Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Why the Single State Conception Does Not Solve the Problem of Phenomenal Unity
View through CrossRef
This chapter discusses a common conception of phenomenal unity, the single state conception (SSC). The intuition underlying SSC is that phenomenal unity goes along with the existence of a single conscious state that encompasses all of the subject’s phenomenal parts. A prominent example of SSC is Tim Bayne’s mereological account of phenomenal unity. It is argued that SSC does not solve the problem of phenomenal unity (PPU). Instead, it raises questions which pose additional problems. Moreover, these problems do not help to make progress on PPU, but can be regarded as red herrings.
Title: Why the Single State Conception Does Not Solve the Problem of Phenomenal Unity
Description:
This chapter discusses a common conception of phenomenal unity, the single state conception (SSC).
The intuition underlying SSC is that phenomenal unity goes along with the existence of a single conscious state that encompasses all of the subject’s phenomenal parts.
A prominent example of SSC is Tim Bayne’s mereological account of phenomenal unity.
It is argued that SSC does not solve the problem of phenomenal unity (PPU).
Instead, it raises questions which pose additional problems.
Moreover, these problems do not help to make progress on PPU, but can be regarded as red herrings.
Related Results
Empirical Evidence Against Phenomenal Theses
Empirical Evidence Against Phenomenal Theses
<p>Classical anti-physicalist reasoning about phenomenal consciousness involves two related theses: (1) phenomenal consciousness exists, and (2) the existence of phenomenal c...
Experienced Wholeness
Experienced Wholeness
An interdisciplinary account of phenomenal unity, investigating how experiential wholes can be characterized and how such characterizations can be analyzed computationally.
...
Think Globally, Experience Locally?
Think Globally, Experience Locally?
This chapter explores how accounts of phenomenal unity can not only satisfy the phenomenality constraint, but also a version of globality. Global phenomenal unity could then be cal...
The problem of consciousness: an assessment of Michael Tye’s and David Chalmers’ criticisms of the phenomenal concept strategy
The problem of consciousness: an assessment of Michael Tye’s and David Chalmers’ criticisms of the phenomenal concept strategy
This paper presents a critical assessment of Michael Tye’s and David Chalmers’ criticisms of the phenomenal concept strategy. The assessment is done with a view to defend the pheno...
Phenomenal Belief, Phenomenal Concepts, and Phenomenal Properties in a Two-Dimensional Framework
Phenomenal Belief, Phenomenal Concepts, and Phenomenal Properties in a Two-Dimensional Framework
Abstract
Peter, who is looking at the cloudless sky during the day, and Eve, who is looking at a painting of Yves Klein, have something in common. They both have a v...
Framing the Problem of Phenomenal Unity (PPU)
Framing the Problem of Phenomenal Unity (PPU)
This chapter lays the conceptual foundation for the rest of the book. The problem of phenomenal unity (PPU) is defined and a general path to its solution is proposed. Apart from th...
Matter, Fields, Dark Matter and Dark Energy in a New Phenomenal Ontology
Matter, Fields, Dark Matter and Dark Energy in a New Phenomenal Ontology
Contemporary physics distinguishes between physical bodies, fields, dark matter, and dark energy as fundamentally different constituents of physical reality. While this classificat...
Cost-Effectiveness of Folic Acid Supplementation Strategies for Preventing Neural Tube Defects in Ethiopia: A Markov Model Analysis
Cost-Effectiveness of Folic Acid Supplementation Strategies for Preventing Neural Tube Defects in Ethiopia: A Markov Model Analysis
Abstract
Background
Neural tube defects (NTDs) are congenital malformations of the brain and spinal cord that result from the incomplete development of the central nervous...

