action
Affirmative action refers to laws or government-mandated or voluntary policies or procedures designed to promote the equitable inclusion of members of certain historically excluded...
Archibald Cox and the Diversity Justification for Affirmative Action
Archibald Cox and the Diversity Justification for Affirmative Action
Discussions of the value of racial, ethnic and gender diversity are so commonplace today that anyone born after 1990 could be excused for thinking that these forms of identity dive...
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: ONLY A SHIELD? OR ALSO A SWORD? Harmse v City of Cape Town (2003) 24 ILJ 1130 and Dudley v City of Cape Town (2004) 25 ILJ 305 (LC)
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: ONLY A SHIELD? OR ALSO A SWORD? Harmse v City of Cape Town (2003) 24 ILJ 1130 and Dudley v City of Cape Town (2004) 25 ILJ 305 (LC)
The Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 (hereinafter “the EEA”) which gives more detailed content to the right of equality enshrined in section 9 of the Constitution of South Africa, ...
Writing Off Race
Writing Off Race
The constitutionality of affirmative action has now become one of the central topics in the politics of race. Ironically, the United States Constitution says absolutely nothing abo...
The South African Sources of the Diversity Justification for U.S. Affirmative Action.
The South African Sources of the Diversity Justification for U.S. Affirmative Action.
This essay reveals that the “diversity justification” for affirmative<br>action has its roots in part in the South African anti-apartheid<br>movement of the 1950s, and ...
Representative Bureaucracy: Implementing Effects and Structural Barriers of Affirmative Action Initiative in Nepal
Representative Bureaucracy: Implementing Effects and Structural Barriers of Affirmative Action Initiative in Nepal
Since its adoption in 2007, affirmative action policy within the Nepalese civil service has been the focus of research concerning representative bureaucracy dynamics. This study el...
Quo Vadis Kebijakan Affirmative Action dalam Sistem Demokrasi di Indonesia
Quo Vadis Kebijakan Affirmative Action dalam Sistem Demokrasi di Indonesia
Secara umum adanya penelitian ini ditujukan untuk mengetahui bagaimana pelaksanaan kebijakan affirmative action di Indonesia dan apakah pelaksanaan tersebut mencerminkan nilai-nila...
Implementasi Affirmative Action Dalam Rekrutmen dan Seleksi Bintara Polri di Polda Papua 2019
Implementasi Affirmative Action Dalam Rekrutmen dan Seleksi Bintara Polri di Polda Papua 2019
AbstrakTujuan tulisan ini adalah menganalisis hasil penerapan tindakan afirmatif selama proses rekrutmen beserta seleksi Kepolisian di Papua, sehingga realisasi kompetensi Polri ya...

