Javascript must be enabled to continue!
The legend of ‘abd allah ibn ‘abd al-muttalib
View through CrossRef
The article is deals with analysis of the legend containing information about ‘Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib, included in the text of the «The Life of the Prophet» by Ibn Ishaq and Ibn Hisham. Due to the absence of «reliable» chains of transmissions that preceding this information, it has to be to considered not as a historical source, but as a literary legend. This work allowed us to identify the connection in plot and ideas between the Quranic story of the sacrifice of Ibrahim and the analyzed legend. Based on the data obtained by comparing the details of the two legends, three groups of reasons of the discrepancies between them were identified. A conclusion is made about the functional purpose of the legend of Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib in the text of the «The Life of the Prophet». Both stories are based on an attempted sacrifice of a son, ending up with a «substitution sacrifice». Based on the data obtained from comparison of details of the two legends, three groups of reasons for discrepancy between them were singled out. The first groups unites the core historical aspects of the legend of ‘Abd Allah that could not be omitted or changed by the authors of the The Life of the Prophet. Existence of the second group is due to the prophetic status of Ibrahim and Ismail, while the pagans ‘Abd al-Muttalib and ‘Abd Allah do not possess it. The third group includes traces of external influences that might have effected creation of the literary version of life of ‘Abd Allah. For instance, mentioning «the light of ‘Abd Allah» and Amina ibn Vahb’s miraculous vision has no direct similarities in the Abrahamic traditions. In the author’s opinion, search for these similarity allows us to assume that the legend could have been influenced by the Zoroastrian tradition.
RIOR Publishing Center
Title: The legend of ‘abd allah ibn ‘abd al-muttalib
Description:
The article is deals with analysis of the legend containing information about ‘Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib, included in the text of the «The Life of the Prophet» by Ibn Ishaq and Ibn Hisham.
Due to the absence of «reliable» chains of transmissions that preceding this information, it has to be to considered not as a historical source, but as a literary legend.
This work allowed us to identify the connection in plot and ideas between the Quranic story of the sacrifice of Ibrahim and the analyzed legend.
Based on the data obtained by comparing the details of the two legends, three groups of reasons of the discrepancies between them were identified.
A conclusion is made about the functional purpose of the legend of Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib in the text of the «The Life of the Prophet».
Both stories are based on an attempted sacrifice of a son, ending up with a «substitution sacrifice».
Based on the data obtained from comparison of details of the two legends, three groups of reasons for discrepancy between them were singled out.
The first groups unites the core historical aspects of the legend of ‘Abd Allah that could not be omitted or changed by the authors of the The Life of the Prophet.
Existence of the second group is due to the prophetic status of Ibrahim and Ismail, while the pagans ‘Abd al-Muttalib and ‘Abd Allah do not possess it.
The third group includes traces of external influences that might have effected creation of the literary version of life of ‘Abd Allah.
For instance, mentioning «the light of ‘Abd Allah» and Amina ibn Vahb’s miraculous vision has no direct similarities in the Abrahamic traditions.
In the author’s opinion, search for these similarity allows us to assume that the legend could have been influenced by the Zoroastrian tradition.
Related Results
Like Lady Godiva
Like Lady Godiva
Introducing Lady Godiva through a Fan-Historical Lens
The legend of Lady Godiva, who famously rode naked through the streets of Coventry, veiled only by her long, flowing hair, has...
Sahabe Şiirlerinde Medine’ye Hicret
Sahabe Şiirlerinde Medine’ye Hicret
Allah Resûlü (s.a.v.),
haksızlıkların ve çarpık inanç biçimlerinin hüküm sürdüğü Mekke ortamında
dünyaya gelir ve kırk yaşına bastığında Yüce Allah tarafından peygamberlikle
görevl...
[Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir’s Political Involvement According to The Chronicle Of Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi] Penglibatan Politik Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir Menurut Catatan Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi
[Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir’s Political Involvement According to The Chronicle Of Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi] Penglibatan Politik Muhammad Ibn Abi ‘Amir Menurut Catatan Ibn Hayyan Al-Qurtubi
Abstract
Muhammad ibn Abi ‘Amir was a de facto leader of al-Andalus during the Umayyad rule based in Cordoba. Caliph al-Hakam II had appointed him to hold some political posi...
Sadreddin Konevî’ye Göre “Allah” İsmi ve Sırları
Sadreddin Konevî’ye Göre “Allah” İsmi ve Sırları
Sadreddin Konevi, vahdet-i vücud düşüncesinin en önemli temsilcilerinden biridir. Konevi, sadece şeyhi İbnü’l Arabi’nin eserlerini şerhetmekle yetinmemiş, bir çok eser vermiş, kend...
Kasih dan Keadilan Allah Berdasarkan Amos 2:6-16
Kasih dan Keadilan Allah Berdasarkan Amos 2:6-16
Allah mengetahui semua perbuatan manusia yang dilakukan dalam seluruh kehidupan manusia. Allah sangat membenci dosa. Allah ingin menunjukkan bahwa dosa yang dilakukan oleh Israel s...
Ibn Ṭumlūs’s Commentary on Ibn Sīnā’s Poem on Medicine The Text within its Context
Ibn Ṭumlūs’s Commentary on Ibn Sīnā’s Poem on Medicine The Text within its Context
Abstract
What makes Ibn Ṭumlūs’
Commentary
on Ibn Sīnā’s
Poem on Medicine
...
Kur'an'da Sınırlayıcı Bir Kayıt İfadesi: Allah’ın İzni
Kur'an'da Sınırlayıcı Bir Kayıt İfadesi: Allah’ın İzni
Kur’an, insanların Allah’la, diğer insanlarla ve toplumla ilişkilerini düzenleyen; onların dünya ve ahiret hayatında mutluluğa erişme yollarını onlara sunan pek çok konuya temas et...
Nilai-nilai Pendidikan Aqidah dalam Prespektif QS. Al-Baqarah Ayat 186
Nilai-nilai Pendidikan Aqidah dalam Prespektif QS. Al-Baqarah Ayat 186
Abstract. Education problems in Indonesia involve phenomena such as bullying and LGBTQ understanding. One of the problems is in the aqidah, as explained in Al-Baqarah verse 186. Th...

