Circular Animal Protein Hydrolysates: A Comparative Approach of Functional Properties

The growing demand for nutraceuticals has driven interest in upcycling low-value proteins from processed animal by-products and insect larvae into functional protein hydrolysates. This study evaluated five such hydrolysates in comparison to a high-value commercial reference (CPSP90), assessing the proximate composition, amino acid profile, molecular weight distribution, antioxidant activity, and bacterial growth dynamics. Results revealed a wide variability in the composition and bioactivity, driven by the raw material and processing conditions. All hydrolysates displayed a medium to high crude protein content (55.1–89.5% DM), with SHARK being the most protein-rich. SHARK and SWINE hydrolysates were particularly rich in collagenic amino acids, while FISH and CPSP90 contained higher levels of essential amino acids. FISH and INSECT demonstrated the strongest antioxidant activity, with INSECT also showing the highest protein solubility. INSECT and SWINE further displayed mild, selective antibacterial effects, indicating a potential for disease mitigation. Conversely, SHARK and FISH supported opportunistic bacteria growth, suggesting a potential use as nitrogen sources in microbial media. These findings highlight the nutritional and functional versatility of animal-derived protein hydrolysates and support their integration into sustainable feed strategies within a circular bioeconomy.