Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Hart on Sovereignty
View through CrossRef
This essay is part of a volume of essays by various authors on the 50 years of H. L. A. Hart’s The Concept of Law (the book will be published as: Andrea Dolcetti, Luís Duarte d’Almeida and James Edwards (eds), Reading HLA Hart's 'The Concept of Law' (Hart Publishing 2013). Although discussing mainly Hart’s chapter 4, my essay seeks to give a more general account of Hart’s achievements and failures. Focusing on Hart’s account of sovereignty, the essay shows how Hart’s descriptivism prevented him from giving an adequate account of the law and the legal system. In my view (see also Eleftheriadis, Legal Rights, 2008) because law is part of practical reason, its theory is also practical reason and cannot be accommodated by Hart’s causal, descriptive model. Hart never accepted this. When speaking of the ‘internal point of view’ Hart ought to have been speaking instead of the practical, deliberative standpoint of the reflective agent who faces a first person choice about action and remains situated in the common circumstances of social life. This standpoint is necessary both at the highest offices of state and in the idea of sovereignty and at the lowest matters of social interaction. That Hart did not see this in chapter IV is the origin of all the subsequent failures of the Concept of Law.
Title: Hart on Sovereignty
Description:
This essay is part of a volume of essays by various authors on the 50 years of H.
L.
A.
Hart’s The Concept of Law (the book will be published as: Andrea Dolcetti, Luís Duarte d’Almeida and James Edwards (eds), Reading HLA Hart's 'The Concept of Law' (Hart Publishing 2013).
Although discussing mainly Hart’s chapter 4, my essay seeks to give a more general account of Hart’s achievements and failures.
Focusing on Hart’s account of sovereignty, the essay shows how Hart’s descriptivism prevented him from giving an adequate account of the law and the legal system.
In my view (see also Eleftheriadis, Legal Rights, 2008) because law is part of practical reason, its theory is also practical reason and cannot be accommodated by Hart’s causal, descriptive model.
Hart never accepted this.
When speaking of the ‘internal point of view’ Hart ought to have been speaking instead of the practical, deliberative standpoint of the reflective agent who faces a first person choice about action and remains situated in the common circumstances of social life.
This standpoint is necessary both at the highest offices of state and in the idea of sovereignty and at the lowest matters of social interaction.
That Hart did not see this in chapter IV is the origin of all the subsequent failures of the Concept of Law.
Related Results
The Problem of "Popular" "Sovereignty"
The Problem of "Popular" "Sovereignty"
<p>“Popular sovereignty” is central to liberal democracy, but the concept of sovereignty—the right to rule and make the rules—has many difficulties and ambiguities that have ...
Untuk Apa Filsafat Hukum? Problem Metodologi Setelah Debat Hart/Dworkin
Untuk Apa Filsafat Hukum? Problem Metodologi Setelah Debat Hart/Dworkin
Abstrak: Tulisan berikut membahas pemikiran hukum Anglo-Amerika yang dikenal sebagai filsafat hukum. Dua pokok yang dibahas adalah masalah metodologi dan debat Hart/Dworkin. In...
Nation-state and Sovereignty in Contemporary Political Discourse
Nation-state and Sovereignty in Contemporary Political Discourse
Sovereignty has had a fundamental importance in modern political discourse. Politically, the term ‘sovereignty’ is used as ‘absolute overlordship or complete suzerainty’. Sovereign...
Unfinished God
Unfinished God
The critical essays constituting the first book-length examination of Ray L. Hart’s contribution to modern religious thought, address seminal aspects of Hart’s speculative philosop...
A Genealogy of State Sovereignty
A Genealogy of State Sovereignty
AbstractA genealogical account of state sovereignty explores the ways in which the concept has emerged, evolved, and is in decline today. Sovereignty has a theological foundation, ...
The Corpus Juris of (Alaska Native) Inherent Tribal Sovereignty
The Corpus Juris of (Alaska Native) Inherent Tribal Sovereignty
<p>The inherent Tribal sovereignty of Native nations predates the formation of the United States and is reflected in the constitutional vision of tripartite sovereignty. Yet ...
Oliver Hart and the Rise of Baptist America
Oliver Hart and the Rise of Baptist America
Abstract
Oliver Hart was arguably the most important evangelical leader of the pre-Revolutionary South. For thirty years the pastor of the Charleston Baptist Church,...
AN INTERACTIVE STUDY ON THE BRITISH AND GERMAN SEMI-COLONIAL STRATEGY AND THE CHANGE OF TRADITIONAL CHINESE SOVEREIGNTY-BASED ON THE COMPARISON BETWEEN SHANGHAI AND QINGDAO
AN INTERACTIVE STUDY ON THE BRITISH AND GERMAN SEMI-COLONIAL STRATEGY AND THE CHANGE OF TRADITIONAL CHINESE SOVEREIGNTY-BASED ON THE COMPARISON BETWEEN SHANGHAI AND QINGDAO
The emergence of “Concessions” is not a simple historical problem. Based on the sovereignty declining theory, this paper attempts to explore the emergence of “Concessions” and the ...

