Javascript must be enabled to continue!
review of the criticisms against Prophet Muhammad’s marriage with Zaynab Bint Jahsh
View through CrossRef
Since the 7th century, we have had criticisms of Prophet Mohammed for his preaching of monotheism by his non-Muslim Arab contemporaries and his discussions on Jewish Faith by Jewish Arabs. During the middle ages, various western and Byzantine Christian thinkers described the Middle East as a hotbed of sexuality and Prophet Muhammad‟s marriage came to be a focal point of criticism in biographical writings. Western critics such as William Montgomery Watt, Dermenghem, Washington Irving, Lammens, William Muir and Karen Armstrong considered Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) to be lustful in his marriage to his wives.His marriage with Zaynab bint Jahsh, more than others, attracted bitterer criticism. Unfortunately, the early Arabic sources relied upon by critics lack scientific. It is against this assertion that this paper re-examined existing literature on the issue and identified the relevance of the marriage to the contemporary time using a combination of historical and exegetical research methods. Historical method is necessary in this work because the author researched into works on biography to study the view of biographers on the personalities discussed. Exegetical works on the Qur‟an are also consulted to navigate the views of exegetes on the verses that relate to the subject matter. The aim of this work is to probe the authenticity of sources relied upon by critics and to relate the lessons in the marriage to the contemporary time. Findings show that the criticism of Prophet Muhammad‟s marriage to Zainab lacks objectivity and so requires a review for the sake of moral justice.
Title: review of the criticisms against Prophet Muhammad’s marriage with Zaynab Bint Jahsh
Description:
Since the 7th century, we have had criticisms of Prophet Mohammed for his preaching of monotheism by his non-Muslim Arab contemporaries and his discussions on Jewish Faith by Jewish Arabs.
During the middle ages, various western and Byzantine Christian thinkers described the Middle East as a hotbed of sexuality and Prophet Muhammad‟s marriage came to be a focal point of criticism in biographical writings.
Western critics such as William Montgomery Watt, Dermenghem, Washington Irving, Lammens, William Muir and Karen Armstrong considered Prophet Muhammad (S.
A.
W.
) to be lustful in his marriage to his wives.
His marriage with Zaynab bint Jahsh, more than others, attracted bitterer criticism.
Unfortunately, the early Arabic sources relied upon by critics lack scientific.
It is against this assertion that this paper re-examined existing literature on the issue and identified the relevance of the marriage to the contemporary time using a combination of historical and exegetical research methods.
Historical method is necessary in this work because the author researched into works on biography to study the view of biographers on the personalities discussed.
Exegetical works on the Qur‟an are also consulted to navigate the views of exegetes on the verses that relate to the subject matter.
The aim of this work is to probe the authenticity of sources relied upon by critics and to relate the lessons in the marriage to the contemporary time.
Findings show that the criticism of Prophet Muhammad‟s marriage to Zainab lacks objectivity and so requires a review for the sake of moral justice.
Related Results
Kesempurnaan Akhlak Dan Pribadi Nabi Muhammad Rasulullah Sallallahu’alaihi Wasallam
Kesempurnaan Akhlak Dan Pribadi Nabi Muhammad Rasulullah Sallallahu’alaihi Wasallam
The Prophet Muhammad was a complete human figure in terms of his humanity and spirituality. The Islamic morals of the Prophet Muhammad are important to practice because they can co...
AL-QUR’AN: THE ONLY DIVINE GUIDANCE IN PRISTINE FORM
AL-QUR’AN: THE ONLY DIVINE GUIDANCE IN PRISTINE FORM
Al-Qur’an is the Final divine revelation sent down to the Final Messenger of God, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Allah SWT is the creator of all humankind, Jinns, and all creatures...
The Historical Debate Over The Prophet's Marriage With Zainab Binti Jaĥsyi
The Historical Debate Over The Prophet's Marriage With Zainab Binti Jaĥsyi
One of the Prophet's life histories that has become the subject of scholarly study is his marriage to Zainab bint Jaĥsyi. Zainab bint Jaĥsyi is the wife of Zaid bin Ĥāritsah who ha...
Amici Curiae Brief of Robert P. George, Sherif Girgis, and Ryan T. Anderson in Support of Hollingsworth and Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group Addressing the Merits and Supporting Reversal
Amici Curiae Brief of Robert P. George, Sherif Girgis, and Ryan T. Anderson in Support of Hollingsworth and Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group Addressing the Merits and Supporting Reversal
At stake in these cases is not who is and is not eligible to marry but what marriage is. Today’s debates offer rival answers to that question, two substantive marriage definitions....
Sejarah dan Strategi Nabi Muhammad.SAW di Mekah
Sejarah dan Strategi Nabi Muhammad.SAW di Mekah
Writing about the history of the Prophet Muhammad's Da'wah in Mecca aims to analyze how the propaganda strategy carried out by the Prophet Muhammad in spreading Islam in Mecca. The...
Underage marriage in Islamic law and Yemeni law
Underage marriage in Islamic law and Yemeni law
This research aims to explain the marriage of minors and to know the point of view of Islamic law and Yemeni law on this marriage, as well as to know its causes and effects. This o...
Child Marriage in South Asian Countries
Child Marriage in South Asian Countries
Mature age is considered the most suitable age for marriage in the world but there is no exact age to enter marriage for a girl in the world, and it differs from country to country...
Legal Protection Against Children of Consanguineous Marriages
Legal Protection Against Children of Consanguineous Marriages
A secret marriage is considered invalid by the state, therefore, children born from this marriage are considered as children born out of wedlock. This is different from the religio...

