Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The Compatibility of Substantive Canons and Originalism
View through CrossRef
Judges and justices who describe themselves as originalists should neither develop nor apply certain substantive canons, including the major questions doctrine. Professor Michael Ramsey argues in a recent article that the judicial power permits the development of new substantive canons that underenforce statutes to protect a core Founding-era value. After evaluating Ramsey’s theory, this Note advances an alternative framework: a substantive canon must have both predated and survived ratification for its use to fall within the original meaning of the judicial power. The Constitution’s separation of powers placed a cap on judicial lawmaking and repudiated meta-lawmaking — the power to make rules that make laws. Already-developed canons, however, were presumptively incorporated into the judicial power, unless they were so vacuous as to permit unbounded lawmaking. Thus, while originalists on courts may comfortably apply most substantive canons that predate ratification, the development or application of any post-ratification canons exceeds the Article III judicial power.
Title: The Compatibility of Substantive Canons and Originalism
Description:
Judges and justices who describe themselves as originalists should neither develop nor apply certain substantive canons, including the major questions doctrine.
Professor Michael Ramsey argues in a recent article that the judicial power permits the development of new substantive canons that underenforce statutes to protect a core Founding-era value.
After evaluating Ramsey’s theory, this Note advances an alternative framework: a substantive canon must have both predated and survived ratification for its use to fall within the original meaning of the judicial power.
The Constitution’s separation of powers placed a cap on judicial lawmaking and repudiated meta-lawmaking — the power to make rules that make laws.
Already-developed canons, however, were presumptively incorporated into the judicial power, unless they were so vacuous as to permit unbounded lawmaking.
Thus, while originalists on courts may comfortably apply most substantive canons that predate ratification, the development or application of any post-ratification canons exceeds the Article III judicial power.
Related Results
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Photo ID 123697425 © Alexandersikov | Dreamstime.com
Abstract
Originalism is an increasingly prevalent method for interpreting provisions of the US Constitution. It requires strict...
Rebooting Originalism
Rebooting Originalism
This article is a critique of the new originalism. New originalists such as Keith Whittington and Randy Barnett assert that the turn to emphasizing the public meaning of the Consti...
Originalism and the Aristotelian Tradition: Virtue’s Home in Originalism
Originalism and the Aristotelian Tradition: Virtue’s Home in Originalism
A concept fundamental to philosophy – virtue – is, with a few notable exceptions, absent from scholarship on constitutional interpretation generally, and originalism in particular....
Are There Any Substantive Canons of Interpretation?
Are There Any Substantive Canons of Interpretation?
<p>Since the late 1980s, scholars have distinguished between two kinds of canons of statutory interpretation: linguistic canons, which judges invoke on the ground that they t...
The End of Originalism
The End of Originalism
Much has been written about originalism - the idea that the Constitution should be interpreted according to its original meaning. This essay goes beyond previous works by assertin...
Originalism is Bunk
Originalism is Bunk
Critical analysis of originalism should start by confronting a modest puzzle: Most commentators suppose that originalism is deeply controversial, while others complain that it mea...
Biblical Literalism and Constitutional Originalism
Biblical Literalism and Constitutional Originalism
Critics of constitutional originalism have often described originalists as “fundamentalists” or “literalists” as a way of discrediting originalism. This comparison has obvious rhet...
Misfiring Textual Canons
Misfiring Textual Canons
The textual canons rank among the most important tools of modern statutory interpretation. Though some already boasted centuries of use, their authority has reached new heights in ...

