Evaluation of TOPSIS Algorithm for Multi-Criteria Handover in LEO Satellite Networks: A Sensitivity Analysis

The Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) is widely recognized as an effective multi-criteria decision-making algorithm for handover management in terrestrial cellular networks, especially in scenarios involving dynamic and multi-faceted criteria. While TOPSIS is widely adopted in terrestrial cellular networks for handover management, its application in satellite networks, particularly in Low Earth Orbit (LEO) constellations, remains limited and underexplored. In this work, the performance of three TOPSIS algorithms is evaluated for handover management in LEO satellite networks, where efficient handover management is crucial due to rapid changes in satellite positions and network conditions. Sensitivity analysis is conducted on Standard Deviation TOPSIS (SD-TOPSIS), Entropy-TOPSIS, and Importance-TOPSIS in the context of LEO satellite networks, assessing their responsiveness to small variations in key performance metrics such as upload speed, download speed, ping, and packet loss. This study uses real-world data from “Starlink-on-the-road-Dataset”. Results show that SD-TOPSIS effectively optimizes handover management in dynamic LEO satellite networks thanks to its lower standard deviation scores and reduced score variation rate, thus demonstrating superior stability and lower sensitivity to small variations in performance metrics values compared to both Entropy-TOPSIS and Importance-TOPSIS. This ensures more consistent decision-making, avoidance of unnecessary handovers, and enhanced robustness in rapidly-changing network conditions, making it particularly suitable for real-time services that require stable, low-latency, and reliable connectivity.