Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Psychoanalytic reality of prose
View through CrossRef
Scientific methods of a particular field of knowledge can not be freely applied to a different field without any adjustments or reservations. Openness to a different approach is detrimental here. According to Nothrop Frye, psychonalysis in literature tends to 'blur the lines between methods' (Frye 1979: 383) thus increasing openness. Therefore, the anxiety that exists between the theory of psychonalysis and the practice of psychoanalytic therapy will follow the application of psychoanalysis to other scientific fields. Solid grasp of the theory of psychoanalysis is incomplete without understanding its practical implementation in the domain of pain as its priviledged source of truth. Even Jacques Lacan emphasized this by distinguishing between understanding and knowing Jacques Derrida's psychoanalysis. The interdisciplinary activity, valued today as an important aspect of research, cannot be accomplished by simple confrontations between various specialized branches of knowledge. According to Roland Barthes, interdisciplinary work is not a peaceful operation: it begins effectively when the solidarity of the old disciplines breaks down to the benefit of a new object and a new language, neither of which is in the domain of those branches of knowledge that one calmly sought to confront (Barthes 1986b:181). Mirjana Lončar Vujnović proposes, following Barthes logic, to substitute the term psychoanalysis with the term 'experimental mysticism' (Lončar Vujnović 2014: 46). Her proposition has no semantic justification (and not only for its failed attempt at oxymoron) let alone scientific. The exploration of the unconscious psyche which is unknown and irrational - designated under certain circumstances as the exploration of the mystical as a hidden, secret part of a man's soul - was scrutinized in psychoanalysis by employing a rigorous scientific method in reverence to the methods of the natural sciences. Furthermore, due to the nomothetic-ideographic and discursive nature of psyche, psychoanalysis also included the hermeneutic method pertinent to the research of various symptoms and sintomas, as well asgenesis and telos.
Centre for Evaluation in Education and Science (CEON/CEES)
Title: Psychoanalytic reality of prose
Description:
Scientific methods of a particular field of knowledge can not be freely applied to a different field without any adjustments or reservations.
Openness to a different approach is detrimental here.
According to Nothrop Frye, psychonalysis in literature tends to 'blur the lines between methods' (Frye 1979: 383) thus increasing openness.
Therefore, the anxiety that exists between the theory of psychonalysis and the practice of psychoanalytic therapy will follow the application of psychoanalysis to other scientific fields.
Solid grasp of the theory of psychoanalysis is incomplete without understanding its practical implementation in the domain of pain as its priviledged source of truth.
Even Jacques Lacan emphasized this by distinguishing between understanding and knowing Jacques Derrida's psychoanalysis.
The interdisciplinary activity, valued today as an important aspect of research, cannot be accomplished by simple confrontations between various specialized branches of knowledge.
According to Roland Barthes, interdisciplinary work is not a peaceful operation: it begins effectively when the solidarity of the old disciplines breaks down to the benefit of a new object and a new language, neither of which is in the domain of those branches of knowledge that one calmly sought to confront (Barthes 1986b:181).
Mirjana Lončar Vujnović proposes, following Barthes logic, to substitute the term psychoanalysis with the term 'experimental mysticism' (Lončar Vujnović 2014: 46).
Her proposition has no semantic justification (and not only for its failed attempt at oxymoron) let alone scientific.
The exploration of the unconscious psyche which is unknown and irrational - designated under certain circumstances as the exploration of the mystical as a hidden, secret part of a man's soul - was scrutinized in psychoanalysis by employing a rigorous scientific method in reverence to the methods of the natural sciences.
Furthermore, due to the nomothetic-ideographic and discursive nature of psyche, psychoanalysis also included the hermeneutic method pertinent to the research of various symptoms and sintomas, as well asgenesis and telos.
Related Results
Psychoanalysis
Psychoanalysis
Grounded in the belief that individual human development and personality are strongly influenced by, if not determined by, early life events, childhood has been a central construct...
Psychoanalytic Theory
Psychoanalytic Theory
Psychoanalytic readings of narrative fiction advance the idea that the novel's most important feature is its depiction of human subjectivity. The psychoanalysts who have most influ...
Comparing cybersickness in virtual reality and mixed reality head-mounted displays
Comparing cybersickness in virtual reality and mixed reality head-mounted displays
Introduction: Defence Research and Development Canada is developing guidance on the use of Mixed Reality head-mounted displays for naval operations in the Royal Canadian Navy. Virt...
Shaping Reality: An Interplay of Freudian and Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Shaping Reality: An Interplay of Freudian and Lacanian Psychoanalysis
This paper delves into the shaping of reality in Freudian and Lacanian psychoanalysis with references to D. W. Winnicott and Slavoj Žižek’s works. It articulates how psychoanalytic...
Augmented Reality for Smoking Cessation: Development and Usability Study (Preprint)
Augmented Reality for Smoking Cessation: Development and Usability Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND
The recent widespread availability of augmented reality via smartphone offers an opportunity to translate cue exposure therapy for smoking cessat...
The Correspondence of Edward Glover and Lawrence S. Kubie
The Correspondence of Edward Glover and Lawrence S. Kubie
Lawrence S. Kubie, one of psychoanalysis's distinguished thinkers, had gone from America to be analyzed in London by Edward Glover in 1928-1930. Glover, in spite of all his achieve...
Factors That Influence Young Adults’ Preferences for Virtual Reality Exergames in a Weight Control Setting: Qualitative Study (Preprint)
Factors That Influence Young Adults’ Preferences for Virtual Reality Exergames in a Weight Control Setting: Qualitative Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND
Obesity could compromise people’s health and elevate the risk of numerous severe chronic conditions and premature mortality. Young adults are at ...

