IDENTIFYING THE UNKNOWN SOURCE OF A PRE-RAMEAU HARMONIC THEORIST: WHO WAS ALEXANDER MALCOLM'S MYSTERIOUS GHOSTWRITER?

ABSTRACTAlexander Malcolm (1685–1763) published his monumentalTreatise of Musickin Edinburgh in 1721, one year before Rameau published hisTraité de l'harmonie. Malcolm's was the first important work on music theory published in Scotland, and it established his musical reputation, influencing theorists and historians for almost a hundred years, both in Europe and in the American colonies. Sir John Hawkins deemed it ‘one of the most valuable treatises on the subject of theoretical and practical music to be found in any of the modern languages’. Malcolm's chapter 13 is often cited by music theorists for anticipating the writings of Rameau. However, Malcolm's Introduction states that the thirteenth chapter was communicated to him by a ‘modest’ friend. Identifying this friend necessitated first determining the author(s) of two rare anonymous contemporaneous treatises, remarkably similar to each other, and one nearly identical to Malcolm's chapter 13. Several writers have speculated on possible authors – two in particular, Alexander Baillie and Alexander Bayne – but none has provided actual evidence. This study identifies the author of these two hitherto anonymous treatises: Malcolm's modest friend.