Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Multidimensional Scaling and Experimental Aesthetics: Escher's Prints as a Case Study
View through CrossRef
This article represents a case-study in the applicability of multidimensional scaling (MDS) to experimental aesthetics. MDS allows experimenters to ask observers to compare stimuli without specifying which criteria they should use. MDS plots data—the similarity judgements—in a “psychological space” whose number of dimensions reflects the number of ways the stimuli are perceived to differ. An experiment attempted to tap into the criteria used by non-specialists when viewing prints by the Dutch artist M. C. Escher, and to study whether or not these criteria correspond to those Escher himself used to classify his work. Forty observers were shown every possible non-duplicate pair combination of twenty-six slides of Escher's prints, and were asked to rate the similarity of each pair, using any criteria they wished. Three dimensions were identified in this experiment (“dimensionality,” “shape” and “degree of realism”). A neighborhood analysis (based on octants) suggests that observers' perceptions seem to correspond to Escher's groupings.
Title: Multidimensional Scaling and Experimental Aesthetics: Escher's Prints as a Case Study
Description:
This article represents a case-study in the applicability of multidimensional scaling (MDS) to experimental aesthetics.
MDS allows experimenters to ask observers to compare stimuli without specifying which criteria they should use.
MDS plots data—the similarity judgements—in a “psychological space” whose number of dimensions reflects the number of ways the stimuli are perceived to differ.
An experiment attempted to tap into the criteria used by non-specialists when viewing prints by the Dutch artist M.
C.
Escher, and to study whether or not these criteria correspond to those Escher himself used to classify his work.
Forty observers were shown every possible non-duplicate pair combination of twenty-six slides of Escher's prints, and were asked to rate the similarity of each pair, using any criteria they wished.
Three dimensions were identified in this experiment (“dimensionality,” “shape” and “degree of realism”).
A neighborhood analysis (based on octants) suggests that observers' perceptions seem to correspond to Escher's groupings.
Related Results
An introduction to György Márkus’s aesthetics: Transformation from praxis aesthetics to theory of aesthetic modernity
An introduction to György Márkus’s aesthetics: Transformation from praxis aesthetics to theory of aesthetic modernity
György Márkus, as a leading member of the Budapest School led by György Lukács in Hungary, is closely concerned with aesthetics. His final unfinished writings in political exile in...
Visualization of Linear Ordering Results for Ordinal Data with Application of Multidimensional Scaling
Visualization of Linear Ordering Results for Ordinal Data with Application of Multidimensional Scaling
A two-step procedure was proposed to visualization of linear ordering results for ordinal data. In the first step as a result of the application of multidimensional scaling (see Bo...
Renormalization group approach to 1D cellular automata with large updating neighborhoods
Renormalization group approach to 1D cellular automata with large updating neighborhoods
We study self‐similarity in one‐dimensional probabilistic cellular automata (PCA) by applying a real‐space renormalization technique to PCA with increasingly large updating neighbo...
Autonomy of art and the limits of aesthetics: Sreten Petrović’s contribution to Marxist aesthetics
Autonomy of art and the limits of aesthetics: Sreten Petrović’s contribution to Marxist aesthetics
The paper explores Sreten Petrović’s contribution to Marxist aesthetics. Petrović developed his theory within the framework of the Yugoslav Praxis School, although he was not a mem...
Preparing and comparing subtitles for quasi-experimental and experimental research in audiovisual translation
studies
Preparing and comparing subtitles for quasi-experimental and experimental research in audiovisual translation
studies
Abstract
Empirical research on cognitive processing in AVT has been on the rise in recent years. A number of overarching
works have recommended ...
The assessment of teamwork competencies for students focuses on dimensionality and mixed-method assessment
The assessment of teamwork competencies for students focuses on dimensionality and mixed-method assessment
The challenges of assessing teamwork competency, which internal structures can be multidimensional and complex. It is necessary to assess of the teamwork competency as unidimension...
The Quest for Causality in Psychotherapy Research
The Quest for Causality in Psychotherapy Research
This commentary on the article by Frankl, Wennberg, Berggraf and Philips (2020) focuses on methodological aspects of case studies versus group designs in psychotherapy research. Ex...
Experimental research in automatic subtitling
Experimental research in automatic subtitling
Abstract
Recent developments in neural machine translation, and especially speech translation, are gradually but firmly entering the field of audiovisual translation (AVT). Automat...
Recent Results
Constraining planet formation with atmospheric observations from the V1298 Tau planet system
Constraining planet formation with atmospheric observations from the V1298 Tau planet system
<p>Theories of planet formation like core accretion mechanism&#160; have been successful over the years in explaining the formation gas giant planets and even...
Genetic diversity, polyphenolic composition and fruit quality trait phenotypic analyses of a Chilean heritage blood-flesh peach (Prunus persica L.)
Genetic diversity, polyphenolic composition and fruit quality trait phenotypic analyses of a Chilean heritage blood-flesh peach (Prunus persica L.)
This study reports the genetic diversity among Chilean heritage blood-flesh peaches and the characterization of phytochemicals and bioactive compounds present in these fruits. A ge...
Curious Conversations: Henry Mayhew and the Street-Sellers in the Media Ecology of London Labour and the London Poor
Curious Conversations: Henry Mayhew and the Street-Sellers in the Media Ecology of London Labour and the London Poor
Abstract
Henry Mayhew is renowned as the chronicler and historian of London street-sellers and poor labourers. However, Mayhew’s relationships with his subjects, and...