Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Plutarch: The Malice of Herodotos
View through CrossRef
The Malice of Herodotus can perhaps best be described as the world's earliest known book review. But it is much more than that, for in the course of 'correcting' with considerable vituperation what he saw as Herodotus' anti-Greek bias, Plutarch tells us much about his own attitude to writing history. So that together with Lucian's How to Write History, it forms a basic text for the study of Greek historiography. It is also perhaps the most revealing example of Plutarch's prose style with its rhetorical variety and energy and odd mixture of good and bad argument. But in citing lost works, Plutarch has preserved valuable fragments which don't exist elsewhere and need to be assessed by all students of the Persian Wars. The book presents Greek text with translation, introduction and commentary.
Title: Plutarch: The Malice of Herodotos
Description:
The Malice of Herodotus can perhaps best be described as the world's earliest known book review.
But it is much more than that, for in the course of 'correcting' with considerable vituperation what he saw as Herodotus' anti-Greek bias, Plutarch tells us much about his own attitude to writing history.
So that together with Lucian's How to Write History, it forms a basic text for the study of Greek historiography.
It is also perhaps the most revealing example of Plutarch's prose style with its rhetorical variety and energy and odd mixture of good and bad argument.
But in citing lost works, Plutarch has preserved valuable fragments which don't exist elsewhere and need to be assessed by all students of the Persian Wars.
The book presents Greek text with translation, introduction and commentary.
Related Results
VIEWS OF HERODOTOS AND PERSIANS IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ORIENT-OCCIDENT OPPOSITION
VIEWS OF HERODOTOS AND PERSIANS IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ORIENT-OCCIDENT OPPOSITION
Antikçağ’ın öne çıkan bölgelerinden Karia’nın Halikarnassos şehrinde dünyaya gelen Herodotos’un hayatı ile alakalı sınırlı bilgiye ulaşılmaktadır. Herodotos’un ismini zikreden üç y...
Plutarch: Upon the Malice of Herodotus
Plutarch: Upon the Malice of Herodotus
This chapter includes the original Greek text of Plutarch's The Malice of Herodotus. It discusses how Plutarch called Herodotus out on several of its errors, outlining the factors ...
Introduction
Introduction
This chapter describes Plutarch's essay The Malice of Herodotus and explains how it was an oddity among his works. It explains how the essay criticized the works of the Herodotus i...
History without Malice?
History without Malice?
Abstract
The chapter analyses to what extent Plutarch wrote without malice in those places where he clearly used Herodotus as a major source. In the account of So...
Introduction
Introduction
This introductory chapter provides an overview of Plutarch's Lives, which represent a valuable ancient source for the more interesting periods of Greek and Roman history. However, ...
Plutarch’s Troy
Plutarch’s Troy
Chapter 12 argues that Plutarch shows no interest in contemporary debates on Troy’s location and its relation to the city of Ilium but constructs his own, imaginary Troy, on the ba...
Plutarch’s Northern Greek Cities
Plutarch’s Northern Greek Cities
Chapter 11 argues that Plutarch shows no interest in contemporary debates on Troy’s location and its relation to the city of Ilium but constructs his own, imaginary Troy, on the ba...
Conclusions
Conclusions
This chapter describes the main features of the content and structure of the Persica works as gathered in this study, and outlines Plutarch's method of employing these sources. Som...

