Javascript must be enabled to continue!
Compositional variations within the TRAPPIST-1 planets
View through CrossRef
Since stars and their planetary accretion disks are formed by the collapse of the same interstellar dust cloud, the composition of a star can be used as a first estimate for the upper limit of the composition of the accretion disk. However, the stellar composition of TRAPPIST-1 has not yet been determined. We therefore derive elemental abundances for the main planet-forming elements from the stellar metallicity using large-scale astronomical surveys (GALAH and Hypatia).  We then apply a stoichiometric model extended from Bitsch & Battistini (2020) to obtain a first-order estimate on the compositional variation of planetary building material depending on the local temperature within an accretion disk. In this approach, the gas within the accretion disk is assumed to have achieved the state of chemical equilibrium before condensation, with the complete set of molecules preexisting in the gas. Consequently, the relative abundance of molecules can be calculatedstochiometrically and based on their condensation temperature (Lodders 2003). We assume a fixed temperature profile within the accretion disk and do not consider planet migration to obtain a first prediction of compositional variability within the TRAPPIST-1 accretion disk. Our predicted composition of the planetary building blocks of the seven planets in the system is shown in Fig. 1. We obtain three different compositional clusters including dominantly dry (b,c,d), water-rich (e,f) and water- and ammonium-rich building blocks.  We then apply our interior-structure model (Noack et al. 2016) employing look-up tables created with Perple_X (Connolly 2009) for thermodynamic properties of the silicate mantles. We apply an Earth-like mantle iron number of 0.1 (i.e. a magnesium number of 0.9) for the silicate mantle, which leads to a predicted core-mass fraction of 25% for the three inner-most planets (Carone et al. in review). This core-mass fraction leads to planet radii matching the observed values from Agol et al. (2021) for all thre planets, which suggests, that our compositional model is able to correctly predict the planetary composition of the TRAPPIST-1 planets and that their composition was not strongly altered during accretion (by e.g. impact erosion).  For the outer planets of the system, the appearance of volatiles adds a degeneracy to our interior structure, since melting processes during planet accretion implies volatile losses. The final planetary composition is therefore expected to be considerably less volatile-rich than predicted here for the planetary building blocks. Assuming the same mantle-core composition as for the three inner-most planets, our model suggests that the outer planets should have a maximum water fraction below 20 wt-% to match their observed radii, which is in accordance with earlier studies, even though here we apply our TRAPPIST-1 adapted compositional model instead of an Earth-like mineralogy.  
Title: Compositional variations within the TRAPPIST-1 planets
Description:
Since stars and their planetary accretion disks are formed by the collapse of the same interstellar dust cloud, the composition of a star can be used as a first estimate for the upper limit of the composition of the accretion disk.
However, the stellar composition of TRAPPIST-1 has not yet been determined.
We therefore derive elemental abundances for the main planet-forming elements from the stellar metallicity using large-scale astronomical surveys (GALAH and Hypatia).
  We then apply a stoichiometric model extended from Bitsch & Battistini (2020) to obtain a first-order estimate on the compositional variation of planetary building material depending on the local temperature within an accretion disk.
In this approach, the gas within the accretion disk is assumed to have achieved the state of chemical equilibrium before condensation, with the complete set of molecules preexisting in the gas.
Consequently, the relative abundance of molecules can be calculatedstochiometrically and based on their condensation temperature (Lodders 2003).
 We assume a fixed temperature profile within the accretion disk and do not consider planet migration to obtain a first prediction of compositional variability within the TRAPPIST-1 accretion disk.
Our predicted composition of the planetary building blocks of the seven planets in the system is shown in Fig.
1.
We obtain three different compositional clusters including dominantly dry (b,c,d), water-rich (e,f) and water- and ammonium-rich building blocks.
  We then apply our interior-structure model (Noack et al.
2016) employing look-up tables created with Perple_X (Connolly 2009) for thermodynamic properties of the silicate mantles.
We apply an Earth-like mantle iron number of 0.
1 (i.
e.
a magnesium number of 0.
9) for the silicate mantle, which leads to a predicted core-mass fraction of 25% for the three inner-most planets (Carone et al.
in review).
This core-mass fraction leads to planet radii matching the observed values from Agol et al.
(2021) for all thre planets, which suggests, that our compositional model is able to correctly predict the planetary composition of the TRAPPIST-1 planets and that their composition was not strongly altered during accretion (by e.
g.
impact erosion).
  For the outer planets of the system, the appearance of volatiles adds a degeneracy to our interior structure, since melting processes during planet accretion implies volatile losses.
The final planetary composition is therefore expected to be considerably less volatile-rich than predicted here for the planetary building blocks.
Assuming the same mantle-core composition as for the three inner-most planets, our model suggests that the outer planets should have a maximum water fraction below 20 wt-% to match their observed radii, which is in accordance with earlier studies, even though here we apply our TRAPPIST-1 adapted compositional model instead of an Earth-like mineralogy.
  .
Related Results
Improving tidal interaction for compact N-body planetary system.
Improving tidal interaction for compact N-body planetary system.
Recent JWST observations of rocky planets, such as TRAPPIST-1, and the increasing number of rocky planets discovered orbiting close to their host star, strongly motivates the impro...
Interior dynamics of small-core and coreless exoplanets
Interior dynamics of small-core and coreless exoplanets
Since the first exoplanet detection in 1992, the study of exoplanets has received considerable attention. It is becoming apparent that the diversity of the general exoplanet popula...
TRAPPIST-1 d: A Case Study in Atmospheric Loss at the Inner Edge of the Habitable Zone
TRAPPIST-1 d: A Case Study in Atmospheric Loss at the Inner Edge of the Habitable Zone
The TRAPPIST-1 system, comprising seven Earth-sized planets orbiting an ultra-cool M8 dwarf, offers a unique laboratory for studying atmospheric retention on temperate rocky exopla...
Dynamics of giant planets in protoplanetary discs
Dynamics of giant planets in protoplanetary discs
New instruments such as the ALMA interferometer and SPHERE on VLT allowed to obtain a large number of high-resolution images of protoplanetary discs. In these images, substructures...
Improving tidal modeling for rocky worlds
Improving tidal modeling for rocky worlds
<p>The high number of discovered close-in planets motivates the improvement of tidal modeling.Among the five thousand exoplanets discovered up to now, half of them ha...
Constraining planet formation with atmospheric observations from the V1298 Tau planet system
Constraining planet formation with atmospheric observations from the V1298 Tau planet system
<p>Theories of planet formation like core accretion mechanism&#160; have been successful over the years in explaining the formation gas giant planets and even...
Outgassing on Stagnant-Lid Planets: Influence of Rheology
Outgassing on Stagnant-Lid Planets: Influence of Rheology
Outgassing from the interior is a key process influencing the evolution of the atmospheres of rocky planets. For planets with a stagnant lid tectonic mode, previous models have ind...
The evolutionary pathway of polluted proto-planets
The evolutionary pathway of polluted proto-planets
. Introduction:In the traditional core accretion scenario, a planet grows by the subsequent accretion of a solid core and a gaseous envelope [3]. However, the accretion of these so...


