Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Plea Bargaining and the Miscarriage of Justice
View through CrossRef
AbstractObjectivesWe examine whether, on average, plea bargaining encourages guilty pleas among defendants who are factually innocent.MethodsWe develop a formal theory of plea bargaining in which defendants take into account the possibility of false convictions or acquittals when making plea-bargain decisions. We use an incidentally truncated bivariate probit model to test the theory, which predicts that if innocent defendants plead guilty, the correlation (ρ) between the unobserved heterogeneity regarding selection into trial and regarding conviction at trial should be sufficiently positive. The method does not require knowledge of whether individual defendants are factually guilty or innocent. Sinceρis also predicted to vary directly with the unobserved toughness of prosecutors, we develop a decomposition theorem to distinguish between the effects of defendants and prosecutors in plea bargain decisions.ResultsUsing data on 2012 criminal cases decided in Israeli courts from 2010 to 2011, we find thatρis large and positive. Hence, defendants who did not plea bargain were positively selected in terms of conviction. This means that defendants who accepted plea bargains had smaller counterfactual conviction probabilities than observationally similar defendants who went to trial.ConclusionsThe results indicate that, on average, factually innocent defendants in Israel during this period took plea bargains instead of going to trial. This contradicts “innocence effect” theory, which predicts that factually innocent defendants, on average, reject plea bargains. Our findings are important for research on shadow trial theory, since they show that selection into plea bargains cannot be ignored when inferring counterfactual trial outcomes for plea bargainers.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: Plea Bargaining and the Miscarriage of Justice
Description:
AbstractObjectivesWe examine whether, on average, plea bargaining encourages guilty pleas among defendants who are factually innocent.
MethodsWe develop a formal theory of plea bargaining in which defendants take into account the possibility of false convictions or acquittals when making plea-bargain decisions.
We use an incidentally truncated bivariate probit model to test the theory, which predicts that if innocent defendants plead guilty, the correlation (ρ) between the unobserved heterogeneity regarding selection into trial and regarding conviction at trial should be sufficiently positive.
The method does not require knowledge of whether individual defendants are factually guilty or innocent.
Sinceρis also predicted to vary directly with the unobserved toughness of prosecutors, we develop a decomposition theorem to distinguish between the effects of defendants and prosecutors in plea bargain decisions.
ResultsUsing data on 2012 criminal cases decided in Israeli courts from 2010 to 2011, we find thatρis large and positive.
Hence, defendants who did not plea bargain were positively selected in terms of conviction.
This means that defendants who accepted plea bargains had smaller counterfactual conviction probabilities than observationally similar defendants who went to trial.
ConclusionsThe results indicate that, on average, factually innocent defendants in Israel during this period took plea bargains instead of going to trial.
This contradicts “innocence effect” theory, which predicts that factually innocent defendants, on average, reject plea bargains.
Our findings are important for research on shadow trial theory, since they show that selection into plea bargains cannot be ignored when inferring counterfactual trial outcomes for plea bargainers.
Related Results
Asset Confiscation in Corruption Cases through Plea Bargaining System: Should Indonesia Learn From Nigeria?
Asset Confiscation in Corruption Cases through Plea Bargaining System: Should Indonesia Learn From Nigeria?
Plea bargaining system is a procedure of bargaining for punishment between the prosecutor and the suspect or defendant on the basis of an admission of guilt from the latter party. ...
University Campus Members' Perceptions and Willingness to Accept Plea Deals
University Campus Members' Perceptions and Willingness to Accept Plea Deals
Previous research on plea bargaining has primarily focused on public opinion about this practice and the disparities among individuals who have accepted a plea deal. This body of r...
COMPARISON OF PLEA BARGAINING IN THE UNITED STATES WITH “SPECIAL LINE” IN THE DRAFT BOOK OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE (KUHAP) IN INDONESIA
COMPARISON OF PLEA BARGAINING IN THE UNITED STATES WITH “SPECIAL LINE” IN THE DRAFT BOOK OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE (KUHAP) IN INDONESIA
Plea Bargaining is a faster and more efficient way of resolving criminal cases, where if the Defendant has admitted guilt, the Defendant or his attorney can make an agreement with ...
Testing a Behavioral Theory Model of Labor Negotiations
Testing a Behavioral Theory Model of Labor Negotiations
SummaryThe Behavioral Theory we have developed stands up well and helps us gain a better feeling for the behavioral dynamics of collective bargaining. As expected, economic variabl...
Plea Bargaining - A Comparative Study of India with Foreign Countries
Plea Bargaining - A Comparative Study of India with Foreign Countries
Plea bargaining has become more popular as a way to resolve court issues around the world. The application, scope, and operation of plea bargains change significantly between the c...
Implementation of Plea Bargaining in the Indonesian Criminal Justice System
Implementation of Plea Bargaining in the Indonesian Criminal Justice System
There is a need for a new system in the Indonesian Criminal Justice System that is thought to make case handling more efficient, specifically by adopting plea bargaining as a probl...
An Exploration Collective Bargaining Units in the Public Service
An Exploration Collective Bargaining Units in the Public Service
Bargaining units and rights are the basis for collective bargaining. The aspect of collecting bargaining unit is intimately related to the aspect of bargaining rights and collectiv...
P-383 Development and validation of a visualized prediction model for early miscarriage risk in patients undergoing IVF/ICSI procedures: a real-world multi-center study
P-383 Development and validation of a visualized prediction model for early miscarriage risk in patients undergoing IVF/ICSI procedures: a real-world multi-center study
Abstract
Study question
What are the key predictors of early miscarriage in patients undergoing IVF/ICSI treatment?
...

