Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Back to the Fourth Amendment
View through CrossRef
<p><span>Does the Fourth Amendment protect against governmental seizures of digital property? The answer depends on what constitutes a meaningful interference with digital property. <i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> looks at the adoption of the Fourth Amendment and the Founders’ intentional choice to use two separate words, search and seizure, to protect against governmental overreach. <i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> advances an approach to the seizure analysis that protects against seizures of digital property—by looking at whether the government’s access meaningfully interfered with the owner’s right to exclude, historically recognized as a possessory interest.</span></p>
<p><span>The Fourth Amendment was adopted in response to “reviled ‘general warrants’ and ‘writs of assistance’ of the colonial era” to prohibit the government from rummaging through “persons, houses, papers, and effects” without either probable cause or the search at least being reasonable. The government’s ability to remotely access and copy each individual’s digital footprint without such a warrant supported by probable cause risks the Fourth Amendment’s words no longer carrying even a fraction of the weight that they were intended to. In <i>Katz v. United States</i>, the Court recognized that the physical intrusion test is no longer the sole method in which the government conducts a search. Governmental seizures also look substantially different today compared to when the Fourth Amendment was adopted.</span></p>
<p><span>The Founders were careful to choose words that carved out narrow bounds in their adoption of the Fourth Amendment—to strike the balance of effective governmental operation without societal oppression. Looking at the owner’s right to exclude individuals from accessing digital data is necessary to assure both sides of the Fourth Amendment scale remain in the air. <i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> proceeds in three parts. Part I discusses the purpose of the Fourth Amendment to show that its history supports an understanding of seizure doctrine that continues to protect possessory interests in a digital world. Part II lays out current search and seizure doctrines and how each has evolved—or not evolved—with technological advancements. Part III then advances a technologically-neutral approach to the Fourth Amendment’s current seizure of property test to sufficiently protect against governmental overreach that the Founders were concerned would permeate society.</span></p>
Title: Back to the Fourth Amendment
Description:
<p><span>Does the Fourth Amendment protect against governmental seizures of digital property? The answer depends on what constitutes a meaningful interference with digital property.
<i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> looks at the adoption of the Fourth Amendment and the Founders’ intentional choice to use two separate words, search and seizure, to protect against governmental overreach.
<i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> advances an approach to the seizure analysis that protects against seizures of digital property—by looking at whether the government’s access meaningfully interfered with the owner’s right to exclude, historically recognized as a possessory interest.
</span></p>
<p><span>The Fourth Amendment was adopted in response to “reviled ‘general warrants’ and ‘writs of assistance’ of the colonial era” to prohibit the government from rummaging through “persons, houses, papers, and effects” without either probable cause or the search at least being reasonable.
The government’s ability to remotely access and copy each individual’s digital footprint without such a warrant supported by probable cause risks the Fourth Amendment’s words no longer carrying even a fraction of the weight that they were intended to.
In <i>Katz v.
United States</i>, the Court recognized that the physical intrusion test is no longer the sole method in which the government conducts a search.
Governmental seizures also look substantially different today compared to when the Fourth Amendment was adopted.
</span></p>
<p><span>The Founders were careful to choose words that carved out narrow bounds in their adoption of the Fourth Amendment—to strike the balance of effective governmental operation without societal oppression.
Looking at the owner’s right to exclude individuals from accessing digital data is necessary to assure both sides of the Fourth Amendment scale remain in the air.
<i>Back to the Fourth Amendment</i> proceeds in three parts.
Part I discusses the purpose of the Fourth Amendment to show that its history supports an understanding of seizure doctrine that continues to protect possessory interests in a digital world.
Part II lays out current search and seizure doctrines and how each has evolved—or not evolved—with technological advancements.
Part III then advances a technologically-neutral approach to the Fourth Amendment’s current seizure of property test to sufficiently protect against governmental overreach that the Founders were concerned would permeate society.
</span></p>.
Related Results
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Photo ID 123697425 © Alexandersikov | Dreamstime.com
Abstract
Originalism is an increasingly prevalent method for interpreting provisions of the US Constitution. It requires strict...
Grutter's First Amendment
Grutter's First Amendment
Most of the reaction to the Supreme Court's decision affirming the law school affirmative action policy at issue in Grutter v. Bollinger has focused on its Fourteenth Amendment imp...
The Fourth Amendment and General Law
The Fourth Amendment and General Law
For decades, Fourth Amendment protections have turned on “reasonable expectations of privacy.” But a new era may be dawning. There is growing interest among judges and scholars in ...
The Evolution of the Fourth Amendment
The Evolution of the Fourth Amendment
This book examines the history of the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits unreasonable search and seizure, and its interpretation by the Supreme Court. It concentrates on the changes...
Not Frozen In Amber: The Second Amendment And The Constitutional Right To Innovation
Not Frozen In Amber: The Second Amendment And The Constitutional Right To Innovation
This Article advances a novel claim: the Second Amendment is the only constitutional provision that explicitly protects access to a category of technological artifacts: "arms.'' Un...
The Unabridged Fifteenth Amendment
The Unabridged Fifteenth Amendment
In the legal histories of Reconstruction, the Fifteenth Amendment is usually an afterthought compared to the Fourteenth Amendment. This oversight is perplexing: the Fifteenth Amend...
Framing the Fourth
Framing the Fourth
Our knowledge of the Fourth Amendment's history was fundamentally transformed when William Cuddihy completed his Ph.D. dissertation in 1990. Cuddihy's study was the most comprehens...
Public Law in the State Courts in 1925–1926
Public Law in the State Courts in 1925–1926
Validity of Procedure. In the summer of 1925 the appellate division of the supreme court of New York held that the City Home Rule Amendment of 1923 had not been legally adopted and...

