Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Sketching Under the Influence? Winsor McCay and the Question of Aesthetic Convergence Between Comic Strips and Film
View through CrossRef
The formal similarities between comic strips and film have often sparked a contentious debate about aesthetic intersections between the two mediums as well as discussions of influence. Comic historian David Kunzle, drawing from the work of Francis Lacassin, has described how characteristics of film form can be traced back to comic strips of the mid to late 1800s. Film historian Donald Crafton, on the other hand, posits that comic strips had little, if any, influence over the evolution of film language. Analyzing both Winsor McCay’s comic strips and animated adaptations, this article hopes to utilize historically informed textual analysis to complicate the question of aesthetic influence.
Title: Sketching Under the Influence? Winsor McCay and the Question of Aesthetic Convergence Between Comic Strips and Film
Description:
The formal similarities between comic strips and film have often sparked a contentious debate about aesthetic intersections between the two mediums as well as discussions of influence.
Comic historian David Kunzle, drawing from the work of Francis Lacassin, has described how characteristics of film form can be traced back to comic strips of the mid to late 1800s.
Film historian Donald Crafton, on the other hand, posits that comic strips had little, if any, influence over the evolution of film language.
Analyzing both Winsor McCay’s comic strips and animated adaptations, this article hopes to utilize historically informed textual analysis to complicate the question of aesthetic influence.
Related Results
The Making and Re-making of Winsor McCay’s Gertie (1914)
The Making and Re-making of Winsor McCay’s Gertie (1914)
In addition to creating legendary comics like Little Nemo in Slumberland, Winsor McCay was a pioneer of animation. His Gertie (1914) was the first American masterpiece of animated ...
Reclaiming the Wasteland: Samson and Delilah and the Historical Perception and Construction of Indigenous Knowledges in Australian Cinema
Reclaiming the Wasteland: Samson and Delilah and the Historical Perception and Construction of Indigenous Knowledges in Australian Cinema
It was always based on a teenage love story between the two kids. One is a sniffer and one is not. It was designed for Central Australia because we do write these kids off there. N...
Lehekoomiks 1990. aastate Eestis [Newspaper comic strips in Estonia during the 1990s]
Lehekoomiks 1990. aastate Eestis [Newspaper comic strips in Estonia during the 1990s]
Artikkel iseloomustab ülevaatlikult 1990ndate Eestis siirde aegse ajakirjandusbuumi ning laiema kultuurilise teisenemise osana tek kinud lehekoomiksiribade lainet. Moodsa ja lään...
Alternative Entrances: Phillip Noyce and Sydney’s Counterculture
Alternative Entrances: Phillip Noyce and Sydney’s Counterculture
Phillip Noyce is one of Australia’s most prominent film makers—a successful feature film director with both iconic Australian narratives and many a Hollywood blockbuster under his ...
Phil Winsor (1938–2012)
Phil Winsor (1938–2012)
Gena describes Winsor’s musical and educational philosophy from his work with Winsor in Chicago in the late 1970s, placing Winsor’s background in the San Francisco Tape Music Cente...
The Effectiveness of Longitudinal Rumble Strips on Indiana Roads
The Effectiveness of Longitudinal Rumble Strips on Indiana Roads
Rumble strips are designed and deployed to reduce run-off-road and head-on crashes by alerting drivers about near-lane departures. Although they have been widely used, their operat...
Animations, Comic Books, and Manga
Animations, Comic Books, and Manga
Comic scholarship emerged out of several different arenas, each with its own distinct style and purpose. Some of the first books about comics were written by comic fans who were in...
IMPROVING THE STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION BY USING COMIC STRIPS AT SMA MUHAMMADIYAH-7 SERBELAWAN GRADE XI
IMPROVING THE STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION BY USING COMIC STRIPS AT SMA MUHAMMADIYAH-7 SERBELAWAN GRADE XI
This Research entitled improving the students’ reading comprehension by using comic strips at SMA MUHAMMADIYAH-7 Serbelawan. It concerned with the problem: Does comic strips effect...

