Javascript must be enabled to continue!
On the Dating of the Seventh Issue of Mykola Lysenko’s “Collection of Uk- rainian Songs”
View through CrossRef
The last, seventh issue of “The Collection of Ukrainian Songs” by M. Lysenko
was published without a date, therefore in musicological literature two conjectural
dates are now mentioned: some give the year 1896, others the year 1911. None of
these controversies, separated by a time distance of a decade and a half, are supported
by references to indisputable documentary evidence and appear to be subjective as-
sumptions devoid of a factual basis, therefore one of them or even both may currently
not correspond to actual reality. With complete obviousness, the first, older date ap-
47
pears absolutely impossible in itself, since it clearly contradicts generally known his-
torical events, and it must disappear immediately and forever from the creative bio-
graphy of the outstanding composer and ethnomusicologist, and at the same time be
entirely erased from the annals of the history of Ukrainian music. By contrast, the
other date, the year 1911, although it too is everywhere given without any substantia-
tion, without any reference to specific sources, nevertheless must be recognized as
entirely authentic. It is one hundred percent verified by a state bibliographic docu-
ment, the registration in the Book Chronicle of the Main Administration for Press
Affairs. At that point, the problem of dating this seventh issue can be considered re-
solved. This was indeed the last lifetime publication of M. Lysenko, his folkloristic
swan song, which he managed to make public one year before his departure from this
world and in such a miraculous manner as if framed the scientific and creative path he
had traveled, begun more than forty years earlier, in 1868, with the first issue of his
epoch-making “Collection of Ukrainian Songs”. As for the year 1896, it most likely
indicates not the date of publication of the seventh issue, but the time of its creation,
well known to the composer’s close circle. Moreover, at that very time, in the middle
of the 19th century, he collaborated intensively with his correspondent S. Vengrzhe-
novskyi, who actually provided his materials not only for the seventh issue but also
for another collection of songs from Podillia, which remained unprocessed due to the
censorship ban on its publication.
Keywords: problems of dating undated sources, Mykola Lysenko, seventh issue
of the “Collection of Ukrainian Songs”, S. Vengrzhenovskyi, manuscript of Mykola
Lysenko’s collection “Songs from Podillia”.
Title: On the Dating of the Seventh Issue of Mykola Lysenko’s “Collection of Uk- rainian Songs”
Description:
The last, seventh issue of “The Collection of Ukrainian Songs” by M.
Lysenko
was published without a date, therefore in musicological literature two conjectural
dates are now mentioned: some give the year 1896, others the year 1911.
None of
these controversies, separated by a time distance of a decade and a half, are supported
by references to indisputable documentary evidence and appear to be subjective as-
sumptions devoid of a factual basis, therefore one of them or even both may currently
not correspond to actual reality.
With complete obviousness, the first, older date ap-
47
pears absolutely impossible in itself, since it clearly contradicts generally known his-
torical events, and it must disappear immediately and forever from the creative bio-
graphy of the outstanding composer and ethnomusicologist, and at the same time be
entirely erased from the annals of the history of Ukrainian music.
By contrast, the
other date, the year 1911, although it too is everywhere given without any substantia-
tion, without any reference to specific sources, nevertheless must be recognized as
entirely authentic.
It is one hundred percent verified by a state bibliographic docu-
ment, the registration in the Book Chronicle of the Main Administration for Press
Affairs.
At that point, the problem of dating this seventh issue can be considered re-
solved.
This was indeed the last lifetime publication of M.
Lysenko, his folkloristic
swan song, which he managed to make public one year before his departure from this
world and in such a miraculous manner as if framed the scientific and creative path he
had traveled, begun more than forty years earlier, in 1868, with the first issue of his
epoch-making “Collection of Ukrainian Songs”.
As for the year 1896, it most likely
indicates not the date of publication of the seventh issue, but the time of its creation,
well known to the composer’s close circle.
Moreover, at that very time, in the middle
of the 19th century, he collaborated intensively with his correspondent S.
Vengrzhe-
novskyi, who actually provided his materials not only for the seventh issue but also
for another collection of songs from Podillia, which remained unprocessed due to the
censorship ban on its publication.
Keywords: problems of dating undated sources, Mykola Lysenko, seventh issue
of the “Collection of Ukrainian Songs”, S.
Vengrzhenovskyi, manuscript of Mykola
Lysenko’s collection “Songs from Podillia”.
Related Results
SYMBOLISM OF IMAGES IN THE OPERAS OF MYKOLA LYSENKO “TARAS BULBA” AND “NOKTURN”
SYMBOLISM OF IMAGES IN THE OPERAS OF MYKOLA LYSENKO “TARAS BULBA” AND “NOKTURN”
Artists of the early 21st century, unlike previous time intervals, are attracted to those stylistic trends that were characteristic of a century ago. Despite the non-symbolist mani...
The role of the Lysenko dynasty in the formation of the choral school in Ukraine (to the 80th anniversary of Vitaly Romanovich Lysenko)
The role of the Lysenko dynasty in the formation of the choral school in Ukraine (to the 80th anniversary of Vitaly Romanovich Lysenko)
The article investigates the sources of formation of conducting skills of Mykola Vitaliyovych Lysenko, and this is done not only in retrospect of the creative path of the individua...
A Collection of Loyal Songs: Songs as Spaces of Memory
A Collection of Loyal Songs: Songs as Spaces of Memory
In 1750, four years after the Battle of Culloden, Edinburgh printer Robert Fleming distributed the Jacobite songbook A Collection of Loyal Songs, Poems, &c. Jacobitism was, for...
Kuban Ukrainian-Cossack Wedding: Songs & Ceremonial, structural analysis
Kuban Ukrainian-Cossack Wedding: Songs & Ceremonial, structural analysis
In current article author presents traditional Kuban Ukrainian-Cossack wedding, on the ground of typological data, archived in 268 items, recorded in 46 settlements of historical C...
Utilization and Significance of the Pansori Inserted Songs
Utilization and Significance of the Pansori Inserted Songs
This study assumed that the insertion of songs or inserted songs during the formative period of Pansori played a significant role in establishing Pansori as epic poetry. To verify ...
Itinerant Musicians of Western Polissia: Mykola Muravets
Itinerant Musicians of Western Polissia: Mykola Muravets
The person and career of the outstanding traveling musician Mykola Muravets from Western Polissia were characterized in general terms on the basis of the newly acquired expedition ...
EXPERIENCE OF USE OF THE RADIOCARBON METHOD DATING OF EARLY SLAVIC SITES FROM UKRAINE (1970—1987)
EXPERIENCE OF USE OF THE RADIOCARBON METHOD DATING OF EARLY SLAVIC SITES FROM UKRAINE (1970—1987)
The introduction of radiocarbon dating method in USSR and Ukrainian archeology was much slower compared to world practice. Natural scientific methods of dating in archeology have f...

