Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

The Benchmarking of the new ISO for the Site Specific Assessment of Mobile Jack-Up Units

View through CrossRef
Abstract The paper presents the logic behind, and the results of, a series of comparisonanalyses between a number of jack-up site-specific assessments using both thenew ISO 19905-1 on the site-specific assessment of mobile jack-up units [Ref.1] and the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers Technical &Research Bulletin 5-5A [Ref. 2]. The study shows that the differences in theresults of analyses between those undertaken using 5-5A and ISO 19905-1 aregenerally small, although one area of potentially larger difference, which wasintentionally excluded from the comparison, (the normally lower kinematicsreduction factor in 19905) could lead to lower wave loads in 19905calculations. ISO 19905 is largely based on 5-5A, however, the ISO development incorporatedsome major changes, including:Enhancements to calculation methodsSignificant changes in the geotechnical calculations, including the method ofcalculating acceptable bearing capacity, incorporation of deep penetrationcases, distinction between backfill and backflow, etc.Changes to enhance compatibility with other ISO documents in the 19900series, particularly ISO 19902 addressing Fixed Offshore Structures [Ref. 3](e.g. the structural code checks for tubular members)Introduction of additional structural member checksRe-structuring of 5-5A into a more logical ISO formatIntroduction of "benign" changes required for ISO compatibility (e.g.introduction of apparent and intrinsic wave periods), although some proved tobe less benign than othersAdditional loadcases for jack-ups operating close to resonance Given so many changes, there was concern that the ISO may not be useable (e.g.there would be gaps, inconsistencies, and serious transposition errors), andeven if an analysis could be undertaken using it, the analysis results would besignificantly different from a similar assessment using 5-5A. To ensure the compatibility and acceptability of ISO assessments results, a twopart benchmarking process was undertaken: Part 1 Contract a single consultant to ensure the complete ISO could be used toproduce an answer. In effect, could an analysts start an analysis using thedocument and arrive at a solution - regardless of whether the solution wascorrect. This work resulted in some important changes. Part 2 Contract four consultants to assess four jack-up designs, and comparethe results to a comparable series of assessments based on SNAME Bulletin 5-5A. In most cases each jack-up was assessed by two consultants with the analysesaligned at specific points. Alignment allowed differences in ISO interpretationto be identified, and ensured that results did not diverge as they progressed.A detailed sample calculation "Go-By" was also produced.
Title: The Benchmarking of the new ISO for the Site Specific Assessment of Mobile Jack-Up Units
Description:
Abstract The paper presents the logic behind, and the results of, a series of comparisonanalyses between a number of jack-up site-specific assessments using both thenew ISO 19905-1 on the site-specific assessment of mobile jack-up units [Ref.
1] and the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers Technical &Research Bulletin 5-5A [Ref.
2].
The study shows that the differences in theresults of analyses between those undertaken using 5-5A and ISO 19905-1 aregenerally small, although one area of potentially larger difference, which wasintentionally excluded from the comparison, (the normally lower kinematicsreduction factor in 19905) could lead to lower wave loads in 19905calculations.
ISO 19905 is largely based on 5-5A, however, the ISO development incorporatedsome major changes, including:Enhancements to calculation methodsSignificant changes in the geotechnical calculations, including the method ofcalculating acceptable bearing capacity, incorporation of deep penetrationcases, distinction between backfill and backflow, etc.
Changes to enhance compatibility with other ISO documents in the 19900series, particularly ISO 19902 addressing Fixed Offshore Structures [Ref.
3](e.
g.
the structural code checks for tubular members)Introduction of additional structural member checksRe-structuring of 5-5A into a more logical ISO formatIntroduction of "benign" changes required for ISO compatibility (e.
g.
introduction of apparent and intrinsic wave periods), although some proved tobe less benign than othersAdditional loadcases for jack-ups operating close to resonance Given so many changes, there was concern that the ISO may not be useable (e.
g.
there would be gaps, inconsistencies, and serious transposition errors), andeven if an analysis could be undertaken using it, the analysis results would besignificantly different from a similar assessment using 5-5A.
To ensure the compatibility and acceptability of ISO assessments results, a twopart benchmarking process was undertaken: Part 1 Contract a single consultant to ensure the complete ISO could be used toproduce an answer.
In effect, could an analysts start an analysis using thedocument and arrive at a solution - regardless of whether the solution wascorrect.
This work resulted in some important changes.
Part 2 Contract four consultants to assess four jack-up designs, and comparethe results to a comparable series of assessments based on SNAME Bulletin 5-5A.
In most cases each jack-up was assessed by two consultants with the analysesaligned at specific points.
Alignment allowed differences in ISO interpretationto be identified, and ensured that results did not diverge as they progressed.
A detailed sample calculation "Go-By" was also produced.

Related Results

Jack-up Operational Guidelines
Jack-up Operational Guidelines
ABSTRACT In the time interval between 1956 and 1977.Zapata Off-Shore Company has operated eleven jack-up rigs for a total of 127 rig-years of operating experience...
Site Assessment for Jack-Ups in Gulf of Mexico
Site Assessment for Jack-Ups in Gulf of Mexico
Abstract Over several years the jack-up industry has worked on SNAME Technical and Research Bulletin 5-5 ‘Recommended Practice for Site Assessment of Jack-ups’ to...
Evolving benchmarking practices: a review for research perspectives
Evolving benchmarking practices: a review for research perspectives
PurposeThe purpose of this study is to review a major section of the literature on benchmarking practices in order to achieve better perspectives for emerging benchmarking research...
EVALUASI TERHADAP PENERAPAN SISTEM MANAJEMEN MUTU ISO-9001:2008 DI POLITEKNIK NEGERI JAKARTA
EVALUASI TERHADAP PENERAPAN SISTEM MANAJEMEN MUTU ISO-9001:2008 DI POLITEKNIK NEGERI JAKARTA
Abstrak Penjaminan mutu di perguruan tinggi menjadi isu penting di Indonesia. Kewajiban adanya penjaminan mutu pada suatu lembaga pendidikan tinggi terdapat pada UU No. 20 Tahun...
Perceptions about benchmarking best practices among French managers: an exploratory survey
Perceptions about benchmarking best practices among French managers: an exploratory survey
PurposeThe purpose of this study is to present a discussion on the most commonly accepted benchmarking norms in the USA, the lessons learned from benchmarking experiences and see h...
Mobile phone usage for m‐learning: comparing heavy and light mobile phone users
Mobile phone usage for m‐learning: comparing heavy and light mobile phone users
PurposeMobile technologies offer the opportunity to embed learning in a natural environment. The objective of the study is to examine how the usage of mobile phones for m‐learning ...
Improving SME logistics performance through benchmarking
Improving SME logistics performance through benchmarking
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to discuss the applicability of current benchmarking proposals for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and to suggest a condensed process...

Back to Top