Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Modality, Mechanism and Translational Indeterminacy
View through CrossRef
How does Quine argue to the indeterminacy of translation? It has always been hard to tell, but one construction goes like this: A fact is determinate only if it is empirically determinable, for empirical evidence under-determines truth about the trans-empirical; theory is underdetermined by data. Therefore, facts about the unobservable, facts of theory, are indeterminate. A fact about the meaning of a person's sentence is only determinate if it is empirically determinable. The meaning of a person's sentence is empirically determinable only if it is empirically determinable under what conditions he assents to it. The meaning of a person's sentence about something unobservable is determinable only if it is determinable what unobservable events are occurring whenever he assents to a sentence supposedly about the unobservable. It is not empirically determinable what is going on in the unobservable realm whenever someone assents to a sentence supposedly about the unobservable. Therefore it is undeterminable what a person's theory sentence means. Therefore what it means is indeterminate.
Title: Modality, Mechanism and Translational Indeterminacy
Description:
How does Quine argue to the indeterminacy of translation? It has always been hard to tell, but one construction goes like this: A fact is determinate only if it is empirically determinable, for empirical evidence under-determines truth about the trans-empirical; theory is underdetermined by data.
Therefore, facts about the unobservable, facts of theory, are indeterminate.
A fact about the meaning of a person's sentence is only determinate if it is empirically determinable.
The meaning of a person's sentence is empirically determinable only if it is empirically determinable under what conditions he assents to it.
The meaning of a person's sentence about something unobservable is determinable only if it is determinable what unobservable events are occurring whenever he assents to a sentence supposedly about the unobservable.
It is not empirically determinable what is going on in the unobservable realm whenever someone assents to a sentence supposedly about the unobservable.
Therefore it is undeterminable what a person's theory sentence means.
Therefore what it means is indeterminate.
Related Results
The Final Date of the Antikythera Mechanism
The Final Date of the Antikythera Mechanism
The Antikythera mechanism is a mechanical astronomical instrument that was discovered in an ancient shipwreck (from about 60 bce) at the beginning of the twentieth century. A conse...
Smallpox inoculation: translation, transference and transformation
Smallpox inoculation: translation, transference and transformation
AbstractIn the early decades of the eighteenth century, small pox inoculation was introduced into northern Europe from the Middle East. The method consisted of grafting infected ma...
The Politics of Visual Indeterminacy in Abstract AI
Art
The Politics of Visual Indeterminacy in Abstract AI
Art
Abstract
In Perception Engines and Synthetic Abstractions, two generative AI art projects begun in 2018, Tom White experiments with visual abstraction to explore the...
Linnebo on reference by abstraction
Linnebo on reference by abstraction
AbstractAccording to Øystein Linnebo's account of abstractionism, abstraction principles, received as Fregean criteria of identity, can be used to reduce facts about singular refer...
Conclusions from the Functional Reconstruction of the Antikythera Mechanism
Conclusions from the Functional Reconstruction of the Antikythera Mechanism
After a careful examination of the Antikythera Mechanism computed tomography scans from the Antikythera Mechanism Research Project, we designed and constructed the mechanical parts...
The Antikythera Mechanism: The Construction of the Metonic Pointer and the Back Plate Spirals
The Antikythera Mechanism: The Construction of the Metonic Pointer and the Back Plate Spirals
The main dials of the back face of the Antikythera Mechanism have partially survived together with the pointer of the upper dial and a few remains of the mechanism that supported a...
Learning with ANIMA
Learning with ANIMA
The paper develops a semi-formal model of learning which modifies the traditional paradigm of artificial neural networks, implementing deep learning by means of a key insight borro...
On the equivalence of translations of Abai’s poetic text
On the equivalence of translations of Abai’s poetic text
We consider the equivalence of source and translation texts. Currently, various ways to achieve the adequacy of texts are being studied, which proves the relevance of this problem....