Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Work, Domination, and the False Hope of Universal Basic Income

View through CrossRef
AbstractUniversal basic income (UBI) is increasingly proposed as a simple answer to the problem of domination at work—one policy whose knock-on effects will transform the balance of power between workers and employers. I argue against such ‘UBI-first’ approaches. Compared to UBI proposals for other purposes, a UBI sufficient or near-sufficient for minimising domination at work would be especially demanding in two ways. First, the level of the grant would be more demanding compared to UBIs suitable for other purposes, in order for workers to be able to credibly threaten to leave their jobs. Secondly, the maintenance of the grant must also meet strict criteria. The demanding level of the grant must be effectively secured against reduction, allowing workers to plan on its long-term acceptability; and in order to avoid increased state domination it must assume the status of an entitlement rather than a gift that may be withdrawn, through stabilisation against political change or some other means. These difficulties render UBI-first approaches doubtful at best, and an unhelpful distraction from other, more fruitful strategies at worst.
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Title: Work, Domination, and the False Hope of Universal Basic Income
Description:
AbstractUniversal basic income (UBI) is increasingly proposed as a simple answer to the problem of domination at work—one policy whose knock-on effects will transform the balance of power between workers and employers.
I argue against such ‘UBI-first’ approaches.
Compared to UBI proposals for other purposes, a UBI sufficient or near-sufficient for minimising domination at work would be especially demanding in two ways.
First, the level of the grant would be more demanding compared to UBIs suitable for other purposes, in order for workers to be able to credibly threaten to leave their jobs.
Secondly, the maintenance of the grant must also meet strict criteria.
The demanding level of the grant must be effectively secured against reduction, allowing workers to plan on its long-term acceptability; and in order to avoid increased state domination it must assume the status of an entitlement rather than a gift that may be withdrawn, through stabilisation against political change or some other means.
These difficulties render UBI-first approaches doubtful at best, and an unhelpful distraction from other, more fruitful strategies at worst.

Related Results

Constantinople as 'New Rome'
Constantinople as 'New Rome'
<!--[if gte mso 9]><xml> <o:DocumentProperties> <o:Revision>0</o:Revision> <o:TotalTime>0</o:TotalTime> <o:Pages>1</o:Pages> &...
Why Do Birds False Alarm Flight?
Why Do Birds False Alarm Flight?
False alarm flighting in avian flocks is common, and has been explained as a maladaptive information cascade. If false alarm flighting is maladaptive per se, then its frequency can...
Importance of basic research in the academic training of health science students
Importance of basic research in the academic training of health science students
Dear Editor: I have been pleasantly impressed by the initiative to include as a topic of consideration, in the Interamerican Journal of Health Sciences, the importance of basic res...
Estimating the Additional Income Needed to Address Higher Deprivation Levels of Children in Households with Disabled People
Estimating the Additional Income Needed to Address Higher Deprivation Levels of Children in Households with Disabled People
Children living in households with disabled people have a rate of material hardship three times that of children living in households with no disabled people. The rate of severe ma...
A simple method for estimating the Lorenz curve
A simple method for estimating the Lorenz curve
AbstractGiven many popular functional forms for the Lorenz curve do not have a closed-form expression for the Gini index and no study has utilized the observed Gini index to estima...
Adorno, Marx, and abstract domination
Adorno, Marx, and abstract domination
This article reconstructs and defends Theodor Adorno’s social theory by motivating the central role of abstract domination within it. Whereas critics such as Axel Honneth have char...
Universal History Upside Down
Universal History Upside Down
Universal history as traditionally understood emerged out of the semi-secularization of Biblical history that followed Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel’s attempt to think the whole of...

Recent Results

Public engagement coming of age: From theory to practice in STS encounters with nanotechnology
Public engagement coming of age: From theory to practice in STS encounters with nanotechnology
In this paper, we present a study of Science and Technology Studies (STS) perspectives on public engagement, specifically focusing on the gap between theory and practice. In aiming...
John Hales (1582-1656). A Tolerant Man Living in an Intolerant Age
John Hales (1582-1656). A Tolerant Man Living in an Intolerant Age
John Hales (1582-1656). A Tolerant Man Living in an Intolerant Age This article focuses upon the seventeenth-century English philosophical theologian, John Hales, wh...

Back to Top