Search engine for discovering works of Art, research articles, and books related to Art and Culture
ShareThis
Javascript must be enabled to continue!

Revisiting nonterminal hydrometeors: Refining instrument uncertainty

View through CrossRef
The fall velocities of rain and drizzle drops are often assumed to be a deterministic function of their size. These diameter-fall speed relationships are intrinsically assumed in the retrievals provided by some commercial rain measurement instruments (e.g. the Joss-Waldvogel Disdrometer (Distromet), Micro Rain Radar (METEK), and 1-Dimensional Video Disdrometer (Joanneum Research)).Some disdrometers are capable of independently measuring droplet size and fall-speed and provide evidence that not all drops adhere to the assumed size/fall-speed relationship. The ubiquity and magnitude of these deviations are still an area of some debate; clear identification of drizzle and rain drops falling at speeds different than their expected terminal fall velocities is muddied by conservative estimates of disdrometer resolution and performance. For a long time the bulk of observed non-terminal drop fall speeds were assumed to be instrumental artifacts and, even now, most investigators conclude drops falling at non-terminal speeds do not have a large impact on rain measurement science.To date, uncertainties in disdrometer-derived drop sizes and fall speeds have usually been derived from the manufacturer estimates. Here, we improve on these estimates by using a field calibration source (the new ``Large Drop Generator'' from Mesa Photonics) that permits user-selectable generation of droplets with known sizes and fall speeds. From these data, empirical estimates of disdrometer sizing and fall velocity bias and uncertainty can be determined. This, then, allows for a more reliable estimate of the fraction of non-terminal drops in natural rain and a more reliable assessment of the impact of non-terminal drizzle and rain drops in data derived from instruments that assume a specific drop size/fall-speed relationship.
Title: Revisiting nonterminal hydrometeors: Refining instrument uncertainty
Description:
The fall velocities of rain and drizzle drops are often assumed to be a deterministic function of their size.
These diameter-fall speed relationships are intrinsically assumed in the retrievals provided by some commercial rain measurement instruments (e.
g.
the Joss-Waldvogel Disdrometer (Distromet), Micro Rain Radar (METEK), and 1-Dimensional Video Disdrometer (Joanneum Research)).
Some disdrometers are capable of independently measuring droplet size and fall-speed and provide evidence that not all drops adhere to the assumed size/fall-speed relationship.
The ubiquity and magnitude of these deviations are still an area of some debate; clear identification of drizzle and rain drops falling at speeds different than their expected terminal fall velocities is muddied by conservative estimates of disdrometer resolution and performance.
For a long time the bulk of observed non-terminal drop fall speeds were assumed to be instrumental artifacts and, even now, most investigators conclude drops falling at non-terminal speeds do not have a large impact on rain measurement science.
To date, uncertainties in disdrometer-derived drop sizes and fall speeds have usually been derived from the manufacturer estimates.
Here, we improve on these estimates by using a field calibration source (the new ``Large Drop Generator'' from Mesa Photonics) that permits user-selectable generation of droplets with known sizes and fall speeds.
From these data, empirical estimates of disdrometer sizing and fall velocity bias and uncertainty can be determined.
This, then, allows for a more reliable estimate of the fraction of non-terminal drops in natural rain and a more reliable assessment of the impact of non-terminal drizzle and rain drops in data derived from instruments that assume a specific drop size/fall-speed relationship.

Related Results

New Perspectives for 3D Visualization of Dynamic Reservoir Uncertainty
New Perspectives for 3D Visualization of Dynamic Reservoir Uncertainty
This reference is for an abstract only. A full paper was not submitted for this conference. Abstract 1 Int...
Progress Toward Addressing the Challenge of Mixed-phase Precipitation for the GPM Combined Algorithms 
Progress Toward Addressing the Challenge of Mixed-phase Precipitation for the GPM Combined Algorithms 
Available evidence indicates that accurate electromagnetic (EM) single scattering properties (SSPs) obtained from hydrometeors with realistic morphology are crucial for simulated s...
Reserves Uncertainty Calculation Accounting for Parameter Uncertainty
Reserves Uncertainty Calculation Accounting for Parameter Uncertainty
Abstract An important goal of geostatistical modeling is to assess output uncertainty after processing realizations through a transfer function, in particular, to...
The uncertainty–investment relationship: scrutinizing the role of firm size
The uncertainty–investment relationship: scrutinizing the role of firm size
PurposeThe objective of this paper is threefold. First, it aims to empirically study whether firm-specific/idiosyncratic uncertainty, macroeconomic/aggregate uncertainty and politi...
Multiband Simulations of Multistream Polarimetric Microwave Radiances Over Aspherical Hydrometeors
Multiband Simulations of Multistream Polarimetric Microwave Radiances Over Aspherical Hydrometeors
AbstractA numerical precision assessment and simulation results of the Unified Microwave Radiative Transfer (UMRT) model incorporating aspherical frozen hydrometeors based on the N...
Parameterization of Mean Terminal Velocity of Hydrometeors in Convective Clouds
Parameterization of Mean Terminal Velocity of Hydrometeors in Convective Clouds
The relationships between mean terminal velocity and volume mean diameter of different hydrometeors, as well as how they change with different background aerosol concentrations hav...
A lattice Boltzmann method to study light scattering by hydrometeors
A lattice Boltzmann method to study light scattering by hydrometeors
We present lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) for simulating light scattering by hydrometeors, addressing the limitations of existing techniques. The accurate modelling of light scatte...
Sampling Space of Uncertainty Through Stochastic Modelling of Geological Facies
Sampling Space of Uncertainty Through Stochastic Modelling of Geological Facies
Abstract The way the space of uncertainty should be sampled from reservoir models is an essential point for discussion that can have a major impact on the assessm...

Back to Top