Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Developments in the prevention and punishment of genocide after Rwanda: Actors, approaches and challenges
View through CrossRef
In February 2022 the Russian Federation launched special military operations in Ukraine, alleging that the latter was committing genocide against the Russian-speaking population in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions, also known as ‘the Donbas’. This led Ukraine to file an application instituting proceedings against the Federation at the International Court of Justice for provisional measures to suspend such operations. It also denied Russia’s accusations of genocide. In the 1990s, Rwandan exiled Tutsis launched an attack to recapture power in their country, resulting in genocide. After lengthy court proceedings, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda determined that genocide had been committed against the Rwandan Tutsis. Thereafter, and despite the Tribunal’s thought-through decisions and judgments, Rwanda’s President Kagame undertook a deceptive campaign, warning of impending genocide in Burundi in 2015, prompting the African Union to decide to deploy troops to prevent such atrocities. Burundi denied any threat of genocide. Also, since 1996, Rwanda has, on numerous occasions, intervened militarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo to, allegedly, prevent genocide against the Banyamulenge, also of Tutsi ethnicity. While international judicial institutions have laboured to ascertain the elements that constitute genocide, irresponsible claims of genocide continue to capture attention. Based on the relevant literature that addresses this burning issue, and some decisions and judgments of the United Nations ad hoc tribunals for Rwanda and the Former Yugoslavia, as well as those of the Extraordinary Chamber in the Courts of Cambodia, this article looks beyond the claim of genocide in the ongoing armed conflicts in the Great Lakes region and between Ukraine and the Russian Federation. The reality is that this claim is made by political leaders in a bid to serve their political agendas, despite legal efforts to clarify the legal requirements for a crime to be characterised as genocide. The article recommends the adoption of a supplementary convention that would reemphasise the requirements that any claims of genocide must meet to prevent its abuse and misuse, including in political discourses.
Juta and Company (Pty) Ltd
Title: Developments in the prevention and punishment of genocide after Rwanda: Actors, approaches and challenges
Description:
In February 2022 the Russian Federation launched special military operations in Ukraine, alleging that the latter was committing genocide against the Russian-speaking population in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions, also known as ‘the Donbas’.
This led Ukraine to file an application instituting proceedings against the Federation at the International Court of Justice for provisional measures to suspend such operations.
It also denied Russia’s accusations of genocide.
In the 1990s, Rwandan exiled Tutsis launched an attack to recapture power in their country, resulting in genocide.
After lengthy court proceedings, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda determined that genocide had been committed against the Rwandan Tutsis.
Thereafter, and despite the Tribunal’s thought-through decisions and judgments, Rwanda’s President Kagame undertook a deceptive campaign, warning of impending genocide in Burundi in 2015, prompting the African Union to decide to deploy troops to prevent such atrocities.
Burundi denied any threat of genocide.
Also, since 1996, Rwanda has, on numerous occasions, intervened militarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo to, allegedly, prevent genocide against the Banyamulenge, also of Tutsi ethnicity.
While international judicial institutions have laboured to ascertain the elements that constitute genocide, irresponsible claims of genocide continue to capture attention.
Based on the relevant literature that addresses this burning issue, and some decisions and judgments of the United Nations ad hoc tribunals for Rwanda and the Former Yugoslavia, as well as those of the Extraordinary Chamber in the Courts of Cambodia, this article looks beyond the claim of genocide in the ongoing armed conflicts in the Great Lakes region and between Ukraine and the Russian Federation.
The reality is that this claim is made by political leaders in a bid to serve their political agendas, despite legal efforts to clarify the legal requirements for a crime to be characterised as genocide.
The article recommends the adoption of a supplementary convention that would reemphasise the requirements that any claims of genocide must meet to prevent its abuse and misuse, including in political discourses.
Related Results
History of Genocides
History of Genocides
The textbook presents the mass killings and other atrocities that have occurred worldwide and have been defined as genocide by international tribunals, other international bodies, ...
Advancing Public Health in Rwanda through the Field Epidemiology Training Program
Advancing Public Health in Rwanda through the Field Epidemiology Training Program
We are pleased to present the latest edition of the Journal of Interventional Epidemiology and Public Health (JIEPH) special supplement featuring articles from the Rwanda Field Epi...
Cases Studied in <em>Genocide Studies and Prevention</em> and <em>Journal of Genocide Research</em> and Implications for the Field of Genocide Studies
Cases Studied in <em>Genocide Studies and Prevention</em> and <em>Journal of Genocide Research</em> and Implications for the Field of Genocide Studies
The adoption of the Genocide Convention in 1948 was accompanied by the emergence of genocide as a field of study, first in the form of Holocaust Studies, followed by Genocide Studi...
The Foundations of Constitutional Punishment
The Foundations of Constitutional Punishment
The recent Supreme Court decision in Brown v. Plata once again shows that analysis of the constitutionality of punishment tends to be reactive by focusing on constitutional violati...
Cultural Genocide in Law and Politics
Cultural Genocide in Law and Politics
The violent and nonviolent repression of cultural groups, or using cultural means to destroy a group, is often identified as “cultural genocide.” The concept’s association with gen...
The probabilistic pool punishment proportional to the difference of payoff outperforms previous pool and peer punishment
The probabilistic pool punishment proportional to the difference of payoff outperforms previous pool and peer punishment
AbstractThe public goods game is a multiplayer version of the prisoner’s dilemma game. In the public goods game, punishment on defectors is necessary to encourage cooperation. Ther...
The Return of Cultural Genocide?
The Return of Cultural Genocide?
Today, cultural genocide and the protection of cultural groups return to occupy criminal international law. Most writers see it as a new problem in need of normative solution. In t...
Why Prevention Fails: Chronicling the Genocide in Artsakh
Why Prevention Fails: Chronicling the Genocide in Artsakh
Azerbaijan’s September 19, 2023 attack on the Republic of Artsakh resulted in the almost total displacement of the indigenous Armenian population, making it one of the most success...

