Javascript must be enabled to continue!
476 Manels and Gender Representation at Major Urological Surgery Conferences
View through CrossRef
Abstract
Aim
Females are disproportionately under-represented in surgery despite the upward trend in women entering the medical profession (Rakestraw et al., 2022). Visibility of female surgeons at academic meetings gives a cross-sectional view of inclusion within the field. We aimed to quantify the proportion of female faculty and prevalence of all-male panels (“manels”) at major international urological surgery meetings.
Method
We retrospectively analysed annual meetings organised by major urological surgery associations or societies between January 2016 and December 2021. Demographic and academic metrics, including H-index, number of publications, and number of citations were collected for each invited lecturer, panellist and chair/moderator.
Results
Twenty-two conferences held by four urological surgery organisations were identified, including 1871 sessions delivered by 5427 speakers. On average across all speakers, 12.0% (n = 643) were female. Of the 838 panel sessions, 584 (69.7%) were manels. Percentage of manels was statistically significant between online and in-person conferences (online 64.6% versus in-person 75.1%; p<0.05). There was a statistically significant difference in the proportion of manels over time (79.4% in 2016 versus 28.8% in 2021; p<0.05). Male invited lecturers had significantly higher H-index than female invited lecturers (male 32 versus female 17; p<0.05).
Conclusions
Despite the encouraging findings that manels are becoming less prevalent in major urological surgery meetings, manels continue to comprise the majority, whilst female speaker representation remains poor. This study hopes to highlight the need for greater gender diversity and female representation in urology.
Oxford University Press (OUP)
Title: 476 Manels and Gender Representation at Major Urological Surgery Conferences
Description:
Abstract
Aim
Females are disproportionately under-represented in surgery despite the upward trend in women entering the medical profession (Rakestraw et al.
, 2022).
Visibility of female surgeons at academic meetings gives a cross-sectional view of inclusion within the field.
We aimed to quantify the proportion of female faculty and prevalence of all-male panels (“manels”) at major international urological surgery meetings.
Method
We retrospectively analysed annual meetings organised by major urological surgery associations or societies between January 2016 and December 2021.
Demographic and academic metrics, including H-index, number of publications, and number of citations were collected for each invited lecturer, panellist and chair/moderator.
Results
Twenty-two conferences held by four urological surgery organisations were identified, including 1871 sessions delivered by 5427 speakers.
On average across all speakers, 12.
0% (n = 643) were female.
Of the 838 panel sessions, 584 (69.
7%) were manels.
Percentage of manels was statistically significant between online and in-person conferences (online 64.
6% versus in-person 75.
1%; p<0.
05).
There was a statistically significant difference in the proportion of manels over time (79.
4% in 2016 versus 28.
8% in 2021; p<0.
05).
Male invited lecturers had significantly higher H-index than female invited lecturers (male 32 versus female 17; p<0.
05).
Conclusions
Despite the encouraging findings that manels are becoming less prevalent in major urological surgery meetings, manels continue to comprise the majority, whilst female speaker representation remains poor.
This study hopes to highlight the need for greater gender diversity and female representation in urology.
Related Results
1299 MANELS: A Retrospective, Multi-National, Longitudinal Study for Quantitative Analysis of Gender Distribution of Speakers at Paediatrics Surgery Conferences
1299 MANELS: A Retrospective, Multi-National, Longitudinal Study for Quantitative Analysis of Gender Distribution of Speakers at Paediatrics Surgery Conferences
Abstract
Aim
Academic representation of women at conferences is vital for improving underrepresentation in surgery, despite the ...
1300 Gender Distribution of Invited Speakers at Major Cardiothoracic Surgery Conferences: A Retrospective Open Cohort Study
1300 Gender Distribution of Invited Speakers at Major Cardiothoracic Surgery Conferences: A Retrospective Open Cohort Study
Abstract
Aim
Females are under-represented in surgery despite the representation of female surgeons at academic meetings being a...
Cerebrospinal Fluid Shunt Complications after Urological Procedures in Children with Myelodysplasia
Cerebrospinal Fluid Shunt Complications after Urological Procedures in Children with Myelodysplasia
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE
Invasive urological procedures, commonly performed on patients with myelodysplasia, may contribute to the occ...
Urological Emergencies in a Nigerian Teaching Hospital
Urological Emergencies in a Nigerian Teaching Hospital
Background:
Urological emergencies constitute a significant part of emergency presentations in various referral centers. Data on the prevalence of these emergencies in ...
Gender identity development in autistic individuals: An interview study
Gender identity development in autistic individuals: An interview study
Autistic individuals report more gender-related questions and gender incongruence compared to non-autistic peers. However, research on gender identity in autistic individuals lacks...
Women in Australian Politics: Maintaining the Rage against the Political Machine
Women in Australian Politics: Maintaining the Rage against the Political Machine
Women in federal politics are under-represented today and always have been. At no time in the history of the federal parliament have women achieved equal representation with men. T...
A Spectrum of Non-Traumatic Urological Emergencies in a Single Center in Tunisia: Ten Years Experience.
A Spectrum of Non-Traumatic Urological Emergencies in a Single Center in Tunisia: Ten Years Experience.
Abstract
Background:Emergency department consultations are the most important in any hospital. Although nontraumatic urological emergencies are a common reason for hospital...
Chronic Kidney Disease and Urological Implications: The interplay between Chronic Kidney Disease and urological conditions
Chronic Kidney Disease and Urological Implications: The interplay between Chronic Kidney Disease and urological conditions
Introduction
People of all ages and cultures are affected by the diabetes crisis. The disease primarily affects the kidneys, heart, and nervous system and is categorised as type 1...

