Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Two-Part Harmony: Concord and Strife Aboard Valerius Flaccus’ Argo

View through CrossRef
Valerius Flaccus’ <I>Argonautica</i> revolves around civil war and fratricide. These themes have a much stronger presence in Valerius’ epic than in other versions of the Argonautic legend (cf. Schenk), in keeping with a contemporary poetic predilection for civil and fraternal strife. Scholars connect the Flavian interest in these themes with the civil wars preceding the accession of the Flavian emperors and with the Flavian period itself (cf. McGuire, Hardie). My paper looks at how Valerius, who shapes his entire epic around the positive and negative interactions of fraternal pairs and the opposition between strife and concord, subtly twines civil war into his narrative. I argue in particular that Valerius activates the Flavian civil war <I>topos</i> not just in literal scenes of civil war but in his construction of the Argo and her crew. The Argo herself, as the locus of Argonautic confraternity, represents both strife and concord in a number of ways. Following the Argo’s construction from broken-apart planks (<I>dissolvere</i>, 1.123; cf. Stover), the shipwright Argus paints on the two sides of her hull the marriage of Peleus and Thetis (1.130–9) and the battle of the Lapiths and Centaurs (1.140-8). This juxtaposition illustrates her inbuilt discord. Furthermore, Argus must constantly ensure that the Argo’s hull – otherwise at risk of splitting apart – retains its impermeable integrity against the sea (1.477-80), while Orpheus uses his music to teach the oars not to fight amongst themselves (1.470-2). The Argo’s crew is evenly divided and rows equally (1.354-5, 1.494), but only so long as Argus and Orpheus are employed in staving off the ship’s inherent internal strife. Without these two enforcing <I>harmonia</i>, as their allotted tasks aboard the Argo indicate, the rowers of the Argo, their oars, and the ship herself would be at perpetual risk of strife and schism. Additionally, by having the Argonauts inscribe their names on their oars (<I>dant remo sua quisque viri, dant nomina transtris</i>, 1.352), Valerius highlights the name “<I>remus</i>” itself. This noun’s near-homophony with the name of Romulus’ ill-fated brother, Remus, imbued the ships of Latin literature with the potential for evoking specters of fratricide and civil war. Although most ancient authors seem not to have played with this available pun, Propertius certainly did in his poem on the Battle of Actium (4.6.19-21, 43-5; cf. Welch 101ff). I argue that Valerius, by including multiple pairs of brothers among the rowers, by associating oars with names and weapons (1.352, 2.392, 5.119), and in his description of Orpheus’ task (the singer is expressly exempt from “plowing” the sea, <I>nec ... pontum remo subigit</i>, 1.470-1), tacitly revives this pun in his <I>Argonautica</i>. The result is a muted allusion to Rome’s own origins in civil war, resonating with themes of civil war and fratricide that are present throughout the epic. As the epic progresses and the Argo sails towards the unceasing strife of the twin Clashing Rocks that occupy the epic’s center (4.637-702), the tensions of her perpetually repressed disharmony become increasingly strained. Ultimately, the Argo bursts through the Clashing Rocks and herself appears to burst apart (4.693-4), thus reenacting the strife of the rocks to which she has just put a stop. I propose that the opposed but exchangeable states of strife and concord in which the Argo is implicated present a series of alternative readings of Rome’s own apparent harmony and potential for fraternal strife in the period of history in which Valerius is writing. <u>Works Cited</u> Hardie, P. (1993) “Tales of Division and Unity in Imperial Latin Epic,” in J. H. Molyneux (ed.) <I>Literary Responses to Civil Discord</i>, 57-71. Nottingham. McGuire, D. T. (1997) <I>Acts of Silence: Civil War, Tyranny, and Suicide in the Flavian Epics</i>. (Altertumswissenschaftliche Texte und Studien Bd. 33). Hildesheim. Schenk, P. (1999) <I>Studien zur poetischen Kunst des Valerius Flaccus: Beobachtungen zur Ausgestaltung des Kriegsthemas in den Argonautica</i>. Munich. Stover, T. (2010) “Rebuilding Argo: Valerius Flaccus’ Poetic Creed.” <I>Mnemosyne</i> (forthcoming). Welch, T. S. (2005) <I>The Elegiac Cityscape: Propertius and the Meaning of Roman Monuments</i>. Columbus, Ohio.
Elsevier BV
Title: Two-Part Harmony: Concord and Strife Aboard Valerius Flaccus’ Argo
Description:
Valerius Flaccus’ <I>Argonautica</i> revolves around civil war and fratricide.
These themes have a much stronger presence in Valerius’ epic than in other versions of the Argonautic legend (cf.
Schenk), in keeping with a contemporary poetic predilection for civil and fraternal strife.
Scholars connect the Flavian interest in these themes with the civil wars preceding the accession of the Flavian emperors and with the Flavian period itself (cf.
McGuire, Hardie).
My paper looks at how Valerius, who shapes his entire epic around the positive and negative interactions of fraternal pairs and the opposition between strife and concord, subtly twines civil war into his narrative.
I argue in particular that Valerius activates the Flavian civil war <I>topos</i> not just in literal scenes of civil war but in his construction of the Argo and her crew.
The Argo herself, as the locus of Argonautic confraternity, represents both strife and concord in a number of ways.
Following the Argo’s construction from broken-apart planks (<I>dissolvere</i>, 1.
123; cf.
Stover), the shipwright Argus paints on the two sides of her hull the marriage of Peleus and Thetis (1.
130–9) and the battle of the Lapiths and Centaurs (1.
140-8).
This juxtaposition illustrates her inbuilt discord.
Furthermore, Argus must constantly ensure that the Argo’s hull – otherwise at risk of splitting apart – retains its impermeable integrity against the sea (1.
477-80), while Orpheus uses his music to teach the oars not to fight amongst themselves (1.
470-2).
The Argo’s crew is evenly divided and rows equally (1.
354-5, 1.
494), but only so long as Argus and Orpheus are employed in staving off the ship’s inherent internal strife.
Without these two enforcing <I>harmonia</i>, as their allotted tasks aboard the Argo indicate, the rowers of the Argo, their oars, and the ship herself would be at perpetual risk of strife and schism.
Additionally, by having the Argonauts inscribe their names on their oars (<I>dant remo sua quisque viri, dant nomina transtris</i>, 1.
352), Valerius highlights the name “<I>remus</i>” itself.
This noun’s near-homophony with the name of Romulus’ ill-fated brother, Remus, imbued the ships of Latin literature with the potential for evoking specters of fratricide and civil war.
Although most ancient authors seem not to have played with this available pun, Propertius certainly did in his poem on the Battle of Actium (4.
6.
19-21, 43-5; cf.
Welch 101ff).
I argue that Valerius, by including multiple pairs of brothers among the rowers, by associating oars with names and weapons (1.
352, 2.
392, 5.
119), and in his description of Orpheus’ task (the singer is expressly exempt from “plowing” the sea, <I>nec .
pontum remo subigit</i>, 1.
470-1), tacitly revives this pun in his <I>Argonautica</i>.
The result is a muted allusion to Rome’s own origins in civil war, resonating with themes of civil war and fratricide that are present throughout the epic.
As the epic progresses and the Argo sails towards the unceasing strife of the twin Clashing Rocks that occupy the epic’s center (4.
637-702), the tensions of her perpetually repressed disharmony become increasingly strained.
Ultimately, the Argo bursts through the Clashing Rocks and herself appears to burst apart (4.
693-4), thus reenacting the strife of the rocks to which she has just put a stop.
I propose that the opposed but exchangeable states of strife and concord in which the Argo is implicated present a series of alternative readings of Rome’s own apparent harmony and potential for fraternal strife in the period of history in which Valerius is writing.
<u>Works Cited</u> Hardie, P.
(1993) “Tales of Division and Unity in Imperial Latin Epic,” in J.
H.
Molyneux (ed.
) <I>Literary Responses to Civil Discord</i>, 57-71.
Nottingham.
McGuire, D.
T.
(1997) <I>Acts of Silence: Civil War, Tyranny, and Suicide in the Flavian Epics</i>.
(Altertumswissenschaftliche Texte und Studien Bd.
33).
Hildesheim.
Schenk, P.
(1999) <I>Studien zur poetischen Kunst des Valerius Flaccus: Beobachtungen zur Ausgestaltung des Kriegsthemas in den Argonautica</i>.
Munich.
Stover, T.
(2010) “Rebuilding Argo: Valerius Flaccus’ Poetic Creed.
” <I>Mnemosyne</i> (forthcoming).
Welch, T.
S.
(2005) <I>The Elegiac Cityscape: Propertius and the Meaning of Roman Monuments</i>.
Columbus, Ohio.

Related Results

Analisis Konsumsi Daya Listrik Pada Kereta Penumpang Kelas Eksekutif Argo Cirebon (Studi Pada PT. Kereta Api Indonesia Daop 1 Jakarta)
Analisis Konsumsi Daya Listrik Pada Kereta Penumpang Kelas Eksekutif Argo Cirebon (Studi Pada PT. Kereta Api Indonesia Daop 1 Jakarta)
ABSTRACT The purpose of this study is to conduct a study of the total electricity consumption on the Argo Cirebon executive class train, and to find out the number of passeng...
Introduction
Introduction
Abstract The Introduction sets out the book’s approach to reading Valerius Flaccus’s Argonautica, proposing that Valerius’s intertextual practices can be read as ...
Lagrangian measurements in the West Spitsbergen Current by Argo floats
Lagrangian measurements in the West Spitsbergen Current by Argo floats
&lt;p&gt;Almost 4000 operational Argo floats covering the world's ocean provide near-real-time data on its state. The Arctic is less covered than other waters, but observat...
Valerius Flaccus
Valerius Flaccus
Gaius Valerius Flaccus Setinus Balbus, usually known simply as Valerius Flaccus, is the author of the Argonautica, an unfinished epic poem in eight books composed during the Flavia...
Hungarian Vowel Harmony
Hungarian Vowel Harmony
Vowel harmony is the phonological requirement that vowels must agree in their specifications for some designated feature(s) (e.g., backness, roundness, height, tongue root) within ...
CUMBADAN RUMBAYA ROMANINDA KADIN ARGOSU
CUMBADAN RUMBAYA ROMANINDA KADIN ARGOSU
Peyami Safa’nın Server Bedi adıyla yayınladığı Cumbadan Rumbaya, doğu – batı çatışmasının Karagümrüklü Deli Cemile’yi merkeze alarak, mizahi dille anlatıldığı bir romandır. Romanda...
Conclusion
Conclusion
Abstract This concluding section draws together some of the threads of the foregoing investigation. It contains a brief discussion of how Silius, Statius, and Claudi...
The Circle Game
The Circle Game
Abstract Chapter 7 takes as its point of departure the much-discussed “two faces” of Venus in Valerius’s Lemnos episode, arguing for reading this Venus, much like...

Back to Top