Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Applications of Neutrality
View through CrossRef
Advantages of the neutrality approach to natural languages are sketched. Paradigmatic ontological debates are described (about entities such as God or Bigfoot), and it is shown how the neutral approach can accommodate requirements on such debates, such as both parties understanding the claims of the other parties but disagreeing on the truth values of certain sentences that are nevertheless understood in common. There are also puzzles about how individuals are supposed to think about particular nonexistent beings over time, or how more than one individual can think about the same nonexistent being. It’s shown how the neutralist approach can accommodate this by focusing, in particular, on Geach’s Hob-Nob puzzle. Pretense approaches to fictional talk are undermined by showing that they prevent expression of needed claims we make about entities.
Title: Applications of Neutrality
Description:
Advantages of the neutrality approach to natural languages are sketched.
Paradigmatic ontological debates are described (about entities such as God or Bigfoot), and it is shown how the neutral approach can accommodate requirements on such debates, such as both parties understanding the claims of the other parties but disagreeing on the truth values of certain sentences that are nevertheless understood in common.
There are also puzzles about how individuals are supposed to think about particular nonexistent beings over time, or how more than one individual can think about the same nonexistent being.
It’s shown how the neutralist approach can accommodate this by focusing, in particular, on Geach’s Hob-Nob puzzle.
Pretense approaches to fictional talk are undermined by showing that they prevent expression of needed claims we make about entities.
Related Results
Beyond Politics
Beyond Politics
Chapter 3 shows how ideologically diverse activists and legislators converged around a narrow, single-issue opposition to child sexual abuse and defined it as a politically neutral...
Introduction
Introduction
This handbook examines Swedish politics as well as institutional changes, political decision-making, foreign affairs, and political behavior. It discusses political change and poli...
Olof Palme, Sweden, and the Vietnam War
Olof Palme, Sweden, and the Vietnam War
In 1972, Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme’s fierce condemnation of the Christmas Bombings of the North Vietnamese cities of Hanoi and Haiphong led to a breakdown in diplomatic rel...
William Franklin Sands in Late Choson Korea
William Franklin Sands in Late Choson Korea
After graduation from Georgetown University in 1896, William Franklin Sands joined the US diplomatic corps as second secretary in Tokyo. His year there sparked his interest in East...
Master Tara Singh Emerges as the Foremost Sikh Leader
Master Tara Singh Emerges as the Foremost Sikh Leader
The Akalis joined the civil disobedience movement, and Master Tara Singh was arrested while leading an Akali jathā to Peshawar and sent to jail. The Communal Award of August 1932 r...
Introduction
Introduction
The introduction lays out a model of social movement relationships that are neither coalitions nor oppositional, including their form and outcomes. It outlines three types of relat...
Introduction
Introduction
There is already an important literature on religion and political philosophy, focusing especially on controversies about religious symbols, freedom of speech, or secular education...
The American Magazine in the Early National Period
The American Magazine in the Early National Period
This chapter explores the demographics of the early magazine readers as well as reader contributions to these magazines. It emphasizes how deeply collaborative and interactive the ...

