Javascript must be enabled to continue!
PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS OF CLASSIFYING ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES IN THE CONTEXT OF THE REFORM OF THE CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
View through CrossRef
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the problems and prospects of classifying administrative offenses in the context of the ongoing reform of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offenses (CоАП RK). The research focuses on a critical review of a legislative novelty – the draft of Article 25-1 of the CоАП RK, which introduces a three-level gradation of offenses by severity (minor, significant, and gross). The authors identify and analyze in detail the systemic contradictions of the proposed model. These include: a conceptual inconsistency between the General and Special Parts of the Code, leading to homogeneous acts being classified into different severity categories; and an excessive dependence of qualification on the status of the subject (individual, business entity), which calls into question the adherence to the principle of equality before the law. The problem of the imperfect classification methodology, which does not allow for the correct inclusion of offenses with penalties in the form of fines calculated as a percentage or whose amounts exceed the established limits, is particularly emphasized. As an alternative, the authors substantiate the necessity of transitioning to a socially oriented and flexible system of administrative penalties that considers not only formal characteristics but also the property status of the offender, the form of guilt, the severity of the consequences, and the real public danger of the act. In conclusion, a set of theoretical and practical measures for improving the gradation is formulated, including the development of clear criteria, the creation of a scientific and practical toolkit for analyzing the elements of offenses in the CоАП RK, and ensuring the proportionality of administrative responsibility to strengthen trust in the legal system.
Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Title: PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS OF CLASSIFYING ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES IN THE CONTEXT OF THE REFORM OF THE CODE OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
Description:
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the problems and prospects of classifying administrative offenses in the context of the ongoing reform of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offenses (CоАП RK).
The research focuses on a critical review of a legislative novelty – the draft of Article 25-1 of the CоАП RK, which introduces a three-level gradation of offenses by severity (minor, significant, and gross).
The authors identify and analyze in detail the systemic contradictions of the proposed model.
These include: a conceptual inconsistency between the General and Special Parts of the Code, leading to homogeneous acts being classified into different severity categories; and an excessive dependence of qualification on the status of the subject (individual, business entity), which calls into question the adherence to the principle of equality before the law.
The problem of the imperfect classification methodology, which does not allow for the correct inclusion of offenses with penalties in the form of fines calculated as a percentage or whose amounts exceed the established limits, is particularly emphasized.
As an alternative, the authors substantiate the necessity of transitioning to a socially oriented and flexible system of administrative penalties that considers not only formal characteristics but also the property status of the offender, the form of guilt, the severity of the consequences, and the real public danger of the act.
In conclusion, a set of theoretical and practical measures for improving the gradation is formulated, including the development of clear criteria, the creation of a scientific and practical toolkit for analyzing the elements of offenses in the CоАП RK, and ensuring the proportionality of administrative responsibility to strengthen trust in the legal system.
Related Results
African Annals of Medicine reviewers in 2024
African Annals of Medicine reviewers in 2024
Le comité éditorial des Annales Africaines de Médecine tient à remercier les lecteurs qui ont analysé les manuscrits soumis pour publication au cours de l’année 2024 et ont ainsi d...
Some issues of administrative offenses
Some issues of administrative offenses
The article examines the study of the content and structure of administrative offenses (torts) during martial law, specifies their theoretical and practical basis.
A detailed...
SPECIALIZED ADMINISTRATIVE COURTS REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
SPECIALIZED ADMINISTRATIVE COURTS REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
The paper describes the historical path of formation and formation of the administrative courts of the Republic of Kazakhstan as specialized. The directions of development of speci...
Raptors and Wind Energy in Kazakhstan: What are the Prospects for Eagles?
Raptors and Wind Energy in Kazakhstan: What are the Prospects for Eagles?
Wind energy is one of the most affordable energy sources worldwide and represents one of the most climate and environmentally friendly options for energy production. However, wind ...
Joint Beamforming and Aerial IRS Positioning Design for IRS-assisted MISO System with Multiple Access Points
Joint Beamforming and Aerial IRS Positioning Design for IRS-assisted MISO System with Multiple Access Points
<p><code>Intelligent reflecting surface (IRS) is a promising concept for </code><code><u>6G</u></code><code> wireless communications...
Joint Beamforming and Aerial IRS Positioning Design for IRS-assisted MISO System with Multiple Access Points
Joint Beamforming and Aerial IRS Positioning Design for IRS-assisted MISO System with Multiple Access Points
<p><code>Intelligent reflecting surface (IRS) is a promising concept for </code><code><u>6G</u></code><code> wireless communications...
LEGAL REGULATION OF CONFESSIONAL RELATIONS IN THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
LEGAL REGULATION OF CONFESSIONAL RELATIONS IN THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
Relations between the state and religious organizations in human history play a significant role. Since religion and law are powerful regulators of human behavior, and religious or...
Сoncept, Content and Types of Procedures for Pre-Court Settlement of Administrative and Legal Disputes
Сoncept, Content and Types of Procedures for Pre-Court Settlement of Administrative and Legal Disputes
The topicality of the topic is due to the study of various forms and procedures of pre-trial settlement of administrative-legal disputes as alternatives to the judicial procedure f...

