Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Biopolitical Foundation of The Theory of M.M. Bakhtin's Carnival
View through CrossRef
Bakhtin is an ambiguous thinker, who manifests himself as well in the political interpretation of his ideas. The political context of Bakhtin's thought is mostly considered based on the work “Rabelais and His World”. The article aims to identify the meaning structures of Bakhtin's work on Rabelais, which determine the political interpretation of his concept. The highlighted meaning structures are interconnected. They represent a series of Bakhtin's theses on the classificatory character of the division of cultural consciousness, on the decline of the laughter principle, etc. These theses form a coherent narrative that can be interpreted in completely different ways. Bakhtin's concept may be presented by interpreters in liberal or leftist way, as well as deeply conservative. These interpretations are based on different understandings of the status of carnivalization, which is essentially identical to the phenomenon of transgression. Accordingly, the second aim of the article is to show how Bakhtin understood transgression. To contextualize Bakhtin's concept of carnivalization, some of his points, which are similar to the ones made by the theorists of the ambivalent sacred (J. Bataille and R. Caillois) are considered. But a fact remains that requires explanation: Bakhtin's thought does not fit well into the framework of one or another political interpretation. As an explanation, a hypothesis of the biopolitical basis of Bakhtin's concept is put forward. The Agamben's figure of naked life constituted by sovereign power is contrasted with the Bakhtin's figure of material-bodily bottom, as the idea of the collective immortality of the people.
National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE)
Title: Biopolitical Foundation of The Theory of M.M. Bakhtin's Carnival
Description:
Bakhtin is an ambiguous thinker, who manifests himself as well in the political interpretation of his ideas.
The political context of Bakhtin's thought is mostly considered based on the work “Rabelais and His World”.
The article aims to identify the meaning structures of Bakhtin's work on Rabelais, which determine the political interpretation of his concept.
The highlighted meaning structures are interconnected.
They represent a series of Bakhtin's theses on the classificatory character of the division of cultural consciousness, on the decline of the laughter principle, etc.
These theses form a coherent narrative that can be interpreted in completely different ways.
Bakhtin's concept may be presented by interpreters in liberal or leftist way, as well as deeply conservative.
These interpretations are based on different understandings of the status of carnivalization, which is essentially identical to the phenomenon of transgression.
Accordingly, the second aim of the article is to show how Bakhtin understood transgression.
To contextualize Bakhtin's concept of carnivalization, some of his points, which are similar to the ones made by the theorists of the ambivalent sacred (J.
Bataille and R.
Caillois) are considered.
But a fact remains that requires explanation: Bakhtin's thought does not fit well into the framework of one or another political interpretation.
As an explanation, a hypothesis of the biopolitical basis of Bakhtin's concept is put forward.
The Agamben's figure of naked life constituted by sovereign power is contrasted with the Bakhtin's figure of material-bodily bottom, as the idea of the collective immortality of the people.
Related Results
Game Theory in Business Ethics: Bad Ideology or Bad Press?
Game Theory in Business Ethics: Bad Ideology or Bad Press?
Solomon’s article and Binmore’s response exemplify a standard exchange between the game theorist and those critical of applying game theory to ethics. The critic of game theory lis...
YCC: a gendered carnival? Project work at Volvo Cars
YCC: a gendered carnival? Project work at Volvo Cars
PurposeTo discusss the first concept car development project in the automotive industry managed by female engineers and designers.Design/methodology/approachAn abiding concern in f...
Erasmus' Praise of Folly and the Spirit of Carnival
Erasmus' Praise of Folly and the Spirit of Carnival
In his far-ranging study, Rabelais and His World, Mikhail Bakhtin describes Erasmus’ Praise of Folly as the most complete expression in the Renaissance of Medieval Latin humour and...
Making Mas: TruDynasty Carnival Takes Josephine Baker to the Caribbean Carnival
Making Mas: TruDynasty Carnival Takes Josephine Baker to the Caribbean Carnival
Over a million spectators descend on Lakeshore Avenue each year to watch Mas Bands create a kinaesthetic landscape of colour with elaborate costumes as they parade in Toronto's Sco...
Women and Carnival Space
Women and Carnival Space
This article focuses on gender relations through the performance of carnival rites in a North Aegean island rural community. Based on qualitative research, it approaches the women’...
Celebrating Her First Half-Century: Queensland's Jubilee Carnival
Celebrating Her First Half-Century: Queensland's Jubilee Carnival
Queensland's Jubilee Carnival of 1909 was, according to Australia's Governor-General, Lord Dudley, ‘the principal and most prominent feature in the series of festivities by which t...
THE CHALLENGES OF ARCHIVING AND RESEARCHING CARNIVAL ART
THE CHALLENGES OF ARCHIVING AND RESEARCHING CARNIVAL ART
The fact that live performance is unrepeatable is both its greatest attribute and a constant worry to theatre historians. How is it possible to study an art form that is fleeting, ...
The carnival of verbal dueling
The carnival of verbal dueling
AbstractIn this article I discuss an example of verbal dueling in Hip Hop culture from the perspective of Bakhtin's (1984) notion of the carnival. Both carnival and Hip Hop are sub...