Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Application of Balint Intervention Groups in Professional Communication in Medical Science Education
View through CrossRef
Dear Editor
The purpose of this research is to familiarize professors and students of medical sciences with the concept of Balint groups. Michael Balint created the Balint groups in 1957 in order to better understand the relationships between family doctors and their patients (1, 2). According to Michael Balint, in addition to medical education, doctors should also have proper communication skills and characteristics with patients (2, 3).
Balint groups are one of the effective methods to improve therapist-client relationships in the form of 90-minute sessions, held weekly to monthly, over several years (4, 5). Each Balint group consists of 6 to 10 members with one to two leaders or facilitators. In these groups, usually, one person presents the desired topic, which can be the condition of a patient, in a period of 3 to 5 minutes, and the desired topic is discussed for an hour or more. All topics discussed in the group are confidential, and the leader emphasizes creating a safe environment that is based on trust and acceptance. The members of the group take turns expressing their opinions on the topic, and finally, the group leader summarizes the opinions, and the final result is obtained (6). Doctors in these groups have meetings to discuss their performance, the psychological aspects of their work, and the relationship between the doctor and the patient (1, 7). One of the goals of Balint groups is to increase one's knowledge by reporting on one's patient, discussing the topic in a safe environment, finding one's mistakes due to the feedback of others, and correcting one's emotional experiences in relation to the patient. Balint group members reveal their innermost feelings and experiences in order to be able to talk about a topic. In this way, members share their content with other group members in a non-judgmental environment. The group members benefit from the feedback of others and compare their experiences with the contents of other colleagues (8). Group discussions about feelings have the benefit of making people more aware of their feelings, thus enabling them to analyze and organize their information. Emotions and feelings in clinical work can be useful for patients if they are tolerated and understood by the doctor (9). Due to the rapid development of technology, the improvement of educational methods, and attention to the needs of patients, the importance of the Balint group should be given more attention due to the change in demographic characteristics (1). As a result, Balint groups have gradually been emphasized in medical education (10). In Balint groups, with the participation of students, the duration is shorter than in normal Balint groups, and the leader may be more active in describing their experiences (11).
The presence of students in Balint groups leads to the development of empathy skills among medical students (12). For example, students are placed in a real and uncomfortable clinical situation to observe their reactions and increase their empathetic abilities, thus becoming more patient-centered (12, 13).
Studies show that doctors who were part of Balint groups during their student period have a higher sense of control and satisfaction in their work environment. Also, these groups improve the skills of giving bad news in students (11). By attending these classes, students can use the professors' experiences with problematic issues in dealing with patients, which they have not observed during their studies. Improving doctor-patient relationships, reducing job burnout, and managing stress and anxiety are other benefits of participating in Balint groups (1). Medical schools should create an environment for students that will lead to progress in their socialization process (14). Therefore, it is suggested that Balint groups be used to improve teacher-student relationships in medical education.
Title: Application of Balint Intervention Groups in Professional Communication in Medical Science Education
Description:
Dear Editor
The purpose of this research is to familiarize professors and students of medical sciences with the concept of Balint groups.
Michael Balint created the Balint groups in 1957 in order to better understand the relationships between family doctors and their patients (1, 2).
According to Michael Balint, in addition to medical education, doctors should also have proper communication skills and characteristics with patients (2, 3).
Balint groups are one of the effective methods to improve therapist-client relationships in the form of 90-minute sessions, held weekly to monthly, over several years (4, 5).
Each Balint group consists of 6 to 10 members with one to two leaders or facilitators.
In these groups, usually, one person presents the desired topic, which can be the condition of a patient, in a period of 3 to 5 minutes, and the desired topic is discussed for an hour or more.
All topics discussed in the group are confidential, and the leader emphasizes creating a safe environment that is based on trust and acceptance.
The members of the group take turns expressing their opinions on the topic, and finally, the group leader summarizes the opinions, and the final result is obtained (6).
Doctors in these groups have meetings to discuss their performance, the psychological aspects of their work, and the relationship between the doctor and the patient (1, 7).
One of the goals of Balint groups is to increase one's knowledge by reporting on one's patient, discussing the topic in a safe environment, finding one's mistakes due to the feedback of others, and correcting one's emotional experiences in relation to the patient.
Balint group members reveal their innermost feelings and experiences in order to be able to talk about a topic.
In this way, members share their content with other group members in a non-judgmental environment.
The group members benefit from the feedback of others and compare their experiences with the contents of other colleagues (8).
Group discussions about feelings have the benefit of making people more aware of their feelings, thus enabling them to analyze and organize their information.
Emotions and feelings in clinical work can be useful for patients if they are tolerated and understood by the doctor (9).
Due to the rapid development of technology, the improvement of educational methods, and attention to the needs of patients, the importance of the Balint group should be given more attention due to the change in demographic characteristics (1).
As a result, Balint groups have gradually been emphasized in medical education (10).
In Balint groups, with the participation of students, the duration is shorter than in normal Balint groups, and the leader may be more active in describing their experiences (11).
The presence of students in Balint groups leads to the development of empathy skills among medical students (12).
For example, students are placed in a real and uncomfortable clinical situation to observe their reactions and increase their empathetic abilities, thus becoming more patient-centered (12, 13).
Studies show that doctors who were part of Balint groups during their student period have a higher sense of control and satisfaction in their work environment.
Also, these groups improve the skills of giving bad news in students (11).
By attending these classes, students can use the professors' experiences with problematic issues in dealing with patients, which they have not observed during their studies.
Improving doctor-patient relationships, reducing job burnout, and managing stress and anxiety are other benefits of participating in Balint groups (1).
Medical schools should create an environment for students that will lead to progress in their socialization process (14).
Therefore, it is suggested that Balint groups be used to improve teacher-student relationships in medical education.
Related Results
Effect of Balint Group on Burnout and Self-efficacy of Nurse Leaders in China: A Randomised Controlled Trial
Effect of Balint Group on Burnout and Self-efficacy of Nurse Leaders in China: A Randomised Controlled Trial
Abstract
Background: Burnout is common among nurses and is related to negative outcomes of medical care. This study aimed to explore the effectiveness of Balint group activ...
Positive effect of Balint group on burnout and self-efficacy of head nurses in China: a randomized controlled trial
Positive effect of Balint group on burnout and self-efficacy of head nurses in China: a randomized controlled trial
BackgroundBurnout is common among nurses and can lead to negative outcomes of medical care. This study aimed to explore the effectiveness of Balint groups to reduce burnout in head...
Balint-Psychodrama – Die Bedeutung des Körpers in der
Balint-Arbeit*
Balint-Psychodrama – Die Bedeutung des Körpers in der
Balint-Arbeit*
Zusammenfassung
Der Autor gibt einem kurzen Überblick über den Stellenwert des
Körpers in Freuds Gedanken und die Bedeutung, die Michael Balin...
Die Deutsche Balint-Gesellschaft The International Balint Federation (IBF)
Die Deutsche Balint-Gesellschaft The International Balint Federation (IBF)
Preis-Ausschreibung Deutscher Balint-Preis für Studierende 2020
Die Deutsche Balint Gesellschaft e. V. schreibt alle 2 Jahre einen Balint-Preis
...
Die Bedeutung der Balint-Arbeit in Zeiten des Umbruchs in der
Medizin
Die Bedeutung der Balint-Arbeit in Zeiten des Umbruchs in der
Medizin
Zusammenfassung
In den letzten 25 Jahren haben die meisten Länder der westlichen Welt
tiefgreifende Veränderungen ihrer Gesundheitssysteme erf...
Przestępca zawodowy
Przestępca zawodowy
The article seeks to sum up all that has been said on the subject of professional criminality in the past half-century. It was never any part of the author’s aim to offer an analy...
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE LAW "PROFESSIONAL PRELIMINARY EDUCATION" IN IVANO-FRANKIVSK NATIONAL MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE LAW "PROFESSIONAL PRELIMINARY EDUCATION" IN IVANO-FRANKIVSK NATIONAL MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
June 6. 2019, Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine implemented the Law "Professional preliminary Education". The law defines the procedure, conditions, forms and features of obtaining profess...
Balint groups: an Australasian perspective for psychiatrists
Balint groups: an Australasian perspective for psychiatrists
Objective:
This paper aims to provide a brief overview of the history and scope of the Balint movement; to outline how Balint groups work; to describe what is e...

