Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The South African Sources of the Diversity Justification for U.S. Affirmative Action.
View through CrossRef
This essay reveals that the “diversity justification” for affirmative<br>action has its roots in part in the South African anti-apartheid<br>movement of the 1950s, and that when Justice Powell wrote the<br>controlling opinion in the Bakke case, placing diversity at the center<br>of our discourse on race in America, he was relying on arguments<br>developed in the anti-apartheid movement that the right to admit a<br>racially diverse student body was a key element of academic freedom.<br>When examined in this light, Justice Powell’s opinion was more<br>concerned with academic freedom than racial justice.<br><br>Though Powell’s opinion – which provides the only basis for<br>race-conscious affirmative action in higher education currently<br>permitted under US law – has been the subject of exhaustive study and<br>criticism, it was only recently revealed that the diversity argument<br>Justice Powell articulated was largely cut and pasted from a brief<br>crafted by the great American lawyer and Harvard Law Professor<br>Archibald Cox. Cox drew on a hundred years of Harvard history,<br>beginning with curricular reforms and an ever-expanding search for<br>diversity begun by Harvard’s transformational President Charles<br>Eliot, who in turn borrowed liberally from the work of John Stuart Mill<br>and Harriet Taylor Mill, and from ideas generated in the nineteenth<br>century reforms of the German university under the leadership of<br>Wilhelm von Humboldt. Critical among these reforms was the decision<br>to admit Catholics, Jews and other nonconformists to Oxford,<br>Cambridge and the University of Berlin. Eliot’s quest for diversity,<br>including racial, religious and ethnic diversity, carried through<br>Harvard’s bitter fights over exclusion and inclusion through the<br>twentieth century, with contributions from Oliver Wendell Holmes,<br>Learned Hand, Felix Frankfurter, Erwin Griswold, Thurgood<br>Marshall and Derrick Bok (among others) in what amounted to a<br>multi-generational discussion about the relationship of diversity and<br>academic freedom.<br><br>The South African anti-apartheid movement played a role in<br>Cox’s argument because his mentors Frankfurter and Griswold<br>befriended their counterparts at the South African Supreme Court and<br>the University of Cape Town just as the South Africans confronted and<br>resisted the beginning of apartheid. In an attempt to prevent the<br>apartheid government from imposing segregation on the two South<br>African universities that then admitted Black students and allowed<br>integrated classrooms, they developed the argument that a university<br>had the freedom to select its students without interference and should<br>select them with an eye on promoting racial diversity in a multi-racial<br>society. Frankfurter and Griswold admired the argument and imported<br>it to the United States, where it fit hand-in-glove into Cox and Bok’s<br>goals for Harvard. When Cox (at Bok’s request) drew on Harvard’s<br>history in writing the brief that persuaded Justice Powell to embrace<br>the diversity rationale, they gave us our anti-apartheid inspired<br>diversity justification.<br><br>Although Justice Powell regarded his Bakke opinion as the most<br>important he wrote in his years on the Court, it has been regarded by<br>many as an unfortunate pragmatic compromise that came out of<br>nowhere and has no intellectual heft. Today, as the Court considers<br>whether diversity – or any other justification – is sufficient to allow<br>affirmative action, it is important to recognize the rich legal,<br>intellectual and political history that underlies the Bakke opinion.
Title: The South African Sources of the Diversity Justification for U.S. Affirmative Action.
Description:
This essay reveals that the “diversity justification” for affirmative<br>action has its roots in part in the South African anti-apartheid<br>movement of the 1950s, and that when Justice Powell wrote the<br>controlling opinion in the Bakke case, placing diversity at the center<br>of our discourse on race in America, he was relying on arguments<br>developed in the anti-apartheid movement that the right to admit a<br>racially diverse student body was a key element of academic freedom.
<br>When examined in this light, Justice Powell’s opinion was more<br>concerned with academic freedom than racial justice.
<br><br>Though Powell’s opinion – which provides the only basis for<br>race-conscious affirmative action in higher education currently<br>permitted under US law – has been the subject of exhaustive study and<br>criticism, it was only recently revealed that the diversity argument<br>Justice Powell articulated was largely cut and pasted from a brief<br>crafted by the great American lawyer and Harvard Law Professor<br>Archibald Cox.
Cox drew on a hundred years of Harvard history,<br>beginning with curricular reforms and an ever-expanding search for<br>diversity begun by Harvard’s transformational President Charles<br>Eliot, who in turn borrowed liberally from the work of John Stuart Mill<br>and Harriet Taylor Mill, and from ideas generated in the nineteenth<br>century reforms of the German university under the leadership of<br>Wilhelm von Humboldt.
Critical among these reforms was the decision<br>to admit Catholics, Jews and other nonconformists to Oxford,<br>Cambridge and the University of Berlin.
Eliot’s quest for diversity,<br>including racial, religious and ethnic diversity, carried through<br>Harvard’s bitter fights over exclusion and inclusion through the<br>twentieth century, with contributions from Oliver Wendell Holmes,<br>Learned Hand, Felix Frankfurter, Erwin Griswold, Thurgood<br>Marshall and Derrick Bok (among others) in what amounted to a<br>multi-generational discussion about the relationship of diversity and<br>academic freedom.
<br><br>The South African anti-apartheid movement played a role in<br>Cox’s argument because his mentors Frankfurter and Griswold<br>befriended their counterparts at the South African Supreme Court and<br>the University of Cape Town just as the South Africans confronted and<br>resisted the beginning of apartheid.
In an attempt to prevent the<br>apartheid government from imposing segregation on the two South<br>African universities that then admitted Black students and allowed<br>integrated classrooms, they developed the argument that a university<br>had the freedom to select its students without interference and should<br>select them with an eye on promoting racial diversity in a multi-racial<br>society.
Frankfurter and Griswold admired the argument and imported<br>it to the United States, where it fit hand-in-glove into Cox and Bok’s<br>goals for Harvard.
When Cox (at Bok’s request) drew on Harvard’s<br>history in writing the brief that persuaded Justice Powell to embrace<br>the diversity rationale, they gave us our anti-apartheid inspired<br>diversity justification.
<br><br>Although Justice Powell regarded his Bakke opinion as the most<br>important he wrote in his years on the Court, it has been regarded by<br>many as an unfortunate pragmatic compromise that came out of<br>nowhere and has no intellectual heft.
Today, as the Court considers<br>whether diversity – or any other justification – is sufficient to allow<br>affirmative action, it is important to recognize the rich legal,<br>intellectual and political history that underlies the Bakke opinion.
Related Results
Affirmative Action
Affirmative Action
Affirmative action refers to laws or government-mandated or voluntary policies or procedures designed to promote the equitable inclusion of members of certain historically excluded...
Potable Water Sources, Household Hygiene, and Sanitation Practices in Ikpoba Okha LGA, Edo State: Implications for Public Health and Sustainable Water Management
Omoregie, Andrew Edosa.1 Omoregie Abieyuwa Peace2 Okoro, Enyinnaya Okoro.3
1 College of Medi
Potable Water Sources, Household Hygiene, and Sanitation Practices in Ikpoba Okha LGA, Edo State: Implications for Public Health and Sustainable Water Management
Omoregie, Andrew Edosa.1 Omoregie Abieyuwa Peace2 Okoro, Enyinnaya Okoro.3
1 College of Medi
BACKGROUND
Access to potable drinking water and sufficient sanitation continues to be an urgent global concern, particularly in developing regions where con...
Archibald Cox and the Diversity Justification for Affirmative Action
Archibald Cox and the Diversity Justification for Affirmative Action
Discussions of the value of racial, ethnic and gender diversity are so commonplace today that anyone born after 1990 could be excused for thinking that these forms of identity dive...
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: ONLY A SHIELD? OR ALSO A SWORD? Harmse v City of Cape Town (2003) 24 ILJ 1130 and Dudley v City of Cape Town (2004) 25 ILJ 305 (LC)
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: ONLY A SHIELD? OR ALSO A SWORD? Harmse v City of Cape Town (2003) 24 ILJ 1130 and Dudley v City of Cape Town (2004) 25 ILJ 305 (LC)
The Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 (hereinafter “the EEA”) which gives more detailed content to the right of equality enshrined in section 9 of the Constitution of South Africa, ...
Augustine of Hippo: On Justification by Faith
Augustine of Hippo: On Justification by Faith
This study aims to retrieve Augustine of Hippo’s view of ‘justification by faith’ from his theological writings from the 390s to the end of his career. Significant sources are his ...
Defining and Certifying Diversity: Affirmative Action
Defining and Certifying Diversity: Affirmative Action
This article is a chapter of my forthcoming book Diversity in America: Keeping Government at a Safe Distance (Harvard U. P., early 2003). The book also contains chapters on a conce...
Mindy Calling: Size, Beauty, Race in The Mindy Project
Mindy Calling: Size, Beauty, Race in The Mindy Project
When characters in the Fox Television sitcom The Mindy Project call Mindy Lahiri fat, Mindy sees it as a case of misidentification. She reminds the character that she is a “petite ...
Why Didnt I Get The Job? White Nonbeneficiaries Reactions To Affirmative Action And Diversity Programs
Why Didnt I Get The Job? White Nonbeneficiaries Reactions To Affirmative Action And Diversity Programs
The purpose of this study was to investigate how justifications for hiring procedures and hiring decisions impact white nonbeneficiaries perceptions of fairness. The results for th...

