Density-Dependent Escapement of Rusty Crayfish from Modified Minnow Traps with Varying Throat Configurations

Abstract Modified minnow traps are the most widely used gear for collecting tertiary burrowing crayfishes. The throats of modified minnow traps are often widened more than 60% to accommodate the capture of larger crayfish. However, widening this crucial chokepoint into the trap may facilitate easier escape of captured individuals, especially as density in the trap increases. Increased escapement rates may reduce catch rates and corresponding estimates of relative abundance and lower detection probability. Incorporating a design feature, that is, throat restriction, that allows entry of all sizes of crayfish while reducing escapement would be an improvement over current designs. Here, I present the results of a paired field and laboratory experiment comparing the effectiveness of modified minnow traps with a throat restriction (restricted) and without such a feature (unrestricted) under varying crayfish densities. I chose rusty crayfish Faxonius rusticus as a study organism because it is widespread and abundant in the Laurentian Great Lakes region and commonly the focus of research and removal efforts. Rusty crayfish capture and escapement were strongly influenced by throat design and crayfish densities. The field component demonstrated that both traps performed similarly under low-to-moderate densities; however, at high densities catch in unrestricted traps plateaued at approximately 50 crayfish/trap, while restricted traps kept accumulating catch up to 155 crayfish/trap. Laboratory trials demonstrated that escapement for both trap types was negligible at low density and slightly higher at medium density: 0.8% for restricted and 11.5% for unrestricted. However, at high density, escapement from restricted traps was 8.8 vs. 45.3% for unrestricted traps. Our findings suggest that inclusion of a throat restriction may increase catch of rusty crayfish by reducing escapement and may be of particular use in removal projects or when sampling in high-density populations.