New Guidelines for Clinical Stage I Testicular Seminoma?

Clinical stage I (CS I) seminoma has been the subject of various studies aimed at finding the ideal treatment. Due to its high radiosensitivity, radiotherapy has been the standard approach for decades. However, the fact that CS I seminoma has a recurrence rate of only 15–20% has prompted many suggestions for better treatment stratification offering surveillance therapy for a subgroup of patients. Moreover, carboplatinum-based monochemotherapy has been the topic of various retrospective studies demonstrating equal effectiveness for adjuvant chemotherapy with one cycle of carboplatin. Since seminoma affects men in their mid-30s, only few reports have been published on long-term survival with reference to radiotoxicity and secondary malignancies. Long-term side effects and secondary malignancies pose an increasing problem for long-term survivors of primary malignancies treated by chemo- or radiotherapy. This becomes evident after a follow-up of 15 years. Since recent studies have disclosed unexpectedly high long-term morbidity and mortality after irradiation, this article critically reviews the value of radiotherapy and carboplatinum-based chemotherapy as equally effective treatment options for CS I seminoma.