Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Dirty Pictures: John Ruskin, Modern Painters, and the Victorian Sanitation of Fine Art
View through CrossRef
WHILE MY PROJECT IS BROADLY INTERESTED in the interdisciplinary work of what I will call sanitary art in nineteenth-century Britain, this essay is primarily concerned with a watershed moment in the production of that interdisciplinarity. In 1842, Edwin Chadwick published his Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population; the following year, John Ruskin published the first volume of Modern Painters. Incomparable in subject, genre, and style, these texts would nonetheless participate in the same cultural project, producing between them a discourse of ''dirty'' art that challenged and eventually redefined nineteenth-century aesthetic standards. This essay argues that Ruskin employed the discourse and ideological necessity of sanitary reform from his earliest work, enforcing through his celebration of modern painters an aesthetic preference for the bright, clean colors of J.M.W. Turner and the Pre-Raphaelites over the pestilential tones and dark obscurity of the Renaissance Old Masters. Moreover, Ruskin's sophisticated preferences were circulated and popularized by a cultural event more generally accessible than Modern Painters. Isolating a mid-Victorian moment when the agitation for urban cleanliness began to dominate a variety of social discourses, this essay will also argue that Chadwick's powerful sanitary idea was channeled through a public controversy in the mid-forties about the aesthetic status of ''picture cleaning'' in the National Gallery at Trafalgar Square. When the dust from this debate finally settled, it was swept away along with the dirty aesthetic theories that had accumulated over previous centuries. Left in its place was the thesis of Modern Painters, and a new standard of aesthetic hygiene for Victorian art.
Title: Dirty Pictures: John Ruskin, Modern Painters, and the Victorian Sanitation of Fine Art
Description:
WHILE MY PROJECT IS BROADLY INTERESTED in the interdisciplinary work of what I will call sanitary art in nineteenth-century Britain, this essay is primarily concerned with a watershed moment in the production of that interdisciplinarity.
In 1842, Edwin Chadwick published his Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population; the following year, John Ruskin published the first volume of Modern Painters.
Incomparable in subject, genre, and style, these texts would nonetheless participate in the same cultural project, producing between them a discourse of ''dirty'' art that challenged and eventually redefined nineteenth-century aesthetic standards.
This essay argues that Ruskin employed the discourse and ideological necessity of sanitary reform from his earliest work, enforcing through his celebration of modern painters an aesthetic preference for the bright, clean colors of J.
M.
W.
Turner and the Pre-Raphaelites over the pestilential tones and dark obscurity of the Renaissance Old Masters.
Moreover, Ruskin's sophisticated preferences were circulated and popularized by a cultural event more generally accessible than Modern Painters.
Isolating a mid-Victorian moment when the agitation for urban cleanliness began to dominate a variety of social discourses, this essay will also argue that Chadwick's powerful sanitary idea was channeled through a public controversy in the mid-forties about the aesthetic status of ''picture cleaning'' in the National Gallery at Trafalgar Square.
When the dust from this debate finally settled, it was swept away along with the dirty aesthetic theories that had accumulated over previous centuries.
Left in its place was the thesis of Modern Painters, and a new standard of aesthetic hygiene for Victorian art.
Related Results
South American Dirty Wars
South American Dirty Wars
The so-called South American “dirty wars” refer to clandestine practices of state terror undertaken in the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s by military governments in Brazil and the Southern...
Visual Culture
Visual Culture
Encompassing such diverse disciplines and fields as fine and applied arts, art, literature, science, photography, theater, and early cinema, Victorian visual culture is far ranging...
The Late-Victorian ‘New Man’ and the Neo-Victorian ‘Neo-Man’
The Late-Victorian ‘New Man’ and the Neo-Victorian ‘Neo-Man’
The New Man was a crucial topic of discussion and a continual preoccupation in late-Victorian feminist writing, precisely because he was more often a wished-for presence than an ac...
Victorian Values
Victorian Values
The contested values associated with the term ‘Victorian’ call for fresh and informed consideration in the light of far-reaching changes brought about by the global economic downtu...
Behind closed doors: Pornographic uses of the Victorian
Behind closed doors: Pornographic uses of the Victorian
This essay argues that the frequency and consistency of Victorian-set or Victorian-influenced pornographic films highlight hardcore’s reliance on class- and gender-related spatial ...
Casual Racism in Victorian Literature
Casual Racism in Victorian Literature
The first time a casually racist reference crops up in the Victorian texts I teach, I tell my students that the presence of slurs and stereotypes in Victorian literature reflects t...
Late-Victorian Decadent Song Literature
Late-Victorian Decadent Song Literature
This article considers the Victorian and Edwardian vogue for setting late-Victorian decadent poetry to music. It examines the particular appeal of Ernest Dowson's and Arthur Symons...
Recent Results
Marcus Antonius Kappus : a reevaluation
Marcus Antonius Kappus : a reevaluation
In the first part of my study I investigate the background in which Marcus Kappus had lived in his youth, before his departure for America. I consider that analysis of these early ...
Giovanni di Paolo, The Creation of the World and the Expulsion from Paradise (1445)
Giovanni di Paolo, The Creation of the World and the Expulsion from Paradise (1445)
Tempera and gold on wood, 18 1/4 × 20 1/2 in...
Renormalization group approach to 1D cellular automata with large updating neighborhoods
Renormalization group approach to 1D cellular automata with large updating neighborhoods
We study self‐similarity in one‐dimensional probabilistic cellular automata (PCA) by applying a real‐space renormalization technique to PCA with increasingly large updating neighbo...
Theodore Syncellus and the 626 Siege of Constantinople
Theodore Syncellus and the 626 Siege of Constantinople
The homily on the Avar siege of Constantinople in 626 attributed to Theodore Syncellus shares numerous linguistic features both with Theodore’s homily of 623 on the Virgin’s Robe a...