Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Information as an occurrence: Pêcheux, discourse and its materiality
View through CrossRef
Purpose
This paper advances a redefinition of information grounded in Michel Pêcheux’s materialist discourse theory. Rather than conceiving information as a representational object or manifested entity, the paper argues that information is best understood as an occurrence – a discursive event produced under determinate historical, ideological and material conditions. The purpose is to articulate the theoretical consequences of this shift for key concepts in Information Science, including relevance, context, document, metadata, knowledge organisation and information behaviour.
Design/methodology/approach
This is a conceptual and discursive study. It employs close theoretical analysis of Pêcheux’s major works (1969/1995; 1975/1982; 1983/2008), combined with a critical dialogue with contemporary Information Science literature such as manifested information (Petras, 2024), document theory (Buckland, 1991, 1997, 2018; Briet, 1951/2006) and epistemological debates in Knowledge Organisation (Machado et al., 2019). The method is interpretive and philosophical, prioritising conceptual clarification and theoretical synthesis rather than empirical examination.
Findings
The analysis demonstrates that representational models of information – whether as thing, record, document or manifestation – are insufficient for capturing the eventual, unstable and ideologically saturated nature of meaning. Conceptualising information as occurrence reveals that informational phenomena are inseparable from material inscription, discursive memory, ideological determination, contextual embeddedness and interpretive labour. This reconceptualisation transforms the understanding of relevance, context, metadata and classification, repositioning them as discursive and ideological practices rather than neutral technical processes.
Research limitations/implications
As a conceptual paper, the study does not offer empirical validation. Its implications are theoretical and methodological: it calls for research designs capable of accounting for discursive production, ideological structuring and historicity in informational phenomena. It also highlights the limitations of behavioural, cognitively oriented and representational methodologies, inviting a broader interpretive and critical approach within the field.
Practical implications
Understanding information as an occurrence exposes the ideological and political dimensions of information work. It emphasises that classification, description, metadata creation, retrieval algorithms and preservation practices actively shape the conditions under which meaning becomes possible. The perspective supports critical cataloguing, inclusive metadata practices and reflexive systems design attentive to context, ideology and interpretive authority.
Social implications
By foregrounding the discursive and ideological constitution of information, the paper offers tools to analyse contemporary issues such as misinformation, algorithmic bias, epistemic injustice and discursive inequality. Recognising informational systems as ideological dispositifs enhances the capacity to critique and redesign them in socially responsible ways.
Originality/value
The paper is the first to develop a sustained theoretical synthesis between Pêcheux’s materialist discourse analysis and Information Science. It introduces the notion of information-as-occurrence as an original ontological proposal and offers a rigorous re-evaluation of foundational Information Science concepts through this lens. The contribution expands the field’s conceptual foundations and provides a theoretical framework capable of addressing informational instability, discursive conflict and ideological structuration in contemporary information environments.
Title: Information as an occurrence: Pêcheux, discourse and its materiality
Description:
Purpose
This paper advances a redefinition of information grounded in Michel Pêcheux’s materialist discourse theory.
Rather than conceiving information as a representational object or manifested entity, the paper argues that information is best understood as an occurrence – a discursive event produced under determinate historical, ideological and material conditions.
The purpose is to articulate the theoretical consequences of this shift for key concepts in Information Science, including relevance, context, document, metadata, knowledge organisation and information behaviour.
Design/methodology/approach
This is a conceptual and discursive study.
It employs close theoretical analysis of Pêcheux’s major works (1969/1995; 1975/1982; 1983/2008), combined with a critical dialogue with contemporary Information Science literature such as manifested information (Petras, 2024), document theory (Buckland, 1991, 1997, 2018; Briet, 1951/2006) and epistemological debates in Knowledge Organisation (Machado et al.
, 2019).
The method is interpretive and philosophical, prioritising conceptual clarification and theoretical synthesis rather than empirical examination.
Findings
The analysis demonstrates that representational models of information – whether as thing, record, document or manifestation – are insufficient for capturing the eventual, unstable and ideologically saturated nature of meaning.
Conceptualising information as occurrence reveals that informational phenomena are inseparable from material inscription, discursive memory, ideological determination, contextual embeddedness and interpretive labour.
This reconceptualisation transforms the understanding of relevance, context, metadata and classification, repositioning them as discursive and ideological practices rather than neutral technical processes.
Research limitations/implications
As a conceptual paper, the study does not offer empirical validation.
Its implications are theoretical and methodological: it calls for research designs capable of accounting for discursive production, ideological structuring and historicity in informational phenomena.
It also highlights the limitations of behavioural, cognitively oriented and representational methodologies, inviting a broader interpretive and critical approach within the field.
Practical implications
Understanding information as an occurrence exposes the ideological and political dimensions of information work.
It emphasises that classification, description, metadata creation, retrieval algorithms and preservation practices actively shape the conditions under which meaning becomes possible.
The perspective supports critical cataloguing, inclusive metadata practices and reflexive systems design attentive to context, ideology and interpretive authority.
Social implications
By foregrounding the discursive and ideological constitution of information, the paper offers tools to analyse contemporary issues such as misinformation, algorithmic bias, epistemic injustice and discursive inequality.
Recognising informational systems as ideological dispositifs enhances the capacity to critique and redesign them in socially responsible ways.
Originality/value
The paper is the first to develop a sustained theoretical synthesis between Pêcheux’s materialist discourse analysis and Information Science.
It introduces the notion of information-as-occurrence as an original ontological proposal and offers a rigorous re-evaluation of foundational Information Science concepts through this lens.
The contribution expands the field’s conceptual foundations and provides a theoretical framework capable of addressing informational instability, discursive conflict and ideological structuration in contemporary information environments.
Related Results
Examining the extent of and drivers for materiality assessment disclosures in sustainability reports
Examining the extent of and drivers for materiality assessment disclosures in sustainability reports
Purpose
This paper aims to evaluate the extent of materiality assessment disclosures in sustainability reports and their determinants. The study examines the di...
Materiality in the context of audit: the real expectations gap
Materiality in the context of audit: the real expectations gap
PurposeThis paper seeks to focus on the issue of materiality judgements and the need for public disclosure of materiality levels. Insights about the concept of materiality are draw...
Materiality in Performing an Audit – Experimental Evidence
Materiality in Performing an Audit – Experimental Evidence
At present, ways to improve audit quality and auditing decisions are intensively being discussed worldwide by standard setters and researchers. Audit quality is mainly influenced b...
Discourse Coherence in Chinese
Discourse Coherence in Chinese
Discourse coherence is motivated by the need of the speaker to be understood, which is a psychological phenomenon reflected in the organization of natural discourse. It can be real...
Les théorisations du discours de Michel Pêcheux et Michel Foucault à la lumière du concept d'énonciation
Les théorisations du discours de Michel Pêcheux et Michel Foucault à la lumière du concept d'énonciation
Pêcheux et Foucault ne se sont probablement jamais rencontrés dans leur aventure intellectuelle. Pourtant ils partagent un mot – « formation discursive » –, et un objet d’intérêt –...
Kritička analiza diskursa o fleksibilizaciji tržišta rada
Kritička analiza diskursa o fleksibilizaciji tržišta rada
The research is focused on the study of public discourse on labor market flexibilization in Croatia during the reform of the Croatian Labor Act which was undertaken by the Croatian...
Korea at a Regulatory Crossroads: Double Materiality and the Future of ESG Accountability
Korea at a Regulatory Crossroads: Double Materiality and the Future of ESG Accountability
The European Union's adoption of double materiality through the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) has introduced a major divergence in global corporate accountabi...
Harmonization and fragmentation in competing ESG materiality regimes and their implications for sustainability reporting
Harmonization and fragmentation in competing ESG materiality regimes and their implications for sustainability reporting
Abstract
Purpose
The rapid development of ESG reporting practices raises cross-border pressures regarding convergence tow...

