Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Biopolitical Foundation of The Theory of M.M. Bakhtin's Carnival

View through CrossRef
Bakhtin is an ambiguous thinker, who manifests himself as well in the political interpretation of his ideas. The political context of Bakhtin's thought is mostly considered based on the work “Rabelais and His World”. The article aims to identify the meaning structures of Bakhtin's work on Rabelais, which determine the political interpretation of his concept. The highlighted meaning structures are interconnected. They represent a series of Bakhtin's theses on the classificatory character of the division of cultural consciousness, on the decline of the laughter principle, etc. These theses form a coherent narrative that can be interpreted in completely different ways. Bakhtin's concept may be presented by interpreters in liberal or leftist way, as well as deeply conservative. These interpretations are based on different understandings of the status of carnivalization, which is essentially identical to the phenomenon of transgression. Accordingly, the second aim of the article is to show how Bakhtin understood transgression. To contextualize Bakhtin's concept of carnivalization, some of his points, which are similar to the ones made by the theorists of the ambivalent sacred (J. Bataille and R. Caillois) are considered. But a fact remains that requires explanation: Bakhtin's thought does not fit well into the framework of one or another political interpretation. As an explanation, a hypothesis of the biopolitical basis of Bakhtin's concept is put forward. The Agamben's figure of naked life constituted by sovereign power is contrasted with the Bakhtin's figure of material-bodily bottom, as the idea of the collective immortality of the people.
National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE)
Title: Biopolitical Foundation of The Theory of M.M. Bakhtin's Carnival
Description:
Bakhtin is an ambiguous thinker, who manifests himself as well in the political interpretation of his ideas.
The political context of Bakhtin's thought is mostly considered based on the work “Rabelais and His World”.
The article aims to identify the meaning structures of Bakhtin's work on Rabelais, which determine the political interpretation of his concept.
The highlighted meaning structures are interconnected.
They represent a series of Bakhtin's theses on the classificatory character of the division of cultural consciousness, on the decline of the laughter principle, etc.
These theses form a coherent narrative that can be interpreted in completely different ways.
Bakhtin's concept may be presented by interpreters in liberal or leftist way, as well as deeply conservative.
These interpretations are based on different understandings of the status of carnivalization, which is essentially identical to the phenomenon of transgression.
Accordingly, the second aim of the article is to show how Bakhtin understood transgression.
To contextualize Bakhtin's concept of carnivalization, some of his points, which are similar to the ones made by the theorists of the ambivalent sacred (J.
Bataille and R.
Caillois) are considered.
But a fact remains that requires explanation: Bakhtin's thought does not fit well into the framework of one or another political interpretation.
As an explanation, a hypothesis of the biopolitical basis of Bakhtin's concept is put forward.
The Agamben's figure of naked life constituted by sovereign power is contrasted with the Bakhtin's figure of material-bodily bottom, as the idea of the collective immortality of the people.

Related Results

Mikhail Bakhtin
Mikhail Bakhtin
Mikhail Mikhailovich Bakhtin (b. 1895–d. 1975) has received much more scholarly attention since his death than he ever did while alive. Bakhtin’s early years found him joining smal...
Bakhtin, Mikhail Mikhailovich (1895–1975)
Bakhtin, Mikhail Mikhailovich (1895–1975)
Bakhtin is generally regarded as the most influential twentieth-century Russian literary theorist. His writings on literature, language, ethics, authorship, carnival, time and the ...
Bakhtin in Shanghai. ‘Chinese lessons’ for Bakhtin studies
Bakhtin in Shanghai. ‘Chinese lessons’ for Bakhtin studies
The philosopher M. Bakhtin occupies a unique place in the process of shaping of a new humanistic paradigm. Amid the 1960s crisis in the West, Bakhtin’s key concepts, from ‘carnival...
Bakhtin, Mikhail (1895–1975)
Bakhtin, Mikhail (1895–1975)
Mikhail Bakhtin was a Russian philosopher and thinker whose long career concerned aesthetics, ethics, literary and cultural theory, linguistics, and sociology. His earliest works, ...
Maneiras criativas de não gostar de Bakhtin: Lydia Ginzburg e Mikhail Gasparov
Maneiras criativas de não gostar de Bakhtin: Lydia Ginzburg e Mikhail Gasparov
RESUMO Este artigo contribui para nossa compreensão de como os russos receberam os conceitos de Bakhtin, principalmente dois influentes estudiosos russos, críticos de Bakhtin, cada...
Queen Of The Bands: Carnival And “Monarchy” In The (416)
Queen Of The Bands: Carnival And “Monarchy” In The (416)
Queen of the Bands: Carnival and “Monarchy” in the (416) is a solo multimedia gallery installation which explores the complexity of Queenliness through the audio and photographic d...
Queen Of The Bands: Carnival And “Monarchy” In The (416)
Queen Of The Bands: Carnival And “Monarchy” In The (416)
Queen of the Bands: Carnival and “Monarchy” in the (416) is a solo multimedia gallery installation which explores the complexity of Queenliness through the audio and photographic d...
Restraining Biopolitics: On Dino Buzzati’s Living Animals
Restraining Biopolitics: On Dino Buzzati’s Living Animals
Michel Foucault’s linking of man to a certain kind of animal that becomes available in modernity anchors my reading of Italian modernity and the birth of the biopolitical animal in...

Back to Top