Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Unlocking Accuracy: Inventory Geometry as a Missing Link in Machine Learning-Based Rockfall Susceptibility Mapping (Case Study: Calcareous Dorsal, Rif, Morocco)

View through CrossRef
Abstract In rockfall susceptibility mapping, the reliability of predictive models depends heavily on the quality and structure of input data, particularly the rockfall inventory that forms the foundation of any analysis. Despite its central role, one critical aspect is often overlooked: the geometric representation of this inventory. Many studies apply different formats, points, polylines, or polygons, without questioning their methodological appropriateness or impact on model performance. This study addresses this issue by assessing how inventory geometry influences model accuracy, interpretability, and efficiency. Using the multilayer perceptron (MLP) technique, we compare three inventory types on a geologically complex limestone ridge in northern Morocco. Model evaluations rely on standard indicators, such as AUC, confusion matrices, and model-reality overlays, ensuring a robust assessment of predictive capabilities while accounting for geological and geomorphological processes in rockfall source areas. Results show that the spatial representation of rockfall events has a direct and substantial impact on susceptibility mapping outcomes. The point-based model requires a more complex neural structure (14 nodes) and yields modest performance (AUC = 0.718, recall = 0.71, F1 = 0.83), tending to overgeneralize susceptibility even in unsuitable areas. It emphasizes structural factors but overlooks environmental dynamics such as erosion. In contrast, models based on polyline and polygon inventories provide higher accuracy and spatial coherence. The polyline model better reflects hydro-morphological processes, while the polygon inventory offers the most integrated approach, capturing both triggering factors and long-term accumulation of displaced material. With simpler neural networks (8 nodes, matching the theoretical optimum for this dataset) and superior metrics (AUC = 0.932, recall = 0.97, F1 = 0.98), the polygon-based model proves the most effective. This study demonstrates that inventory geometry is not merely a technical choice but a strategic parameter that shapes model behavior and the quality of risk assessment. It offers a methodological contribution to improve susceptibility mapping and supports more accurate, reliable decisions in natural hazard management and land-use planning. Graphical Abstract This work presents an in-depth comparative analysis of Rockfall Susceptibility Mapping (RSM) using the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) model. The study addresses a critical and often overlooked methodological question: the impact of the geometric representation of the rockfall inventory (point, polyline, and polygon) on the predictive model’s performance and interpretability. The analysis is conducted at the level of a geologically complex area in northern Morocco, namely the Dorsale calcaire. The data used in this analysis include topographic and geological maps, satellite images, and a high-resolution digital terrain model (DEM). Several conditioning factors (slope, curvature, aspect, elevation, lithology, and others) have been integrated as explanatory variables. Each inventory geometry datum is divided into two parts: training (70%) and testing (30%), with the same spatial distribution. The latter are subjected to the multilayer neural network model via specific neural architectures. The results obtained highlight the differential contribution of variables according to the geometry used during the analysis and in the various resulting susceptibility maps. In this study, the polygon appears to be the most reliable geometry for modeling rockfall susceptibility, while the point performs the least well. This confirms that the geometry of the rockfall inventory has a decisive impact on the quality and reliability of Rockfall Susceptibility Models (RSM), leading to differential variable contributions and distinct optimal network configurations. Far from being a neutral technical choice, the inventory’s representation format profoundly influences the ranking of predisposing factors and the model’s ability to reflect geomorphological reality. This conclusion is fundamental to attempts to standardize methodologies for assessing rockfall susceptibility mapping or to choose the appropriate inventory geometry according to the phenomenon studied, the data used, and the method employed.
Title: Unlocking Accuracy: Inventory Geometry as a Missing Link in Machine Learning-Based Rockfall Susceptibility Mapping (Case Study: Calcareous Dorsal, Rif, Morocco)
Description:
Abstract In rockfall susceptibility mapping, the reliability of predictive models depends heavily on the quality and structure of input data, particularly the rockfall inventory that forms the foundation of any analysis.
Despite its central role, one critical aspect is often overlooked: the geometric representation of this inventory.
Many studies apply different formats, points, polylines, or polygons, without questioning their methodological appropriateness or impact on model performance.
This study addresses this issue by assessing how inventory geometry influences model accuracy, interpretability, and efficiency.
Using the multilayer perceptron (MLP) technique, we compare three inventory types on a geologically complex limestone ridge in northern Morocco.
Model evaluations rely on standard indicators, such as AUC, confusion matrices, and model-reality overlays, ensuring a robust assessment of predictive capabilities while accounting for geological and geomorphological processes in rockfall source areas.
Results show that the spatial representation of rockfall events has a direct and substantial impact on susceptibility mapping outcomes.
The point-based model requires a more complex neural structure (14 nodes) and yields modest performance (AUC = 0.
718, recall = 0.
71, F1 = 0.
83), tending to overgeneralize susceptibility even in unsuitable areas.
It emphasizes structural factors but overlooks environmental dynamics such as erosion.
In contrast, models based on polyline and polygon inventories provide higher accuracy and spatial coherence.
The polyline model better reflects hydro-morphological processes, while the polygon inventory offers the most integrated approach, capturing both triggering factors and long-term accumulation of displaced material.
With simpler neural networks (8 nodes, matching the theoretical optimum for this dataset) and superior metrics (AUC = 0.
932, recall = 0.
97, F1 = 0.
98), the polygon-based model proves the most effective.
This study demonstrates that inventory geometry is not merely a technical choice but a strategic parameter that shapes model behavior and the quality of risk assessment.
It offers a methodological contribution to improve susceptibility mapping and supports more accurate, reliable decisions in natural hazard management and land-use planning.
Graphical Abstract This work presents an in-depth comparative analysis of Rockfall Susceptibility Mapping (RSM) using the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) model.
The study addresses a critical and often overlooked methodological question: the impact of the geometric representation of the rockfall inventory (point, polyline, and polygon) on the predictive model’s performance and interpretability.
The analysis is conducted at the level of a geologically complex area in northern Morocco, namely the Dorsale calcaire.
The data used in this analysis include topographic and geological maps, satellite images, and a high-resolution digital terrain model (DEM).
Several conditioning factors (slope, curvature, aspect, elevation, lithology, and others) have been integrated as explanatory variables.
Each inventory geometry datum is divided into two parts: training (70%) and testing (30%), with the same spatial distribution.
The latter are subjected to the multilayer neural network model via specific neural architectures.
The results obtained highlight the differential contribution of variables according to the geometry used during the analysis and in the various resulting susceptibility maps.
In this study, the polygon appears to be the most reliable geometry for modeling rockfall susceptibility, while the point performs the least well.
This confirms that the geometry of the rockfall inventory has a decisive impact on the quality and reliability of Rockfall Susceptibility Models (RSM), leading to differential variable contributions and distinct optimal network configurations.
Far from being a neutral technical choice, the inventory’s representation format profoundly influences the ranking of predisposing factors and the model’s ability to reflect geomorphological reality.
This conclusion is fundamental to attempts to standardize methodologies for assessing rockfall susceptibility mapping or to choose the appropriate inventory geometry according to the phenomenon studied, the data used, and the method employed.

Related Results

Hydatid Disease of The Brain Parenchyma: A Systematic Review
Hydatid Disease of The Brain Parenchyma: A Systematic Review
Abstarct Introduction Isolated brain hydatid disease (BHD) is an extremely rare form of echinococcosis. A prompt and timely diagnosis is a crucial step in disease management. This ...
Rockfall Barrier Testing in an Open Pit Mine: Comparing Empirical and Modeled Rockfall Dynamics
Rockfall Barrier Testing in an Open Pit Mine: Comparing Empirical and Modeled Rockfall Dynamics
ABSTRACT: Rockfalls pose severe hazards to miners and infrastructure in open pit mines, and rockfall barrier systems are an increasingly common method for mitigat...
Large rockfall detection, location and characterization using broadband seismic records: A case study of Hongya rockfall
Large rockfall detection, location and characterization using broadband seismic records: A case study of Hongya rockfall
Large rockfalls often cause huge economic losses and casualties in densely populated mountain areas. Timely acquiring information on a large rockfall can help promptly assess the d...
Comparison evaluation between gene Xpert Mtb/Rif and multiplex PCR for rapid diagnosis of mycobacterium tuberculosis
Comparison evaluation between gene Xpert Mtb/Rif and multiplex PCR for rapid diagnosis of mycobacterium tuberculosis
Abstract Objective: To evaluate Gene Xpert MTB/RIF and Multiplex PCRfor detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Rifampicin resistance comparing with gold standard MGIT 96...
Morphological study of dorsal Barton's fracture based on three-dimensional CT imaging
Morphological study of dorsal Barton's fracture based on three-dimensional CT imaging
Abstract Background Dorsal Barton's fracture is a distinct type of distal radius fracture. The treatment of dorsal Barton's fracture is contentious and may lead to severe ...
Quantifying Topographic Influences on Rockfall Trajectories in Open Pit Mines Using Stochastic Rockfall Modeling
Quantifying Topographic Influences on Rockfall Trajectories in Open Pit Mines Using Stochastic Rockfall Modeling
ABSTRACT: Rockfall remains one of the most critical and least understood hazards faced in open pit mining. The factors controlling when and where rockfalls occur ...

Back to Top