Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Human and man side by side, woman trapped in a different reality: word associations in Czech
View through Europeana Collections
b1_The main objective of the research was to verify the symbolic asymmetry in spontaneous and socially shared representations of gender categories, also on the evaluative dimension in the Czech cultural context. Two hundred and twenty-three undergraduate students (117 males and 106 females, M = 20.5 years old) were asked to freely produce their associations on primes Human, Man and Woman (in randomized order) and to evaluate each of them. Hypotheses. 1. Authors expected a stronger overlap between primes Man and Human than between Woman and Human: a) in overall valence of primes; b) on agency-communion dimensions. 2. They expected overall a more favorable evaluation of Woman than Man. 3. They also expected a greater heterogeneity for Man in comparison with Woman in terms of total number of different words associated with primes. Two sets of analyses were subsequently carried out; the overall valence of words associated with each prime and a categorical analysis specifically targeted at evaluating the extent to which responses to the primes pertained to communion vs. agency. For the former an univariate ANOVA was conducted considering prime (Human vs. Man vs. Woman) and sex of participant (Female vs. Male participant) as between-participants variables. For the latter, a mixed ANOVA was performed on the number of associated words considering prime (Human vs. Man vs. Woman) and sex of participant (Female vs. Male participant) as between-participants variables and attributes (Agency vs. Communion) as a within-participants variable. All hypotheses were supported. The results strongly suggest that Czech speakers spontaneously consider Man a higher-level gender. More globally, the study supports the idea of gendersymbolic asymmetry: gender categories do not differ only in their content, status or power, but also in their hierarchical cognitive organizations.
Title: Human and man side by side, woman trapped in a different reality: word associations in Czech
Description:
b1_The main objective of the research was to verify the symbolic asymmetry in spontaneous and socially shared representations of gender categories, also on the evaluative dimension in the Czech cultural context.
Two hundred and twenty-three undergraduate students (117 males and 106 females, M = 20.
5 years old) were asked to freely produce their associations on primes Human, Man and Woman (in randomized order) and to evaluate each of them.
Hypotheses.
1.
Authors expected a stronger overlap between primes Man and Human than between Woman and Human: a) in overall valence of primes; b) on agency-communion dimensions.
2.
They expected overall a more favorable evaluation of Woman than Man.
3.
They also expected a greater heterogeneity for Man in comparison with Woman in terms of total number of different words associated with primes.
Two sets of analyses were subsequently carried out; the overall valence of words associated with each prime and a categorical analysis specifically targeted at evaluating the extent to which responses to the primes pertained to communion vs.
agency.
For the former an univariate ANOVA was conducted considering prime (Human vs.
Man vs.
Woman) and sex of participant (Female vs.
Male participant) as between-participants variables.
For the latter, a mixed ANOVA was performed on the number of associated words considering prime (Human vs.
Man vs.
Woman) and sex of participant (Female vs.
Male participant) as between-participants variables and attributes (Agency vs.
Communion) as a within-participants variable.
All hypotheses were supported.
The results strongly suggest that Czech speakers spontaneously consider Man a higher-level gender.
More globally, the study supports the idea of gendersymbolic asymmetry: gender categories do not differ only in their content, status or power, but also in their hierarchical cognitive organizations.
Related Results
Temporal structure of repetition disfluencies in American English
Temporal structure of repetition disfluencies in American English
A repetition disfluency involves an interruption in the flow of speech followed by a restart, leading to repetition of one or more words. We analyzed the temporal structure of one-...
The Word ‘Noor’: Tracing a Long Journey through Translation and Adaptation from Classical Arabic to Contemporary Punjabi/Hindi Pop Songs
The Word ‘Noor’: Tracing a Long Journey through Translation and Adaptation from Classical Arabic to Contemporary Punjabi/Hindi Pop Songs
In contemporary India, through popular Punjabi, Bollywood songs, we often come across the word “Noor” (tere chehre ka noor etc.) in reference to a female beauty most of the times. ...
Will parties help themselves? The role of women associations in Czech parliamentary parties
Will parties help themselves? The role of women associations in Czech parliamentary parties
The aim of this article is to fill in the gap in research focusing on the problem of the political participation of women in the Czech Republic. Based on text and interview analysi...
Every Word is a Name: Autonymy and Quotation in Augustine
Every Word is a Name: Autonymy and Quotation in Augustine
AbstractAugustine famously claims every word is a name. Some readers take Augustine to thereby maintain a purely referentialist semantic account according to which every word is a ...
The decline of the Greek myth of man and being
The decline of the Greek myth of man and being
Modern philosophy is forced to return to the question of “what is philosophy?” Does it need to be understood as the science of being or a science about man? M. Heidegger believes t...
Spatial and temporal thresholds in installation art: Jan van der Merwe’s Eclipse
Spatial and temporal thresholds in installation art: Jan van der Merwe’s Eclipse
The notion of thresholds and their potential to suggest liminality is usually associated with spatialities. However, I contend this notion can be extended to layered temporal thres...
Boundaries: an Interdisciplinary (Hi)Story
Boundaries: an Interdisciplinary (Hi)Story
The experience and awareness of boundaries forms an integral part of being human. This article investigates the systematic philosophical underpinnings of our understanding of the n...
The Serpent and the Dove
The Serpent and the Dove
In his essay ‘The Simple Art of Murder’, Raymond Chandler describes the world of the American detective story as ‘a world in which gangsters can rule nations and almost rule cities...