Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
KRITIK ATAS KRITIK IGNAZ GOLDZIHER TENTANG QIRĀ’ĀT
View through CrossRef
Goldziher went to great length to impose the Qur'an as scripture by critisizing the Qirā'āt aspect. He argued that the existence of Qirā'āt was an evidence of inconsistency of the Qur'an in its reading variants. Goldziher also revealed that Muslims previously tried to equate the Qirā'āt, but this was not realized because it was hampered by the lack of punctuation system at that time. This article describes and analyzes some of the scholars' criticisms which has criticized Goldziher's opinion. From the analysis, it is found that Goldziher's argument is not supported by strong evidence and data, and tends to ignore historical data.
Keywords: Qirā'āt, al-Qur`an, Ignaz Golziher, Criticism of opinion
Title: KRITIK ATAS KRITIK IGNAZ GOLDZIHER TENTANG QIRĀ’ĀT
Description:
Goldziher went to great length to impose the Qur'an as scripture by critisizing the Qirā'āt aspect.
He argued that the existence of Qirā'āt was an evidence of inconsistency of the Qur'an in its reading variants.
Goldziher also revealed that Muslims previously tried to equate the Qirā'āt, but this was not realized because it was hampered by the lack of punctuation system at that time.
This article describes and analyzes some of the scholars' criticisms which has criticized Goldziher's opinion.
From the analysis, it is found that Goldziher's argument is not supported by strong evidence and data, and tends to ignore historical data.
Keywords: Qirā'āt, al-Qur`an, Ignaz Golziher, Criticism of opinion.
Related Results
HERMENEUTIKA GRAMATIKAL: Telaah Epistemologi Kitab Faidhul Barākat Fī Sab’il Qira’at Karya K.H. Muhamad Arwani bin Muhamad Amin al-Qudsi
HERMENEUTIKA GRAMATIKAL: Telaah Epistemologi Kitab Faidhul Barākat Fī Sab’il Qira’at Karya K.H. Muhamad Arwani bin Muhamad Amin al-Qudsi
Abstract: This article is aiming at revealing the linguistic aspects of the Qur'anic hermeneutics, in which the tradition of Qira'at (various ways of reading Qur’an) in Islam shows...
M. Hayri Kırbaşoğlu’nun Ignaz Goldziher Savunusuna Eleştirel Bir Yaklaşım (Goldziher’i Anlamak Adlı Çalışması Özelinde)
M. Hayri Kırbaşoğlu’nun Ignaz Goldziher Savunusuna Eleştirel Bir Yaklaşım (Goldziher’i Anlamak Adlı Çalışması Özelinde)
M. Hayri Kırbaşoğlu akademik çalışmalarını hadis alanında yürüten bir araştırmacıdır. O, son çalışmasını ünlü oryantalist Ignaz Goldziher hakkında yapmış, Goldziher’i Anlamak adını...
PERAN IMAM ASY-SYATHIBI DALAM QIRA’AT AL-QUR’AN
PERAN IMAM ASY-SYATHIBI DALAM QIRA’AT AL-QUR’AN
Ilmu qira’at adalah salah satu ilmu yang mempunyai kedudukan tinggi dalam Islam, karena kaitannya dengan kitab suci al-Qur’an. Banyak ulama qira’at yang mendedikasikan diri dalam i...
Analisis Ragam Qirā’at dan Implikasinya terhadap Penafsiran
Analisis Ragam Qirā’at dan Implikasinya terhadap Penafsiran
This paper tries to analyze the influence of the various Qirā’at on the Tafsīr of Al-Jāmi 'Li Ahkām Al-Qur’ān by Imam Al-Qurţubī, the extent to which the Qirā’at implications in th...
Ignaz Goldziher’in Müslümanlara Yaklaşımındaki Tutarsızlıklar Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme
Ignaz Goldziher’in Müslümanlara Yaklaşımındaki Tutarsızlıklar Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme
Ignaz Goldziher, Batı dünyasında İslâm araştırmalarının üstadı kabul edilen, çalışmalarıyla Müslüman ve Batılı araştırmacıları etkileyen bir ilim insanıdır. O, bazı Müslümanlara it...
QIRA’AT AL-QUR’AN DALAM SEKILAS PANDANGAN EKONOMI ISLAM
QIRA’AT AL-QUR’AN DALAM SEKILAS PANDANGAN EKONOMI ISLAM
Pentingnya mengetahui macammacam dan syaratsyarat Qira`at yang dapat diterima, agar terhindar campurnya Qira`at yang mutawatir dengan yang tidak, di samping itu juga untuk menambah...
Metode Pemaparan Qirâ’at dalam Tafsir Fath Al-Qadir oleh Imam Al-Syaukâni
Metode Pemaparan Qirâ’at dalam Tafsir Fath Al-Qadir oleh Imam Al-Syaukâni
This article is entitled the method of explaining Qirâ'at in the book of commentary on Fath al-Qadir by Imam al-Syaukâni. In interpreting the Qur'an, al-Syaukâni also very often us...
Qiro'atil Qur'an
Qiro'atil Qur'an
Qira’at adalah perbedaan cara mengucapkan lafazh-lafazh Al-Quran yang baik menyankut hurufnya atau cara pengucapan huruf-huruf.Qira’at memiliki bermacam-macam, yakni Qira’at sab’ah...