Javascript must be enabled to continue!
David Hume’s Concept of Personal Identity: Perfect and Imperfect identity
View through CrossRef
The famous 18th centuries Scottish philosopher David Hume famously mentioned the “bundle theory” in the work “A Treatise of Human Nature” where he referred to identity as a bundle of different perceptions. We believe that personal identity is the sum of our experiences through which we perceive our own identity to be numerically the same through mental processes. But he clarifies that this is how we misinterpret “identity”, when in fact the analysis of “identity” is immutability and constancy over time. Hume defined “identity” based on this type of analysis, known as “perfect identity”. So, any “identity” of person or thing cannot be “perfect identity” because it changes over time, but Hume clarifies why we mistakenly think of ourselves as “the same” and “one” over time. He mentions various examples to explain personal identity such as vegetables, republic, river, church etc. Where he tries to make us clear that even though our mind perceives these as perfect over time, they are actually imperfect identities because they can never remain constant over time. But the question is, how do we interpret our identity by misconceptions and illusions? This question is truly arguable by Hume’s concept. However, the main purpose of this paper is to analyze how Hume explains “perfect” and “imperfect identity” in by the evaluations of his analysis of personal identity.
International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
Title: David Hume’s Concept of Personal Identity: Perfect and Imperfect identity
Description:
The famous 18th centuries Scottish philosopher David Hume famously mentioned the “bundle theory” in the work “A Treatise of Human Nature” where he referred to identity as a bundle of different perceptions.
We believe that personal identity is the sum of our experiences through which we perceive our own identity to be numerically the same through mental processes.
But he clarifies that this is how we misinterpret “identity”, when in fact the analysis of “identity” is immutability and constancy over time.
Hume defined “identity” based on this type of analysis, known as “perfect identity”.
So, any “identity” of person or thing cannot be “perfect identity” because it changes over time, but Hume clarifies why we mistakenly think of ourselves as “the same” and “one” over time.
He mentions various examples to explain personal identity such as vegetables, republic, river, church etc.
Where he tries to make us clear that even though our mind perceives these as perfect over time, they are actually imperfect identities because they can never remain constant over time.
But the question is, how do we interpret our identity by misconceptions and illusions? This question is truly arguable by Hume’s concept.
However, the main purpose of this paper is to analyze how Hume explains “perfect” and “imperfect identity” in by the evaluations of his analysis of personal identity.
Related Results
Hume's 'New Scene of Thought' and the Several Faces of David Hume in the Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion
Hume's 'New Scene of Thought' and the Several Faces of David Hume in the Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion
Hume's 'New Scene of Thought,' is a defense of Hume's philosophical principles in the Treatise of Human Nature. Nelson shows that Hume's new philosophy was a uniquely original and ...
Hume’s Political Thought
Hume’s Political Thought
David Hume (b. 1711–d. 1776) was one of the central figures of what we now commonly call the Scottish Enlightenment. He lived and wrote during a time when questions about Scotland’...
FILSAFAT EMPIRISME DAVID HUME
FILSAFAT EMPIRISME DAVID HUME
Tulisan ini membahas pemikiran David Hume tentang empirisme, Hume mengembangkan pandangan Hutcheson dan menggabungkan empirisme Locke dan Berkeleym. Menurut Hume bahwa pengetahuan ...
David Hume’s Epistemology and Its Contemporary Importance
David Hume’s Epistemology and Its Contemporary Importance
The paper is about some epistemological ideas of David Hume. At first, I give a review of his most influential epistemological conceptions: his exposition of the problem of inducti...
Hume on Personal Identity: Memory and Natural Relations
Hume on Personal Identity: Memory and Natural Relations
In 1739, David Hume revolutionized the notion of personal identity in his work “A Treatise of Human Nature.” He articulated some aspects of personal identity that we cannot easily ...
David Hume, Paternalist
David Hume, Paternalist
A standard worry about Hume’s account of justice is that it leaves those who are most vulnerable outside the circumstances of justice. An equally standard reply is that those who a...
David Hume
David Hume
This chapter presents Jean-Jacques Rousseau's letter to David Hume on July 10, 1766. In this letter, Rousseau provides a long explanation to Hume. He begins by declaring that “the ...
Hume’s Critics: Kames and Reid
Hume’s Critics: Kames and Reid
Abstract
Hume’s view of justice was criticized by three other notable Scottish philosophers, all of whom nevertheless recognized his pre-eminence as a thinker. Lord ...

