Coastal insect herbivore populations are strongly influenced by environmental variation

Abstract. Pissonotus quadripustulatus is a brachypterous planthopper that feeds on the clonal salt marsh plant, sea oxeye daisy, Borrichia frutescens. Asphondylia borrichiae is a macropterous gall fly that creates galls on the apical meristems. Most Borrichia occurs in isolated patches consisting of more than one genotype. Densities of Pissonotus and Asphondylia do not significantly differ within patches but they do differ between patches. I tried to find out why some patches of Borrichia support consistently higher densities of Pissonotus and Asphondylia than others. Reciprocal transplants of Borrichia between patches showed that for both Pissonotus and Asphondylia recipient site (local environment) had a strong effect on population densities. However, the best sites for Asphondylia were generally the worst sites for Pissonotus and vice versa. Donor site (local plant genotypes) was not significant for Pissonotus but was marginally significant for Asphondylia. However, for Asphondylia recipient site had a greater effect. Local plant genotype effects may be greater for gall‐forming insects, which tend to be specialists, than for more generalist sapsucking insects.