Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Bending Gender: Disability Justice, Abolitionist Queer Theory, and ADA Claims for Gender Dysphoria
View through CrossRef
The trans rights movement is engaged in an internal debate over whether trans people diagnosed with gender dysphoria should bring claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Some have argued the ADA is a good vehicle for those with gender dysphoria to access medical needs, while others contend that because gender identity should not be pathologized and the state should not be the arbiter for who can access care, trans plaintiffs should not raise ADA claims. <br><br>This Essay defends the ADA as a viable path for trans plaintiffs in prison to seek accommodations based on gender dysphoria, applying a critical autoethnographic lens. First, it presents survey data of the views of trans people incarcerated in Massachusetts on bringing ADA claims for gender dysphoria. Second, it summarizes the history of gender dysphoria in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) and its recent legal interpretation under the ADA. Third, applying the lenses of queer and Crip theory, the Essay argues that trans people should raise ADA claims as necessary to fulfill their medical needs under our current regime as striving toward a Disability Justice future. Finally, it considers counterarguments raised by trans movement litigators and scholars.
Title: Bending Gender: Disability Justice, Abolitionist Queer Theory, and ADA Claims for Gender Dysphoria
Description:
The trans rights movement is engaged in an internal debate over whether trans people diagnosed with gender dysphoria should bring claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Some have argued the ADA is a good vehicle for those with gender dysphoria to access medical needs, while others contend that because gender identity should not be pathologized and the state should not be the arbiter for who can access care, trans plaintiffs should not raise ADA claims.
<br><br>This Essay defends the ADA as a viable path for trans plaintiffs in prison to seek accommodations based on gender dysphoria, applying a critical autoethnographic lens.
First, it presents survey data of the views of trans people incarcerated in Massachusetts on bringing ADA claims for gender dysphoria.
Second, it summarizes the history of gender dysphoria in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) and its recent legal interpretation under the ADA.
Third, applying the lenses of queer and Crip theory, the Essay argues that trans people should raise ADA claims as necessary to fulfill their medical needs under our current regime as striving toward a Disability Justice future.
Finally, it considers counterarguments raised by trans movement litigators and scholars.
Related Results
Queer Pedagogy
Queer Pedagogy
Queer pedagogy is an approach to educational praxis and curricula emerging in the late 20th century, drawing from the theoretical traditions of poststructuralism, queer theory, and...
Kuaer Theory
Kuaer Theory
Abstract
Although queer theory was profoundly influenced by the womanist feminism of the 1980s and its emphasis on the ways in which intersectionality affects liv...
ANALISIS PENGARUH RADIUS BENDING PADA PROSES BENDING MENGGUNAKAN PELAT SPCC-SD TERHADAP PERUBAHAN STRUKTUR MIKRO
ANALISIS PENGARUH RADIUS BENDING PADA PROSES BENDING MENGGUNAKAN PELAT SPCC-SD TERHADAP PERUBAHAN STRUKTUR MIKRO
Paper ini membahas tentang pengaruh radius bending pada kualitas hasil bending dan pengaruhnya terhadap perubahan microstructure. Proses bending merupakan salah satu proses pembent...
Trends in Disability Prevalence among Young People: Insights from the Growing Up in Ireland Study
Trends in Disability Prevalence among Young People: Insights from the Growing Up in Ireland Study
Background to the study This report draws on analyses of the two cohorts of the Growing Up in Ireland (GUI) study to examine trends in the prevalence of disability among 13-year-ol...
Gender Dysphoria Canons
Gender Dysphoria Canons
The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and its predecessor, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, protect people with disabilities from discrimination in a broad rang...
Disability Studies
Disability Studies
This article brings together key texts and theorists from disability studies, which is a growing and vibrant inter/multidisciplinary field. It is an area of inquiry that has been e...
Epistemologias queer e direito: apagamentos na pesquisa brasileira entre 2019-2023 e os embates ao reconhecimento de uma teoria jurídica queer
Epistemologias queer e direito: apagamentos na pesquisa brasileira entre 2019-2023 e os embates ao reconhecimento de uma teoria jurídica queer
Resumo: O presente artigo se propõe a abordar a temática das epistemologias queer na ciência jurídica brasileira, a partir da investigação em plataformas de artigos, teses e disser...
Gender Dysphoria in When The Moon Was Ours Novel By Anna Marie Mclemore
Gender Dysphoria in When The Moon Was Ours Novel By Anna Marie Mclemore
This research discusses gender dysphoria in When the Moon Was Ours novel by Anna-Marie McLemore as reflected by the main character named Samir. ...

