Javascript must be enabled to continue!
DIM Theory Applied to Law: The Disintegration of American Law
View through CrossRef
Plato, Aristotle, and Montesquieu each argued the importance of law to political regime and Constitution. The ancients emphasized the law as the rational component of the regime and Montesquieu applied some of the first political science to show how political regimes rely upon law. Still, the exact connection between law and politics, and law and philosophy more broadly has remained largely obscured. In my account, legal system ought to be understood as the institutional framework that supports and protect a particular kind of life accepted by the intellectuals and the people of a nation. Using DIM theory from The DIM Hypothesis by Leonard Peikoff, I examine American history to argue the connection between law and the philosophical mode of the dominant culture in American society. Separating out American history out into three different legal regimes, early, middle, and late, I discuss the progression of America’s legal systems. Each part of this dissertation discusses a period in terms of the philosophical context that led to the creation of the legal regime, the key cases that gave further definition to the regime, and a key justice for the period as well as the key attributes of the courtroom etiquette and structure. Together, the discussions of these aspects of a period’s legal system is meant to establish its identity properly categorized as based on one of the five DIM modes of in The DIM Hypothesis . The early American legal system is classified as of the integrative mode; the middle American legal system is classified as of the mixture of the integrative and disintegrative modes; and the late American legal system, yet to be, is classified by the disintegrative mode. The transformation of the American legal system has been from a philosophically integrative legal system, towards a disintegrative legal system. In the context of law, in Part Two, I argue that the early American legal system was the first objective legal system; in Part Three, I describe how the disintegrative pressures around the time of the Civil War led to the transformation of this objective legal system into a fundamentally administrative legal system; in Part Four I describe how the modal logic accepted by the pluralists in changing from an objective legal system led to the continued transformation of our legal system until today, toward egalitarianism. I argue this progression from integration to disintegration has yet to be completed, as the egalitarian legal system has not been fully formalized. The dominant philosophy of legal scholars today may be disintegrative, but until the American legal system sheds it integrative elements, the transformation of American law is not yet complete. This dissertation has two main conclusions. First, that law is a uniquely important subculture for DIM theory, as the law is the final step in crystalizing the dominance of a particular philosophy in the culture. Second, that American legal history should be understood as having three distinct legal periods and that it has progressively changed from a legal system based on the integrative mode to a legal system based on the disintegrative mode. The future of American law will depend on convincing the American people to accept a certain way of life.
Title: DIM Theory Applied to Law: The Disintegration of American Law
Description:
Plato, Aristotle, and Montesquieu each argued the importance of law to political regime and Constitution.
The ancients emphasized the law as the rational component of the regime and Montesquieu applied some of the first political science to show how political regimes rely upon law.
Still, the exact connection between law and politics, and law and philosophy more broadly has remained largely obscured.
In my account, legal system ought to be understood as the institutional framework that supports and protect a particular kind of life accepted by the intellectuals and the people of a nation.
Using DIM theory from The DIM Hypothesis by Leonard Peikoff, I examine American history to argue the connection between law and the philosophical mode of the dominant culture in American society.
Separating out American history out into three different legal regimes, early, middle, and late, I discuss the progression of America’s legal systems.
Each part of this dissertation discusses a period in terms of the philosophical context that led to the creation of the legal regime, the key cases that gave further definition to the regime, and a key justice for the period as well as the key attributes of the courtroom etiquette and structure.
Together, the discussions of these aspects of a period’s legal system is meant to establish its identity properly categorized as based on one of the five DIM modes of in The DIM Hypothesis .
The early American legal system is classified as of the integrative mode; the middle American legal system is classified as of the mixture of the integrative and disintegrative modes; and the late American legal system, yet to be, is classified by the disintegrative mode.
The transformation of the American legal system has been from a philosophically integrative legal system, towards a disintegrative legal system.
In the context of law, in Part Two, I argue that the early American legal system was the first objective legal system; in Part Three, I describe how the disintegrative pressures around the time of the Civil War led to the transformation of this objective legal system into a fundamentally administrative legal system; in Part Four I describe how the modal logic accepted by the pluralists in changing from an objective legal system led to the continued transformation of our legal system until today, toward egalitarianism.
I argue this progression from integration to disintegration has yet to be completed, as the egalitarian legal system has not been fully formalized.
The dominant philosophy of legal scholars today may be disintegrative, but until the American legal system sheds it integrative elements, the transformation of American law is not yet complete.
This dissertation has two main conclusions.
First, that law is a uniquely important subculture for DIM theory, as the law is the final step in crystalizing the dominance of a particular philosophy in the culture.
Second, that American legal history should be understood as having three distinct legal periods and that it has progressively changed from a legal system based on the integrative mode to a legal system based on the disintegrative mode.
The future of American law will depend on convincing the American people to accept a certain way of life.
Related Results
Disintegration Characteristics of Remolded Granite Residual Soil with Different Moisture Contents
Disintegration Characteristics of Remolded Granite Residual Soil with Different Moisture Contents
Granite residual soil (GRS) has prominent disintegration characteristics which have induced various geological disasters and engineering problems. The initial moisture content is b...
DIM Theory Applied to Law: The Disintegration of American Law
DIM Theory Applied to Law: The Disintegration of American Law
<p><span>Plato, Aristotle, and Montesquieu each argued the importance of law to political regime and Constitution. The ancients emphasized the law as the rational compo...
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere
From Constitutional Comparison to Life in the Biosphere is a monograph that argues for a fundamental reorientation of constitutional law around the realities of biospheric interdep...
Feed conversion efficiency and marginal milk production responses of pasture-fed dairy cows offered supplementary grain during an extended lactation
Feed conversion efficiency and marginal milk production responses of pasture-fed dairy cows offered supplementary grain during an extended lactation
A study was conducted to quantify the feed conversion efficiency (FCE) and marginal milk responses of pasture-fed cows offered supplementary grain during an extended lactation of 6...
Functional heterogeneity between NKR-P1bright/Lycopersicon esculentum lectin (L.E.)bright and NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim subpopulations of rat natural killer cells
Functional heterogeneity between NKR-P1bright/Lycopersicon esculentum lectin (L.E.)bright and NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim subpopulations of rat natural killer cells
Abstract
In this report, we present data on heterogeneity of rat NK cells utilizing a combination of antibody and lectin-binding characteristics. Among NKR-P1bright ...
Circulating Thyroid Hormones and Indices of Energy and Lipid Metabolism in Normal and Hormonally Induced Oestrus Cows
Circulating Thyroid Hormones and Indices of Energy and Lipid Metabolism in Normal and Hormonally Induced Oestrus Cows
In a field study, circulating thyroid hormones, their free forms and indices of energy and lipid metabolism were measured in blood samples of 16 dairy cows expressing detectable oe...
QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF CRUCIFEROUS VEGETABLE EXTRACTS USEFUL FOR ESTROGEN METABOLISM FOR DIINDOLYLMETHANE (DIM)
QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF CRUCIFEROUS VEGETABLE EXTRACTS USEFUL FOR ESTROGEN METABOLISM FOR DIINDOLYLMETHANE (DIM)
3,3′-Diindolylmethane (DIM) is a compound derived from the digestion of indole-3-carbinol, found in Cruciferous vegetables (Broccoli, Cabbage, Cauliflower,) which promotes Estrogen...
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Envisioning Originalism Applied to Bioethics Cases
Photo ID 123697425 © Alexandersikov | Dreamstime.com
Abstract
Originalism is an increasingly prevalent method for interpreting provisions of the US Constitution. It requires strict...

