Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Khotyn battle 1621. Іgnored source in ukrainian historiography
View through CrossRef
The article offers a historiographical consideration of the description of the Khotyn battle 1621with an emphasis on the historical value of M. Kostin's “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” in the coverage of theevent. The relevance of the study is dictated by the 400th anniversary of the battle. The purpose of the study is to clarify the historical significance of thechronicle in revealing the theme of the Battle of Khotyn in 1621. Methodology describes the work of M. Kostin, its source base, comparison with other historical sources, review of its use. Conclusions. “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” by Myron Kostin, being the only source for studying the history of Moldova in the early and mid seventeenth century. at the same time it is a true description of the events of the Khotyn War (1620–1621). Although the chronicler is not a contemporary of the events, his account of the Battle of Khotyn is based on serious Polish sources of the relevant era, oral information from contemporaries of the fighting, the traditions of the princely family of Movileshty, and so on. The work is positively characterized by a deep and detailed description of events, impartiality, clear analysis of military operations of a participant in many battles, education of the author and his broad outlook, which allowed him to understand the causal links of actions, actions of the parties, unconditional literary talent M. Kostin. His disregard for the events of the Khotyn War of 1621 by a number of Ukrainian historians shows a reluctance to consider the event comprehensively, using all sources. Moreover, we see a focus on showing only one fragment of this historical event, the participation of the Ukrainian side in it. The language barrier to the use of the Chronicle is no more a problem than a political motive.
Higher State Educational Establishment of Ukraine Bukovinian State Medical University
Title: Khotyn battle 1621. Іgnored source in ukrainian historiography
Description:
The article offers a historiographical consideration of the description of the Khotyn battle 1621with an emphasis on the historical value of M.
Kostin's “Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” in the coverage of theevent.
The relevance of the study is dictated by the 400th anniversary of the battle.
The purpose of the study is to clarify the historical significance of thechronicle in revealing the theme of the Battle of Khotyn in 1621.
Methodology describes the work of M.
Kostin, its source base, comparison with other historical sources, review of its use.
Conclusions.
“Chronicle of the Land of Moldova” by Myron Kostin, being the only source for studying the history of Moldova in the early and mid seventeenth century.
at the same time it is a true description of the events of the Khotyn War (1620–1621).
Although the chronicler is not a contemporary of the events, his account of the Battle of Khotyn is based on serious Polish sources of the relevant era, oral information from contemporaries of the fighting, the traditions of the princely family of Movileshty, and so on.
The work is positively characterized by a deep and detailed description of events, impartiality, clear analysis of military operations of a participant in many battles, education of the author and his broad outlook, which allowed him to understand the causal links of actions, actions of the parties, unconditional literary talent M.
Kostin.
His disregard for the events of the Khotyn War of 1621 by a number of Ukrainian historians shows a reluctance to consider the event comprehensively, using all sources.
Moreover, we see a focus on showing only one fragment of this historical event, the participation of the Ukrainian side in it.
The language barrier to the use of the Chronicle is no more a problem than a political motive.
Related Results
The Polish-Turkish war of 1620–1621: Myths and istorical reality
The Polish-Turkish war of 1620–1621: Myths and istorical reality
The subject of the investigation is created by historiography, prospects of the Polish-Turkish war in its diversity of existing concepts; the major event in it turns out to be the ...
Serhii Tymoshenko: Ukrainian Architect and Diplomat
Serhii Tymoshenko: Ukrainian Architect and Diplomat
This research is focused on the life and legacy of Serhii Tymoshenko (1881–1950), Ukrainian political emigrant, political activist, statesman, and a member of the Ukrainian nationa...
IVAN KRYPIAKEVYCH AND THE POLITICAL EMIGRANTS OF NADDNIPRIANSHCHYNA: RELATIONS AND COOPERATION (1910 – 1930)
IVAN KRYPIAKEVYCH AND THE POLITICAL EMIGRANTS OF NADDNIPRIANSHCHYNA: RELATIONS AND COOPERATION (1910 – 1930)
The study deals with Ivan Krypiakevych's relations with political emigrants of Naddniprianshchyna during the Ukrainian people's struggle for the state and national-cultural rights....
Ethnomusicology of Ukraine at the Turn of XX–XXI Centuries (1991–2022): Science, Publications, Conferences
Ethnomusicology of Ukraine at the Turn of XX–XXI Centuries (1991–2022): Science, Publications, Conferences
The long-awaited times of Independence opened wide opportunities for Ukrainian ethnomusicologists. In the last issue of Problems of Ethnomusicology”, we began to review the achieve...
Events in Ukraine 1914–1922 their importance and historical background (Part 4)
Events in Ukraine 1914–1922 their importance and historical background (Part 4)
The editorial board continues to publish the most important documents that characterize the state and progress of the Ukrainian national liberation movement, the attitude of other ...
TRANSLATION AS A MEAN FOR INTERCULTURAL COMMUNICATION: THE LATEST LITERARY TRANSLATIONS FROM UKRAINIAN TO ROMANIAN
TRANSLATION AS A MEAN FOR INTERCULTURAL COMMUNICATION: THE LATEST LITERARY TRANSLATIONS FROM UKRAINIAN TO ROMANIAN
The purpose of this article is to present literary translations from Ukrainian to Romanian in the context of Romanian-Ukrainian intercultural relations. The specificity of translat...
UKRAINIAN-POLISH INTELLECTUAL CONNECTIONS: THE CHALLENGES OF HISTORY
UKRAINIAN-POLISH INTELLECTUAL CONNECTIONS: THE CHALLENGES OF HISTORY
The article examines the characteristics and particularities of Ukrainian-Polish intellectual and scientific exchanges from the late 19th to the early 21st centuries. It reveals th...
LANGUAGE PORTRAIT OF KYIV IN PERCEPTION
BY UKRAINIAN AND FOREIGN STUDENTS (2018-2022)
LANGUAGE PORTRAIT OF KYIV IN PERCEPTION
BY UKRAINIAN AND FOREIGN STUDENTS (2018-2022)
The article analyzes the results of language observation and surveys of Ukrainian and foreign students of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, conducted in 2018, 2019, 202...

