Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Nudging Outgroup Altruism: A Human-Agent Interactional Approach for Reducing Ingroup Favoritism
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Ingroup favoritism and intergroup conflict can be mutually reinforcing during social interaction, threatening the peace and sustainability of societies. In two studies (N = 880), we investigated whether promoting prosocial outgroup altruism would weaken the ingroup favoritism cycle of influence. Using novel methods of human-agent interaction via a computer-mediated experimental platform, we introduced outgroup altruism by (i) nonadaptive artificial agents with preprogrammed outgroup altruistic behavior (Study 1; N = 400) and (ii) adaptive artificial agents whose altruistic behavior was informed by the prediction of a machine learning algorithm (Study 2; N = 480). A rating task ensured that the observed behavior did not result from the participant’s awareness of the artificial agents. In Study 1, nonadaptive agents prompted ingroup members to uphold their group identity by reinforcing ingroup favoritism. In Study 2, adaptive agents were able to weaken ingroup favoritism over time by maintaining a good reputation with both the ingroup and outgroup members, who perceived agents as being fairer than humans and rated agents as more human than humans. We conclude that a good reputation of the individual exhibiting outgroup altruism is necessary to weaken ingroup favoritism and reduce intergroup conflict. Thus, reputation is important for designing nudge agents.
Title: Nudging Outgroup Altruism: A Human-Agent Interactional Approach for Reducing Ingroup Favoritism
Description:
Abstract
Ingroup favoritism and intergroup conflict can be mutually reinforcing during social interaction, threatening the peace and sustainability of societies.
In two studies (N = 880), we investigated whether promoting prosocial outgroup altruism would weaken the ingroup favoritism cycle of influence.
Using novel methods of human-agent interaction via a computer-mediated experimental platform, we introduced outgroup altruism by (i) nonadaptive artificial agents with preprogrammed outgroup altruistic behavior (Study 1; N = 400) and (ii) adaptive artificial agents whose altruistic behavior was informed by the prediction of a machine learning algorithm (Study 2; N = 480).
A rating task ensured that the observed behavior did not result from the participant’s awareness of the artificial agents.
In Study 1, nonadaptive agents prompted ingroup members to uphold their group identity by reinforcing ingroup favoritism.
In Study 2, adaptive agents were able to weaken ingroup favoritism over time by maintaining a good reputation with both the ingroup and outgroup members, who perceived agents as being fairer than humans and rated agents as more human than humans.
We conclude that a good reputation of the individual exhibiting outgroup altruism is necessary to weaken ingroup favoritism and reduce intergroup conflict.
Thus, reputation is important for designing nudge agents.
Related Results
Ingroup Love and Outgroup Hate
Ingroup Love and Outgroup Hate
Abstract
In everyday life, we are faced with disparate examples of intergroup bias, ranging from a mild tendency to ingroup favoritism to harsh episodes of discri...
Like Me or Like Us
Like Me or Like Us
Research has shown abundant evidence for social projection, that is, the tendency to expect similarity between oneself and others ( Krueger, 1998a , 1998b ). This effect is stronge...
Revisiting Gino, Ayal, et al.’s (2009) Contagion and Differentiation in Unethical Behavior: A Registered Conceptual Replication and Extension
Revisiting Gino, Ayal, et al.’s (2009) Contagion and Differentiation in Unethical Behavior: A Registered Conceptual Replication and Extension
Individual behavior is often shaped by observing others’ actions. The seminal Gino, Ayal, et al.'s (2009) study found that individuals behave more dishonestly after witnessing blat...
Örgütsel Kayırmacılık (Organizational Favoritism)
Örgütsel Kayırmacılık (Organizational Favoritism)
Kayırmacılık yönetsel etik dışı davranışlardan bir tanesidir. Her sektörde kayırmacılık belirli düzeylerde yaşanmaktadır. Kurumların eleman seçme ve yerleştirme, kariyer planlaması...
Ingroup Categorization of Robots Is Affected by Self-Cognitions and Level of Anthropomorphism
Ingroup Categorization of Robots Is Affected by Self-Cognitions and Level of Anthropomorphism
Objective: The purpose of this work was to examine the relationship between self-concept and ingroup/outgroup categorization of robots.
Background: Social psychol...
Ingroup positivity and outgroup negativity jointly motivate toddlers' social behavior
Ingroup positivity and outgroup negativity jointly motivate toddlers' social behavior
Intergroup bias has been a pervasive phenomenon throughout human history, but its psychological underpinnings are still the subject of debate. The present work tests whether interg...
A review of long‐branch attraction
A review of long‐branch attraction
AbstractThe history of long‐branch attraction, and in particular methods suggested to detect and avoid the artifact to date, is reviewed. Methods suggested to avoid LBA‐artifacts i...
Loyal to a fault: Mistaken reputational pressures fuel partisan endorsement of winning at all costs
Loyal to a fault: Mistaken reputational pressures fuel partisan endorsement of winning at all costs
In the polarized context of American politics, we study a phenomenon we term winning at all costs: prioritizing ingroup political gain at the expense of immediate societal harm. Do...

