Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Aberration of the citation

View through CrossRef
Multiple inherent biases related to different citation practices (for e.g., self-citations, negative citations, wrong citations, multi-authorship-biased citations, honorary citations, circumstantial citations, discriminatory citations, selective and arbitrary citations, etc.) make citation-based bibliometrics strongly flawed and defective measures. A paper can be highly cited for a while (for e.g., under circumstantial or transitional knowledge), but years later it may appear that its findings, paradigms, or theories were untrue or invalid anymore. By contrast, a paper may remain shelved or overlooked for years or decades, but new studies or discoveries may actualize its subject at any moment. As citation-based metrics are transformed into "commercial activities," the "citation credit" should be considered on a commercial basis too, in the sense that "citation credit" should be shared out as a "citation dividend" by shareholders (coauthors) averagely or proportionally to their contributions but not fully appropriated by each of them. At equal numbers of citations, the greater number of authors, the lower "citation credit" should be and vice versa. Overlooking the presence of distorted and subjective citation practices makes many people and administrators "obsessed" with the number of citations to such an extent to run after "highly cited" authors and to create specialized citation databases for commercial purposes. Citation-based bibliometrics, however, are unreliable and unscientific measures; citation counts do not mean that a more cited work is of a higher quality or accuracy than a less cited work because citations do not measure the quality or accuracy. Citations do not mean that a highly cited author or journal is more commendable than a less cited author or journal. Citations are not more than countable numbers: no more, no less.
California Digital Library (CDL)
Title: Aberration of the citation
Description:
Multiple inherent biases related to different citation practices (for e.
g.
, self-citations, negative citations, wrong citations, multi-authorship-biased citations, honorary citations, circumstantial citations, discriminatory citations, selective and arbitrary citations, etc.
) make citation-based bibliometrics strongly flawed and defective measures.
A paper can be highly cited for a while (for e.
g.
, under circumstantial or transitional knowledge), but years later it may appear that its findings, paradigms, or theories were untrue or invalid anymore.
By contrast, a paper may remain shelved or overlooked for years or decades, but new studies or discoveries may actualize its subject at any moment.
As citation-based metrics are transformed into "commercial activities," the "citation credit" should be considered on a commercial basis too, in the sense that "citation credit" should be shared out as a "citation dividend" by shareholders (coauthors) averagely or proportionally to their contributions but not fully appropriated by each of them.
At equal numbers of citations, the greater number of authors, the lower "citation credit" should be and vice versa.
Overlooking the presence of distorted and subjective citation practices makes many people and administrators "obsessed" with the number of citations to such an extent to run after "highly cited" authors and to create specialized citation databases for commercial purposes.
Citation-based bibliometrics, however, are unreliable and unscientific measures; citation counts do not mean that a more cited work is of a higher quality or accuracy than a less cited work because citations do not measure the quality or accuracy.
Citations do not mean that a highly cited author or journal is more commendable than a less cited author or journal.
Citations are not more than countable numbers: no more, no less.

Related Results

Effect of chromatic aberration on performance of concentrated multi-junction solar cells and their optimization
Effect of chromatic aberration on performance of concentrated multi-junction solar cells and their optimization
In order to investigate the influence of the chromatic aberration on the performance of multi-junction solar cells, the performance of the triple-junction GaInP/GaInAs/Ge solar cel...
Evaluation of residual aberration in fifth-order geometrical aberration correctors
Evaluation of residual aberration in fifth-order geometrical aberration correctors
Abstract Higher order geometrical aberration correctors for transmission electron microscopes are essential for atomic-resolution imaging, especially at low-accel...
Numerical simulation of effect of pump distribution on spherical aberration of end-pumped laser
Numerical simulation of effect of pump distribution on spherical aberration of end-pumped laser
In order to study the spherical aberration of thermal lens when the laser crystal is pumped with the pump light distributed differently and the pump light under the end-pumping con...
Prevalence and Consequences of Anomalous Citation Styles in Ethiopian Academic Journals
Prevalence and Consequences of Anomalous Citation Styles in Ethiopian Academic Journals
Abstract Background Study investigating the prevalence of citation inaccuracies occurring due to intentional misuse or failed quality control has been growing, but citatio...
Aberration control by high NA focusing in transparent media
Aberration control by high NA focusing in transparent media
High numerical aperture (NA) focusing of light in transparent media is important in microscopy, various techniques of optical data storage and laser microprocessing. By high NA foc...
Novel multiple field of view detection method for the off-axis reflection zoom optical system
Novel multiple field of view detection method for the off-axis reflection zoom optical system
In order to study the computer-aided alignment for the off-axis reflective zoom optical system, the wavefront aberration of the off-axis reflective zoom system across the field of ...
Author self-citation in orthodontics is associated with author origin and gender
Author self-citation in orthodontics is associated with author origin and gender
Abstract Background The aims of this bibliometric study were to determine author self-citation trends in high-impact orthodontic literature and to i...

Back to Top