Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Punk music and social criticism in Indonesia. The controversy of the song Bayar Bayar Bayar and the institutional response
View through CrossRef
The song Bayar Bayar Bayar by the punk band Sukatani sparked controversy in Indonesia, showing how punk music has become a tool of social criticism of economic policies and structural injustices. This issue is important in the broader discourse on cultural censorship, freedom of expression, and the role of institutions in responding to social criticism through music. This research aims to analyze the meaning of the song's lyrics, public and media reactions, and institutional responses to them. Using a qualitative method with critical discourse analysis, this study examines media texts, audiovisual recordings, and interviews with academics. The results of the analysis show that punk music remains a form of resistance to state hegemony, despite facing censorship and silencing. Thus, the repressive response to music with social criticism strengthens the song's appeal as a symbol of resistance. This study emphasizes the need for more inclusive cultural policies, as well as more open dialogue between artists and institutions to accommodate freedom of expression in public spaces.
Universidad Rey Juan Carlos
Title: Punk music and social criticism in Indonesia. The controversy of the song Bayar Bayar Bayar and the institutional response
Description:
The song Bayar Bayar Bayar by the punk band Sukatani sparked controversy in Indonesia, showing how punk music has become a tool of social criticism of economic policies and structural injustices.
This issue is important in the broader discourse on cultural censorship, freedom of expression, and the role of institutions in responding to social criticism through music.
This research aims to analyze the meaning of the song's lyrics, public and media reactions, and institutional responses to them.
Using a qualitative method with critical discourse analysis, this study examines media texts, audiovisual recordings, and interviews with academics.
The results of the analysis show that punk music remains a form of resistance to state hegemony, despite facing censorship and silencing.
Thus, the repressive response to music with social criticism strengthens the song's appeal as a symbol of resistance.
This study emphasizes the need for more inclusive cultural policies, as well as more open dialogue between artists and institutions to accommodate freedom of expression in public spaces.
Related Results
Musical protagonism: Beyond participation in punk and post-punk
Musical protagonism: Beyond participation in punk and post-punk
Abstract
This article applies the notion of participation in artworks to the phenomenon of punk and post-punk. Participation has been championed as a means of descri...
Punk is punk but by no means punk: Definition, genre evasion and the quest for an authentic voice in contemporary Russia
Punk is punk but by no means punk: Definition, genre evasion and the quest for an authentic voice in contemporary Russia
At a recent London seminar on punk in post-socialist Eastern Europe, Penny Rimbaud made an unexpected twist to definitions, stating simply that punk ‘isn’t’. He posits punk as the ...
Music and Mysticism
Music and Mysticism
The word “mystic” has a common meaning in philosophical traditions like neo-Platonism and religions (Hindu, Jewish, Christian, and Muslim)—namely the elevation of a human being to ...
Rebelling in different ways: Older punk women, employment and ‘being/doing’ punk
Rebelling in different ways: Older punk women, employment and ‘being/doing’ punk
How do older women negotiate employment and the workplace alongside being and ‘doing’ punk? This article takes this question as its focus, exploring three key areas that a sample o...
The afterlife of punk: Evental sites of punk 771
The afterlife of punk: Evental sites of punk 771
Building on the argument of my previous article ‘Autonomy and agency: The event of punk 77’, this article defends the continuing political relevance of punk. Rejecting the dominant...
Putting the ‘punk’ back into pop-punk: Analysing presentations of deviance in pop-punk music
Putting the ‘punk’ back into pop-punk: Analysing presentations of deviance in pop-punk music
Writing on pop-punk, the melodic branch of punk that rose to fame in the mid-to-late-1990s, usually centres on the pop aspect of the genre: its popularity, polished sound and comme...
Owner Bound Music: A study of popular sheet music selling and music making in the New Zealand home 1840-1940
Owner Bound Music: A study of popular sheet music selling and music making in the New Zealand home 1840-1940
<p>From 1840, when New Zealand became part of the British Empire, until 1940 when the nation celebrated its Centennial, the piano was the most dominant instrument in domestic...
Perlindungan Hukum Seniman Sukatani atas Lagu Bayar Bayar Bayar ditinjau dari Instrumen HAM Internasional dan Nasional
Perlindungan Hukum Seniman Sukatani atas Lagu Bayar Bayar Bayar ditinjau dari Instrumen HAM Internasional dan Nasional
Abstract. Songs are a medium of expression that falls under the right to freedom of opinion and expression, which is clearly recognized in various human rights legal instruments, b...

