Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

We still fail to account for Mendel's observations

View through CrossRef
Abstract Background The present article corrects common textbook accounts of Mendel's experiments by re-establishing what he wrote and how he accounted for his observations. It notes the long-established tests for the validity of any explanations that purport to explain observations obtained by experiment. Application of these tests to Mendel's paper shows that the arguments he used to explain his observations were internally consistent but were, on one crucial issue, implausible. The same tests are applied to the currently accepted explanation for Mendel's observations. Conclusions The currently favoured explanation for Mendel's observations is untenable. It misrepresents Mendel, fails to distinguish between the parameters and the variables of any system of interacting components, its arguments are inconsistent, it repeats the implausibility in Mendel's paper, fails to give a rational explanation for his observed 3:1 trait ratio and cannot explain why this ratio is not always observed in experimental practice. A rational explanation for Mendel's observations is initiated. Readers are challenged to complete the process before a further article appears.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: We still fail to account for Mendel's observations
Description:
Abstract Background The present article corrects common textbook accounts of Mendel's experiments by re-establishing what he wrote and how he accounted for his observations.
It notes the long-established tests for the validity of any explanations that purport to explain observations obtained by experiment.
Application of these tests to Mendel's paper shows that the arguments he used to explain his observations were internally consistent but were, on one crucial issue, implausible.
The same tests are applied to the currently accepted explanation for Mendel's observations.
Conclusions The currently favoured explanation for Mendel's observations is untenable.
It misrepresents Mendel, fails to distinguish between the parameters and the variables of any system of interacting components, its arguments are inconsistent, it repeats the implausibility in Mendel's paper, fails to give a rational explanation for his observed 3:1 trait ratio and cannot explain why this ratio is not always observed in experimental practice.
A rational explanation for Mendel's observations is initiated.
Readers are challenged to complete the process before a further article appears.

Related Results

The Genius of Gregor Mendel and the genome of the first geneticist
The Genius of Gregor Mendel and the genome of the first geneticist
This review gives a detailed description of the life path of the founder of genetics, Gregor Mendel, who forever entered the pleiad of the most significant personalities in the his...
Historical study: Johann Gregor Mendel 1822–1884
Historical study: Johann Gregor Mendel 1822–1884
AbstractThe life and personality of Johann Gregor Mendel (1822–1884), the founder of scientific genetics, are reviewed against the contemporary background of his times. At the end ...
Kalıtımın Temel İlkeleri ve Temel Kavramlar
Kalıtımın Temel İlkeleri ve Temel Kavramlar
On dokuzuncu yüzyılın ortalarında Mendel, ünlü bezelye deneylerini gerçekleştirdi. Mayoz bölünme, kromozomlar veya DNA'nın ayrıntıları hakkında hiçbir şey bilmiyordu, ancak çiftleş...
Alts and Automediality: Compartmentalising the Self through Multiple Social Media Profiles
Alts and Automediality: Compartmentalising the Self through Multiple Social Media Profiles
IntroductionAlt, or alternative, accounts are secondary profiles people use in addition to a main account on a social media platform. They are a kind of automediation, a way of rep...
Características genéticas mendelianas: redescobrindo os trabalhos de Mendel/ Mendelian genetic characteristics: rediscovering Mendel's work
Características genéticas mendelianas: redescobrindo os trabalhos de Mendel/ Mendelian genetic characteristics: rediscovering Mendel's work
A genética analisa as características e os mecanismos hereditários ao longo das gerações, possuindo inestimável importância ao promover embasamento teórico e resoluções de problema...
Principles and biological concepts of heredity before Mendel
Principles and biological concepts of heredity before Mendel
AbstractThe knowledge of the history of a subject stimulates understanding. As we study how other people have made scientific breakthroughs, we develop the breadth of imagination t...
HUBUNGAN PERAN ORANG TUA DAN PENGETAHUAN SISWA DENGAN PERILAKU BULLYING PADA SISWA KELAS XI MENDEL SMA KRISTEN RANTEPAO TAHUN 2024
HUBUNGAN PERAN ORANG TUA DAN PENGETAHUAN SISWA DENGAN PERILAKU BULLYING PADA SISWA KELAS XI MENDEL SMA KRISTEN RANTEPAO TAHUN 2024
Salah satu perilaku bullying yang masih sering terjadi pada siswa kelas XI Mendel SMA Kristen Rantepao Tahun 2024 yaitu bentuk perilaku bullying verbal seperti mengejek temannya de...
Was Gregor Mendel imprisoned in 1849 by the order of the young Emperor François-Joseph?
Was Gregor Mendel imprisoned in 1849 by the order of the young Emperor François-Joseph?
The appreciation of Gregor Mendel's discovery in 1865 of what we now know as "genes," occurred long after his death in 1884. The difficulties during his life that may have contribu...

Back to Top