Javascript must be enabled to continue!
‘The Only Thing “Womanish” is the Composer’: Music at Nineteenth-Century Exhibitions of Women’s Work
View through CrossRef
Abstract
The 1880s saw a burgeoning of exhibitions of ‘Women’s Work’ across the world. These events focused on the artistic and industrial abilities of women, signifying an unprecedented shift away from the emphasis usually placed on maleness and masculinized technology in contemporary exhibition culture. The first Exhibition, held in Bristol in 1885, included a musical novelty: a concert entirely of works composed by women. The next, in Sydney in 1888, included a whole series of such concerts. These concerts—containing works by Kate Loder, Clara Wieck, Fanny Hensel, Agnes Zimmermann, and Maude Valérie White—were extraordinarily well received, applauded in both concept and execution. Yet, their reception appears paradoxical against the contemporary critical climate. In both Britain and Australia, the ‘question’ of women composers was widely debated, and works met with condescension or hostility. By exploring the expectations surrounding displays of ‘women’s work’, I argue that it was the exhibition context itself that influenced the reception of this music. While Exhibitions were conventionally seen as male-gendered events, ‘Women’s’ Exhibitions allowed organizers to blur the distinctions between private and public space. Similarly, while women composers were criticized for their encroachment in the male concert sphere, these Exhibitions also blurred these boundaries and gave critics an appropriate ‘feminine’ framework through which to view and critique the works.
Title: ‘The Only Thing “Womanish” is the Composer’: Music at Nineteenth-Century Exhibitions of Women’s Work
Description:
Abstract
The 1880s saw a burgeoning of exhibitions of ‘Women’s Work’ across the world.
These events focused on the artistic and industrial abilities of women, signifying an unprecedented shift away from the emphasis usually placed on maleness and masculinized technology in contemporary exhibition culture.
The first Exhibition, held in Bristol in 1885, included a musical novelty: a concert entirely of works composed by women.
The next, in Sydney in 1888, included a whole series of such concerts.
These concerts—containing works by Kate Loder, Clara Wieck, Fanny Hensel, Agnes Zimmermann, and Maude Valérie White—were extraordinarily well received, applauded in both concept and execution.
Yet, their reception appears paradoxical against the contemporary critical climate.
In both Britain and Australia, the ‘question’ of women composers was widely debated, and works met with condescension or hostility.
By exploring the expectations surrounding displays of ‘women’s work’, I argue that it was the exhibition context itself that influenced the reception of this music.
While Exhibitions were conventionally seen as male-gendered events, ‘Women’s’ Exhibitions allowed organizers to blur the distinctions between private and public space.
Similarly, while women composers were criticized for their encroachment in the male concert sphere, these Exhibitions also blurred these boundaries and gave critics an appropriate ‘feminine’ framework through which to view and critique the works.
Related Results
Retuning music teaching: Online music tutorials preferences as predictors of amateur musicians’ music self-efficacy in informal music learning
Retuning music teaching: Online music tutorials preferences as predictors of amateur musicians’ music self-efficacy in informal music learning
Music self-efficacy has been acknowledged as a strong predictor of successful performance among musicians and music students, but is less researched among amateur musicians. The pu...
Pop and world music in Dutch music education: two cases of authentic learning in music teacher education and secondary music education
Pop and world music in Dutch music education: two cases of authentic learning in music teacher education and secondary music education
Popular and world music play an important role in Dutch music education. This article examines two case studies that illustrate authentic music learning environments in which these...
Music and communication in music psychology
Music and communication in music psychology
There is a general consensus that music is both universal and communicative, and musical dialogue is a key element in much music-therapeutic practice. However, the idea that music ...
Tempo in Baroque Music and Dance
Tempo in Baroque Music and Dance
Growing interest in studies on the relationship between music and movement has given rise to many paradigms and theories, including embodied approaches that provide interesting met...
Integrating popular music and informal music learning practices: A multiple case study of secondary school music teachers enacting change in music education
Integrating popular music and informal music learning practices: A multiple case study of secondary school music teachers enacting change in music education
The purpose of this multiple case study was to examine the practices and perspectives of four music teachers who integrated popular music and informal music learning practices into...
The gendered carnival of pop
The gendered carnival of pop
One of the ironies of popular music studies is that the music that is the most popular, in terms of contemporary chart success, is rarely discussed by academics writing in the fiel...
Music therapy for people with chronic pain: facilitators and barriers.
Music therapy for people with chronic pain: facilitators and barriers.
The aim of this study was to investigate the perceptions of music therapy among those living with chronic pain, and the possible facilitators and barriers to music therapy if offer...
Psychophysiological Responses to “Happy” and “Sad” Music
Psychophysiological Responses to “Happy” and “Sad” Music
Lundqvist, Carlsson, Hilmersson, and Juslin (2009) presented evidence of differential autonomic emotional responses to “happy” and “sad” music in healthy adult listeners. The prese...